RESOLVED - ( i ) That the Executive Board decision of 14 July 2015 to develop an NPDO/Trust to manage Library Services, should not be implemented. (ii) That the proposal for the Council to retain the management of Heritage & Archives Services, Libraries and Community Resource Centres, as in-house services be supported. (iii) That the Head of Housing and Economy, in consultation with the Lead Member for People – Communities and Partnerships, be authorised to progress with development of a trust for the purposes of managing the newly established Peoples Market/Oriel Wrexham. Reason for decisions To safeguard the ongoing provision, future viability and sustainability of Library Services, Heritage and Archives and the Arts Service and ensure that services are delivered in the most cost-effective way and within an efficient management structure; and that appropriate and effective arrangements are in place to manage the Peoples Market/Oriel Wrecsam upon completion.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
To update Members of the outcome of a review into the proposed Wrexham Culture Trust and; for Members to consider and agree whether in view of this information to proceed with the development of a Wrexham Culture Trust for the future delivery of the Library, Museum and Archives Service.
Executive summary
2.1The future management of the Council’s Library Services, Heritage and Archives Service and the Arts Service has been subject to extensive review since 2013 and previous reports have been endorsed by the Executive Board.
2.2In July 2015, the Executive Board approved the principle of the Library Service in Wrexham becoming part of a new Non Profit Distributing Organisation (NPDO)/Trust (HCWD/13/15) with articles of association sufficiently broad enough to allow other services to join the trust in the future. Further to this decision in January 2016 (HAED06/16) the Executive Board approved the principle that the future delivery of Wrexham Heritage and Archives Service forms part of a new NPDO/Trust together with the Arts and Library Services and that the necessary steps should be taken to establish a Wrexham Trust. 2.3 Since January 2016 further work has been undertaken to interrogate the legal and financial implications of this decision to fully understand the processes that must be followed and the financial requirements of developing an independent body for this purpose.
2.4The procurement procedure for the proposed management of the Council’s Libraries and Heritage and Archives Services would be dealt with under the ‘Light Touch Regime’ of the Public Contracts Regulations 2015. As the value of the contract is above the threshold (currently £589,148) it will need to be advertised in order to seek tenders. As there is no power under the 2015 Regulations for a direct award of the contract to the new NPDO/Trust, there is a risk that the new NPDO/Trust loses out during the tender exercise. A procedure is available under the 2015 Regulations to ‘reserve’ a contract to qualifying organisations, such as mutuals or social enterprises (Regulation 77). However the contract would still need to be advertised as this Regulation does not permit direct award. Furthermore, under the provisions of Regulation 77, the contract may only be for a maximum period of 3 years and thereafter, the incumbent organisation is precluded from a further award of the contract if using the procedures under Regulation 77. The contracting authority could choose to run an open competition following the initial 3 year contract, which would allow the incumbent organisation to compete.
2.5A detailed review of the costs of establishing a new trust and a comparison of the costs of establishing a viable management structure comparing a trust model with a retained ‘in house’ model concluded that it is no longer more cost effective or more efficient to deliver the Library, Museum and Archives Services as part of a Wrexham Culture Trust. Table 1 in Section 4 of this report details the projected savings of a trust model together with the anticipated additional cost concluding that even the most efficient management structure would result in a trust costing £202,000 more per year than an in house model, as itemised in Table 1
2.6Taking into account the outcome of both the legal and financial review, it is felt no longer financially viable at this time to setup an independent NPDO/Trust to potentially deliver the Council’s Library, Heritage and Archives services and that the most cost-effective option at this point in time is to retain these services within the Council.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.