AI summaryWrexham Planning Committee defers Christmas Farm application for a site visit to consider highway and pedestrian safety, despite an officer recommendation to grant.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDeferredMembers to view site before determining application
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextSite visit to be arrangedApplication determined by Committee after visit
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
A site visit will be arranged for committee members before the application is determined.
The stated reason for the site visit is to consider highway and pedestrian safety.
Why
A local councillor raised concerns about highway and pedestrian safety, mirroring issues described in the earlier appeal inspector's report. Report P18, P19, P21
The previous application for the same use was refused and dismissed on appeal in part because of pedestrian safety concerns at the site access. Report P11, P34
The Highway Officer recommended conditions on opening hours to manage pedestrian safety given traffic speeds and lack of street lighting on the B5102. Report P25, P61
What happens next
Members of the Planning Committee will visit the application site at Christmas Farm, Llay Road, Cefn y Bedd. Report P3
Following the site visit, the Committee will determine the application at a future meeting.
Options considered
Rejected: Grant planning permission, as recommended by the Chief Officer Economy and Planning. Committee chose to defer and visit the site first Report P7
Chosen: Arrange a site visit for Members before determining the application. To consider highway and pedestrian safety
Implications
Risk: Pedestrian safety concerns remain on the B5102 due to traffic speeds and lack of street lighting; a protective barrier and opening-hour limits have been proposed as mitigation. Report P60, P61
Legal: The previous appeal (P/2022/0681) was dismissed on phosphorous loading and pedestrian safety grounds; this resubmission must address both. Report P11, P34
Environment and climate: Natural Resources Wales raised no objection subject to conditions on protected sites, species, and biosecurity; the site adjoins Blast Road Pond Local Wildlife Site and is near Llay Bog SSSI. Report P22, P64
Other: Officer concluded the scheme would not harm the River Dee SAC, in contrast with the previous appeal position. Report P34, P75, P76
Who and where
The applicant seeking a Christmas tree farm and outdoor recreation centre at Christmas Farm Report P3, P4
Neighbouring residents around Llay Road, Cefn y Bedd Report P51
Pedestrians, cyclists and motorists using the B5102 (Llay Road) Report P59, P60, P61
Visitors to the proposed reindeer centre, paddle boarding and water-based recreation Report P4, P10
TAN: Technical Advice Note issued by Welsh Government
NRW: Natural Resources Wales, the Welsh environmental regulator
SAB: Sustainable Drainage Systems Approval Body, which must approve surface water drainage separately
RAMs: Reasonable Avoidance Measures for protected species such as otters
GCN: Great Crested Newt, a European protected species
INNS: Invasive Non-Native Species
AMS: Arboricultural Method Statement, required to protect trees during construction
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item93
Resolved
RESOLVED – That a site visit be arranged for Members of the Committee to view the application site prior to determination of the application by the Committee. Reason for decision Reason for site visit: To consider highway and pedestrian safety.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
Description of Development NEWID DEFNYDD TIR AR GYFER EI DDEFNYDDIO FEL FFERM GOED NADOLIG A CHANOLFAN HAMDDEN AWYR AGORED I GYNNWYS CANOLFAN CEIRW, PADLFYRDDIO, GWEITHGAREDDAU DWR AC YMESTYN Y LLYN PRESENNOL, CREU LLWYBR RHISGL, CODI ADEILAD I DDARPARU SWYDDFA, STORFA PEIRIANNAU AC OFFER, STORFA WELLT A GOFOD BAE SALWCH/MAMOLAETH AR GYFER CEIRW A CHREU MAES PARCIO, MYNEDIAD A THIRLUNIO SAFLE / CHANGE OF USE OF LAND FOR USE AS CHRISTMAS TREE FARM AND OUTDOOR RECREATION CENTRE TO INCLUDE REINDEER CENTRE, PADDLE BOARDING, WATER RELATED ACTIVITIES AND EXTENSION OF EXISTING LAKE, CREATION OF BARK FOOTPATH, ERECTION OF BUILDING TO PROVIDE OFFICE, MACHINE AND EQUIPMENT STORE, HAY/STRAW STORAGE AND SICK BAY/MATERNITY BAY SPACE FOR REINDEER, AND CREATION OF CAR PARK, ACCESS AND SITE LANDSCAPING
Ward Llay/Llai
Community Llay/Llai
Recommendation Grant
Officer Report
Site Description The application site comprises approximately 16.6ha of agricultural land located to the south of the B5102 public highway (Llay Road) and to the east of Park Road. Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Proposal The application seeks consent for the change of use of land to a mixed use including a Christmas tree farm and outdoor recreation including the provision of a reindeer centre, paddle boarding, water related activities, engineering operations to extend the existing lake, creation of bark footpath, erection of a cedar clad agricultural building to provide office, machinery and equipment store, hay/straw storage, a sick bay and maternity bay for reindeer, the creation of a car park, the creation of a new access onto Llay Road and landscaping.
Site History P/2022/0681 - use of the site as a Christmas tree farm and outdoor recreation centre to include a ‘reindeer centre’, paddle boarding and water related activities. The application also proposed the erection of a building to provide an office, machine and equipment store, a hay/straw storage area and a sick/maternity bay for reindeer. Refused 06/11/2023 Appeal dismissed 03/12/2024.
Development Plan Wrexham Unitary Development Plan Outside of a defined settlement, policies PS2, PS8, PS11, GPD1, EC3, EC4, EC6, EC13, T8 and T9 are applicable Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Wrexham Local Planning Guidance Notes (LPGN) 7 – Landscape & Development 16 – Parking Standards 17 – Trees & Development 30 – Design 32 – Biodiversity & Development T2 – Active Travel
Relevant National Policy
National Planning Policy and Guidance Future Wales: The National Plan 2040 Planning Policy Wales, Edition 12 2024 (PPW)
Technical Advice Notes (TANs) TAN 5 – Nature Conservation & Planning TAN 6 – Planning for Sustainable Rural Communities TAN 11 – Noise TAN 12 – Design TAN 13 – Tourism TAN 16 – Sport, Recreation and Open Space TAN 18 – Transport
Consultation Responses Community Council: No response received.
Local Members: Cllr Apsley Concerned that this application is coming before the Planning Committee within four months of it being refused at appeal. Concerned as there is no specific policy in the LDP which covers this kind of development. The stagnant water is highly likely to be a health hazard to people like Paddle Boarders. Concerned with highway and pedestrian safety as described by the inspector's report.
The same concern is expressed on the drainage and biodiversity effects explained by the inspector's report.
Cllr Walsh
Resubmitted comments made in respect of the previous application. Support the application on the proviso that all highway/footway and ecological concerns are properly addressed through appropriate mitigation Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Natural Resources Wales: Consulted No objection subject to planning conditions relating to protected sites and protected species.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.