That the current project be cancelled, and the full proposals be put on hold until funding is available, utilising the capital allocation for other current projects with budget pressures. This would mean the Council would fail to deliver the proposed acoustic solution expected by the complainants. However, the continued rise in material and construction costs could have both significant financial and public perception implications on the Council by users who enjoy the open public amenity that has been provided. That no build be carried out until consultation with South West Water due to the site being in a critical flood risk area. In view of the severe financial constraints on the council’s budget, the whole project to be put on hold for 12 months and noise complaints continue to be monitored and dialogue maintained with the residents concerned. That the current project be cancelled, and the full proposals be put on hold until funding is available, utilising the capital allocation for other current projects with budget pressures. This would mean the Council would fail to deliver the proposed acoustic solution expected by the complainants. However, the continued rise in material and construction costs could have both significant financial and public perception implications on the Council by users who enjoy the open public amenity that has been provided. That no build be carried out until consultation with South West Water due to the site being in a critical flood risk area. In view of the severe financial constraints on the council’s budget, the whole project to be put on hold for 12 months and noise complaints continue to be monitored and dialogue maintained with the residents concerned. (Vote: For 8, Against 2, Abstentions 1)
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk
To update Members on the design, construction options and budget available for the installation of the acoustic screen to the perimeter of the skate park concrete plaza to obtain a decision on the most appropriate solution for the delivery of the screen.
1. INTRODUCTION
Members have previously allocated a capital budget for the installation of an acoustic screen to the western side of the concrete plaza of the Bideford Skate Park.
Original design options were developed in 2021 and orders were placed for the provision of a clear acrylic screen system in March 2022. The original system proposed is no longer available and the alternative systems identified are no longer deliverable within the original budget.
This report sets out the current status of the project, the options available and budget costs to enable a decision to be made on the most appropriate way forward for the installation.
2. REPORT
Bideford Skate Park was opened in July 2019 and is one of the Council’s most valued and popular recreational facilities.
Following a series of complaints from property owners in the vicinity, associated with the noise from the use of the Bideford Skate Park, and a subsequent Ombudsman review of the case an acoustic consultant was appointed to independently assess the noise transfer and significance for the neighbouring properties to the west of the concrete plaza. Recommendations for mitigation measures were provided and were developed into a design solution comprising the formation of a clear acoustic screen to wrap around the western end of the plaza.
The noise monitoring undertaken by the Environmental Health Officer as part of the response to the Ombudsman review concluded that the noise levels at the neighbouring properties does not surpass the threshold for statutory nuisance. However, it was agreed by Members to construct an acoustic barrier to mitigate the noise complaints from neighbouring properties. The original acoustic screen was designed to be 3m high to the entire western end of the plaza with returns to the north and south sides to reduce the breakout of noise from the plaza and enhance the overall structural integrity of the screen system. Following further negotiations between the acoustic consultant, RoSPA and the acoustic specialist appointed by the neighbouring property owners, the height of the screen was increased to 4m to further limit the transmission of noise to the upper parts of the neighbouring properties.
The design of the system solution comprises a series of metal posts with clear acoustically rated acrylic panels between the posts. An order was placed with a framework contractor for the supply and installation of the system in March 2022. Unfortunately, due to material shortages and supply challenges in Europe, the procurement of the specialist rated acrylic prevented the work from progressing within the original timeframes expected. As the supply difficulties continued prices increased with no certainty of a delivery to the UK to the point where the original system solution could no longer be delivered.
Alternative systems were considered to achieve the acoustic properties required without the use of acrylic sheets. An acoustically rated timber fencing system was identified as a suitable alternative, but the foundation design and installation costs for the timber system were not deliverable within the remaining budget available.
Further options have been considered comprising free standing pre-cast concrete wall panels, but the cost of these items can only be considered for a partial installation for the most significant western elevation of the concrete plaza to keep within the original budget.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Harbour Masters Quarterly ReportIt was agreed that future reports would state the quarterly period. When asked the Director of Communities & Place ad...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.