AI summaryWrexham planning committee grants retrospective permission for a mobile home at Borras, made personal to the applicant and dependants without a time limit, citing the Armed Forces Covenant.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedPermission made personal to applicant and dependants, no expiry date
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextBiodiversity scheme within 6 monthsSubmit net benefit to biodiversity scheme to local planning authority
Who it affectsApplicant and dependants only
What was decided
Permission was granted, made personal to the applicant and any resident dependants, with the mobile home to be removed permanently if they cease to occupy the land.
A scheme to deliver a net benefit to biodiversity must be submitted for written approval within six months of the decision, with a timetable for implementation.
The committee did not include the temporary two-year deadline (to 30 June 2028) that officers had recommended, granting a personal permission without a time limit. Report P106, P111, P112
Why
The applicant is an armed forces veteran who sustained life-changing injuries during operational service in Afghanistan, resulting in ongoing medical needs and a requirement for specially adapted accommodation. Report P88, P100
The council has a statutory duty under the Armed Forces Covenant to consider bespoke solutions for those who have sacrificed the most, and the applicant's personal circumstances were treated as a material planning consideration. Report P89, P90, P91, P96, P98
Officers had concluded that the development conflicts with UDP policies PS1 and H5 on housing in the countryside, that there is no essential rural enterprise need, and that the proximity to Borras Quarry raises concerns about noise, dust and impact on mineral extraction. Report P42, P48, P66, P80, P85
What happens next
A biodiversity net benefit scheme with an implementation timetable must be submitted for written approval within six months of the decision and retained for the lifetime of the development.
The applicant is advised as a note that the site is adjacent to Borras Quarry and that quarry working may give rise to noise and dust.
If the land ceases to be occupied by the applicant and dependants, the mobile home must be removed permanently from the land.
Options considered
Chosen: Grant personal planning permission with no time limit, plus a biodiversity condition (as decided by committee). Bespoke solution under the Armed Forces Covenant for a veteran with life-changing injuries, given the mobile home is already specially adapted. Report P88, P91, P96, P98, P106
Rejected: Grant a personal, temporary planning permission for two years expiring on 30 June 2028 (officer recommendation). The committee departed from this recommendation and did not include a time limit in the conditions imposed. Report P106, P111, P112
Rejected: Refuse planning permission. Refusal would not render the applicant homeless (three other dwellings on site) but the Covenant duty and personal circumstances outweighed the policy conflict for the committee. Report P99, P103, P108
Implications
Legal: Permission is personal to the named applicant and dependants and does not run with the land; the mobile home must be removed if they cease to occupy it.
Equalities: The decision treats the applicant's status as a wounded armed forces veteran and the Armed Forces Covenant as material considerations justifying a bespoke planning outcome despite policy conflict. Report P88, P90, P91, P96, P98
Other: The committee granted without the temporary time limit that officers recommended, accepting the personal circumstances argument more fully than the officer report. Report P106, P112
Other: Officers remain concerned that the mobile home is closer to the quarry than the other three dwellings and is not shown to provide acoustic or dust attenuation; no air quality assessment was provided. Report P82, P83, P84, P85
Risk: Breedon Quarry Group raised concerns that the red line includes land they own without being notified, and that the dwelling may restrict quarry operations and constrain mineral extraction. Report P38, P39, P40
Who and where
The applicant, a Royal Welsh Fusilier veteran with life-changing injuries, his partner and their young child, who currently occupy the mobile home Report P3, P88, P100
Breedon Quarry Group, operator of the adjacent Borras Quarry Report P38, P39, P40
Occupants of the three existing dwellings on the wider Moss Bank Farm site (farmhouse and two barn conversions let as holiday accommodation) Report P9, P12, P13, P44, P59
Gresford community and the Gresford East and West ward member Report P5, P6, P18, P19
Timeline
27.1.2020: Planning permission P/2019/0888 granted for two-storey extension, renovations and detached double garage at Moss Bank Farm farmhouse Report P12
16.12.2020: Planning permission P/2020/0463 granted for conversion of barn to dwelling and double garage Report P12
18.8.2021: Planning permission P/2021/0288 granted for conversion of barn to two dwellings and garage Report P13
2026-04-13: Planning Committee resolves to grant retrospective permission for the mobile home, personal to the applicant and dependants
Within six months of the decision: Net benefit to biodiversity scheme to be submitted for written approval of the Local Planning Authority
30 June 2028: Officer-recommended deadline for removal of the mobile home; not included in the committee's decision Report P112
Plain English for the jargon
UDP: Wrexham Unitary Development Plan, the adopted local development plan for the area.
PPW12: Planning Policy Wales (12th edition), the national planning policy document for Wales.
TAN6: Technical Advice Note 6: Planning for Sustainable Rural Communities, Welsh Government guidance on rural development.
MTAN1: Minerals Technical Advice Note 1, Welsh Government guidance on minerals planning.
NBB: Net Benefit to Biodiversity, an enhancement required by Planning Policy Wales paragraph 6.4.5.
RAMs: Reasonable Avoidance Measures, working methods to avoid harm to protected species such as great crested newts.
