Resolved That permission be refused for the following reason: 1. The application site currently consists of a mix of uses and buildings and has an industrial/agricultural appearance within a rural location currently undergoing significant planned change as part of the South West of Exeter Urban Extension. The application site is identified within the South West Exeter Development Framework (2014) as Development Plan Area E1 for Mixed Use development and Community Facilities and has outline planning permission granted for such a development. Whilst the need for electricity infrastructure to serve the new dwellings at South West Exeter is acknowledged it is considered that the proposed development on the application site would result in a large, overbearing and alien structure, ... view the full minutes text for item 16.
Word for word from the decision Teignbridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.teignbridge.gov.uk
1.1It is considered that the application merits oversight by the Planning Committee, taking into account the importance of the infrastructure for housing delivery in the South West Exeter allocation and HIF (Housing Infrastructure Fund) funding. In addition, Exminster Parish Council has requested the application be referred to the Planning Committee.
1.2A Planning Committee members’ site inspection took place on 15 February 2024.
1.3The application was previously before Members at the February 2024 Planning Committee but was deferred to allow for further consideration of matters raised by the applicant following the publication of the Committee Agenda. Osborne Clark LLP submitted a letter dated 15 February 2024 acting for National Grid Electricity Distribution in agreement with Devon County Council as the applicant. The letter raised a number of new matters in relation to the weight to be given to the National Policy Statements (NPS) for Energy dated November 2023, which came into force on 17 January 2024 including the introduction of a new Critical National Priority (CNP) for nationally significant low carbon infrastructure. The Letter states that National Grid and Devon County Council requested that the Secretary of State call-in the application for determination. Subsequent to this letter the application has not been called-in by the Secretary of State and remains with Teignbridge District Council for determination.
1.4EN-1 is the Overarching National Policy Statement for Energy and EN-5 is the National Policy Statement for Electricity Networks Infrastructure; the NPS are the primary policy for the Secretary of State decision making.
1.5The letter from Osborne Clarke states that the development is proposed to deliver a bulk supply point electricity substation to support the electrical demand of the city of Exeter and the surrounding area and the infrastructure is needed as a major reinforcement to serve both development growth and the increasing electrification of heat and transport in the area and that the development is of regional importance to the wider area and of national importance in that it supports the government’s statutory obligations to decarbonise energy networks. The letter states that there is an urgent need for new electricity network infrastructure to be brought forward at pace to meet the government’s energy objective and to provide resilience in the network to avoid the very real risk of supply interruptions (power cuts) and that there is a real risk during winter peaks as soon as 2027 based on the capacity constraints of the current network. The letter also sets out that the applicant considers the Critical National Priority policy to be material to the current application. Paragraph 4.1.7 of EN-1 states that where an NPS requires an applicant to mitigate a particular impact as far as possible but there would still be residual adverse effects after the implementation of such mitigation measures the Secretary of State should weigh those residual effects against the benefits of the proposed development and for projects that qualify as CNP Infrastructure, it is likely that the need case will outweigh the residual effects in all but the most exceptional cases.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.