What was decided
The application is to be referred to the Secretary of State under the Town and Country Planning (Consultation) (England) Direction 2024, advising of the council's intention to grant permission, despite the Environment Agency's flood risk objection. Report P139, P140, P141
Delegated authority is granted to the Head of Development Control, in consultation with the Chair and/or Vice Chair and the proposer, to approve the report and full condition wording to be sent to the Secretary of State.
The vote was 8 in favour, 0 against and 1 not voting, against the officer recommendation to refuse. Report P1, P2, P3
Why
Officers recommended refusal because the site lies in Flood Zone 3b Functional Floodplain and the educational use is classified as More Vulnerable development, which Policy F6 of the NPPF and Annex F Table 3 say should be refused. Report P1, P2, 3.33, 3.34, 3.35, 3.36, 3.59
Officers also recommended refusal because no Ecological Impact Assessment, protected species surveys or Habitat Regulations Assessment information was submitted, contrary to Local Plan policies EN10, EN11, EN12, EN13 and EN15. Report P3, 3.80, 3.81, 3.82
Members chose to grant weight to the specialist SEND educational and community benefits, the limited scale of the use (6 to 12 pupils), term-time only operation, the school's proactive flood monitoring and the absence of recorded flooding since 2018. Report 3.24, 3.89, 3.90, 3.95, 3.96, 3.97, 3.50, 3.51, 3.52
What happens next
An Ecological Impact Assessment and Landscape and Ecological Management Plan must be submitted within six months, covering habitat assessment, protected species, habitat enhancement, bat commuting routes, management and monitoring.
A Flood Management Plan must be submitted within three months, including river level monitoring, trigger levels, flood warning arrangements, staff responsibilities, evacuation procedures, emergency contacts and annual review, plus resistance and resilience measures.
Conditions also require a Travel Plan for all staff and pupils within three months, surface water drainage details and maintenance, restriction of use to a satellite facility tied to the school, pupil number limits, school day hours only, removal of relevant permitted development rights, restriction on external lighting, and restriction on vegetation clearance.
Options considered
- Rejected: Refuse planning permission as recommended by officers due to flood risk and ecological information gaps. Members gave significant weight to the specialist SEND educational and social benefits and to the school's proactive flood management, and resolved instead to refer to the Secretary of State with an intention to grant Report P1, P2, P3, 3.89, 3.97, 3.98
- Chosen: Refer to Secretary of State under the 2024 Direction with intention to grant, subject to conditions. Committee considered the educational benefits and flood management evidence outweighed the policy conflict, and used delegated authority route because the application is contrary to the Environment Agency's objection Report P141
Implications
- Legal: Application must be referred to the Secretary of State because it is for development in Flood Zone 3b contrary to the Environment Agency's objection, under the Town and Country Planning (Consultation) (England) Direction 2024. Report P139, P140, P141
- Risk: Site lies in Flood Zone 3b Functional Floodplain of the River Lemon; Environment Agency maintains an in-principle objection that additional flood risk information cannot overcome. Report 3.28, 3.53, 3.54, 3.55, P140, P141
- Equalities: School provides specialist SEND education for up to 50 children and young people aged 8 to 18, with the Chipley Mill site supporting 6 to 12 pupils at a time; closure would affect existing pupils and a reported high level of unmet SEND need in Devon. Report 3.1, 3.24, 3.95, 3.96
- Other: A previous retrospective application (22/01348/FUL) was refused and the subsequent appeal (APP/P1133/W/24/3355745) was dismissed on 22 April 2025 on flood risk grounds; the planning inspector classified the use as More Vulnerable, not water-compatible. Report 3.9, 3.10, 3.11, 3.29
Who and where
- The Greater Horseshoe School and its pupils and staff Report 3.1, 3.24, 3.95
- Children and young people with SEND referred to or attending the school Report 3.95, 3.96
- Neighbouring residential properties (Chipley House and the former mill building) Report 3.4, 3.72, 3.73
- Environment Agency as statutory consultee Report 5.2, P139, P140, P141
- Devon County Council as Lead Local Flood Authority and Highway Authority Report 5.3, 5.4, P143, P144, P146, P147, P148
Timeline
- April 1996: Planning permission granted for an amenity building and access track under reference 96/02246/FUL Report 3.7
- September 2018: Site began operating as a satellite educational facility of The Greater Horseshoe School Report 3.5, 3.8, 3.15
- 7 July 2022: Retrospective application 22/01348/FUL submitted for change of use from agriculture to education (Class F1) Report 3.9
- 2 August 2024: Application 22/01348/FUL refused by the Local Planning Authority Report 3.9, 3.10
- 22 April 2025: Planning Inspectorate dismissed the appeal (APP/P1133/W/24/3355745) on flood risk grounds Report 3.11, 3.29
- 18 November 2025: Planning Committee deferred formal enforcement action and gave the school until 29 May 2026 to submit a further application Report 3.12, 3.13
- 28 July 2026: Letter received from the applicant's agent providing further submissions on planning balance and benefits Report 3.93
- 22 September 2026: Planning Committee resolved to refer the application to the Secretary of State with intention to grant, subject to conditions (8 for, 0 against, 1 not voting)
Plain English for the jargon
- Flood Zone 3b: Functional floodplain: land where water has to flow or be stored in times of flood, identified by the Environment Agency.
- More Vulnerable development: A planning classification for land uses such as educational establishments, which are more sensitive to flood risk than water-compatible uses.
- Sequential and Exception Tests: Tests in national flood risk policy used to steer development to lower risk areas and, where that is not possible, to demonstrate that development is safe and provides wider sustainability benefits.
- Town and Country Planning (Consultation) (England) Direction 2024: A statutory direction requiring local planning authorities to consult the Secretary of State before granting planning permission contrary to the Environment Agency's objection on flood risk grounds.
- Habitats Regulations Assessment: An assessment required where a plan or project may have a likely significant effect on a European protected site such as the South Hams Special Area of Conservation.
- PD rights (Permitted Development rights): National planning rules that allow certain changes, such as some new buildings, without needing a separate planning application.