Armed Forces Covenant: A statutory duty on public bodies to have due regard to the needs of the armed forces community and to consider bespoke support for those who have sacrificed the most.
DMM: Development Management Manual, Welsh Government guidance on the handling of planning applications, including the treatment of personal circumstances.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item95
Resolved
RESOLVED – That permission be granted subject to the following conditions and advisory note: Condition 1 The use hereby permitted shall be limited to [name removed] and/or [name removed] and to any resident dependants. Reason: In recondition of the applicant's requirement for specially adapted accommodation and to ensure compliance with policies PS1 and H5 of the Wrexham Unitary Development Plan. Condition 2 When the land edged in red on the plan appended to this decision notice ceases to be occupied for residential purposes by [name removed] and/or [name removed], any mobile home shall be removed permanently from the land. Reason: In recondition of the applicant's requirement for specially adapted accommodation and to ensure compliance with policies PS1 and H5 of the Wrexham Unitary Development Plan. Condition 3 Within six months of the date of this decision a scheme to deliver a net benefit to biodiversity shall have been submitted for the written approval of the Local Planning Authority. The scheme shall include a timetable for its implementation. Biodiversity enhancement shall be implemented in accordance with the approved details and thereafter retained for the lifetime of the development. Reason: To secure a net benefit to biodiversity in accordance with Planning Policy Wales 12 paragraph 6.4.5. Note to applicant The site is adjacent to Borras Quarry. You are therefore advised that quarry working may give rise noise and dust.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
Description of Development NEWID DEFNYDD TIR O AMAETHYDDOL I BRESWYL I GYNNWYS LLEOLI ANNEDD CARTREF SYMUDOL, DRAENIO, PARCIO, DREIF A MYNEDIAD / CHANGE OF USE OF LAND FROM AGRICULTURAL TO RESIDENTIAL TO INCLUDE SITING OF MOBILE HOME DWELLING, DRAINAGE, PARKING, DRIVEWAY AND ACCESS
Ward Gresford East and West/Dwyrain a Gorllewin Gresffordd
Community Gresford/Gresffordd
Recommendation Grant for a temporary period. Permission made personal to the applicant.
Officer Report
Site Description Moss Bank Farm is on the north-western side of Borras Road. The mobile home is located to the rear of an existing complex of buildings that include a farmhouse, a brick barn that has been converted to residential use, and a Dutch barn. The site is situated in open countryside. Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Proposal The application seeks retrospective planning permission for the change of use of land for the siting of a mobile home, together with associated drainage parking, driveway and access.
Reason for Committee Determination The development conflicts with policies in the adopted development plan regarding housing in the countryside.
Site History Moss Bank Farm (Main dwelling) P/2019/0888 TWO STOREY EXTENSION, RENOVATIONS AND ERECTION OF DETACHED DOUBLE GARAGE. Granted 27.1.2020 Moss Bank Farm (Barn) P/2020/0463 CONVERSION OF BARN TO DWELLING AND ERECTION OF DOUBLE GARAGE. Granted 16.12.2020
P/2021/0288 CONVERSION OF BARN TO 2 DWELLINGS AND ERECTION OF GARAGE. Granted 18.8.2021
P/2021/1110 DISCHARGE OF CONDITIONS 3 (MATERIALS) 7 (PAINT SAMPLE) 20 (ECOLOGY) AND 21 (DRAINAGE) OF PLANNING PERMISSION P/2021/0288. Approved 15.12.2021
Development Plan Unitary Development Plan UDP PS1 - The Broad Location Of Development UDP PS2 - The Broad Location of Development UDP Policy PS11 - Biodiversity UDP Policy EC4 - Hedgerows, Trees and Woodland UDP Policy EC1 - Green Barriers UDP Policy EC6 - Biodiversity Conservation Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
UDP Policy T8 - Parking UDP Policy MW11 - Minerals Buffer Zones UDP Policy H5 - Housing in the Countryside
Relevant National Policy Planning Policy Wales Technical Advice Note 6: Sustainable Rural Communities Future Wales
Consultation Responses Community Council: Considers that there should be a condition attached to any approval granted that this mobile home is only a dwelling for the current occupants.
Local Member: No comments or concern to raise.
Natural Resources Wales: Raises concerns about the application and advises that further information is required in respect of foul drainage.
Notes that the submitted Ecology Reports have identified Great Crested Newts are material to the application site. Consider the reports provide an adequate basis upon which to consider the potential impacts of the development. Recommends the reports should be listed in the 'approved plans' planning condition.
Dwr Cymru Welsh Water: Recommends that as the proposals intends to use alternatives to mains drains, advice sought from NRW.
Highway Officer: Notes the site has two accesses. Also notes the proposed block plan indicates visibility splays based on an assumed 40mph speed limit. Advises this is acceptable subject to confirmation of actual vehicle speeds and the implementation of hedgerow removal.
Confirms the parking and turning arrangements comply with local standards.
Comments that the lodge replaces a previous static caravan and is occupied by the applicant and his family and that it is not expected to result in a material increase in traffic generation, noting that the seasonal nature of the adjacent holiday lets and the low density of development accords the wider site mitigates cumulative impacts.
Contaminated Land Officer: No comments.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.