That Cabinet receives the report and recommends that the coast protection option of the stepped revetment, rather than increased height to the promenade seafront wall adjacent to the Harbour is supported and recommended for funding. On the basis that a large sea wall in Central Margate would inhibit economic regeneration of the town centre.
Word for word from the decision Thanet published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thanet.gov.uk
Summary This report sets out progress made regarding a major scheme to protect Margate Old Town from coastal flooding, the report also recommends that the option of constructing a stepped revetment to reduce wave form and overtopping be supported.
For Decision
1.0Introduction and background
1.1It is has been understood that work is required to the Harbour Arm for the past few years. Technical work associated with the first Turner Contemporary design provided information about the structural integrity of the Harbour Arm.
1.2This was significant. Because the structure plays an important role, not just in protecting the Old Town from flooding, but also in terms of beach building. Without the Harbour Arm, Margate Beach would be far narrower and fully submerged at high tide.
1.3Cabinet supported a bid in 2006 to secure external funding, from the Environment Agency to carry out repairs to the Harbour Arm. Grant awards for eligible works are 100% funded. They may be considered match funding for other grant schemes.
2.0Current Position
2.1In 2009, the Council was awarded £98,000 grant to carry out a feasibility study. The aim of which was to quantify the problem and set out appropriate solutions.
2.2The funding enabled appointment of Consulting Engineers and production of two design options to protect against future flooding. Herrington Consulting was appointed. It being a practice with considerable coast protection and flood defence experience.
2.3Funding decisions are taken by the Environment Agency within the framework of a hierarchy of options;
• Do nothing • Do minimum works • Works to maintain existing structures • Work to sustain current standard of protection • Improve protection
Assessment of each potential scheme is made against the background of cost benefit analysis. With the typical intention to move to 1 in 200 year risk of flooding. Early calculations show that the cost benefit analysis in this particular case very strongly supports major investment in Margate. With current protection being around a 1 in 20 year standard of protection. Unsurprisingly then the analysis shows that improved protection is needed to Margate. Therefore, against a background of falling public sector spending, and increasing need for flood protection works elsewhere, the scheme for Margate is in a very favourable position to proceed. And rightly so.
2.4The two emergent engineering options for Margate are as follows;
Firstly, and most economically, a higher wall offering protection can be built along the vulnerable part of the seafront. This would be located in Zone F on a plan at annex 1, A typical section can also be seen in annex 3. This particular option has the disadvantage of providing a visual barrier from the seafront into the harbour and out to sea. Therefore, it may not be welcome by local business / residents and would not help regeneration and the local economy. The second option, as shown on the annex 1 drawing features a stepped revetment, such that views across the harbour are still possible with potential amenity use of the stepped revetment itself. Both schemes feature the same element of sheet piling and core grouting, with associated works to secure the future of the Harbour Arm. The opportunity was taken in December to report this subject to the Margate Renewal Partnership Board. At its meeting in December it had in attendance the Urban Design Panel. The unanimous recommendation from the Board and Urban Design Panel was for the second option, i.e. the stepped revetment.
2.5Funding in the sum of £4,000,000 has already been allocated for the scheme subject to technical approval. On the basis of further investigative and design work, this figure will increase in the next funding allocation round.
2.6Attached at annex 2 is a plan showing the proposed revetment in section.
3.0Issues
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
26/013 - Pride in Place Impact FundDecision Making Panel to include the MP’s representing the district and relevant Cabinet members; 5. To recommend to ...
Birchington Draft Neighbourhood PlanDecision Statement that the plan should proceed to a referendum. Councillor Kup spoke under Council Procedure Rule 20...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.