CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Wrexham County Borough Council
Planning Committee, Monday 6 July 2026 at 4.00pm

Information Report - Phosphorus Update

Noted Planning 1 paper

AI summaryWrexham Planning Committee notes report finding Lower Dee phosphorus levels are within target when Environment Agency data is included, clearing the way to resume deciding held planning applications.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedNo decision required, information only
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextFurther information report on application prioritiesDevelopment Management backlog to be addressed
Who it affectsLower Dee catchment planning applicantsSettments served by listed waste-water treatment works

What was decided

The committee noted the information report on phosphorus compliance and its implications for development in the Lower Dee catchment. Report 3.1

Why

Natural Resources Wales assessed the Lower Dee as failing its 50 µg/l phosphorus target at 56.5 µg/l, but this was driven by a single outlier sample of approximately 335 µg/l, giving NRW a low confidence rating. Report 2.1, 2.5, 2.6, 2.7

An independent review found that when Environment Agency data (97 datasets, 2018 to 2026) is combined with NRW data and analysed using NRW's approach, the Lower Dee remains below the 50 µg/l threshold. Report 2.10, 2.12, 2.13, 2.14

Counsel advised that the council may lawfully rely on the combined EA and NRW data when determining planning applications, provided it is transparent, rational and properly weighs NRW's evidence. Report 2.17, 2.18

What happens next

Planning applications currently held in abeyance can be processed, with each assessed through a case-by-case Appropriate Assessment that explains why the proposal does not adversely affect the River Dee and Bala Lake SAC. Report 2.20, 2.21, 2.25

NRW will be consulted on each Appropriate Assessment in the Lower Dee and its views taken into account before a decision is made. Report 2.23, 2.28

A further information report will set out how the Development Management team will prioritise the backlog of applications given limited staffing resources. Report 2.26

Options considered

  • Chosen: Rely on combined NRW and Environment Agency phosphorus data for planning decisions in the Lower Dee. Counsel advice confirms this is lawful; evidence shows the waterbody passes the 50 µg/l target when the full dataset is used Report 2.17, 2.18, 2.20
  • Rejected: Continue to refuse or delay all new housing and employment applications in the Lower Dee on phosphorus grounds. Combined evidence indicates the SAC is not at risk of failing its phosphorus target Report 2.4, 2.14, 2.15, 2.25
  • Rejected: Apply the new approach to catchments upstream of the Lower Dee (for example Cefn Mawr or the Ceiriog). The report states there is no change in approach upstream, where nutrient neutrality continues to be required Report 2.27

Implications

  • Legal: Council must still carry out a transparent, evidence-based Appropriate Assessment for each application and give proper weight to NRW's evidence under the Habitats Regulations. Report 2.18, 2.21, 2.24
  • Legal: The position must be kept under review as new monitoring data becomes available, and refusal of planning permission remains an option if new evidence shows adverse effects. Report 2.18, 2.22
  • Environment and climate: If a proposal alone or in combination with others could have a significant impact, this would be material to decision making and could still result in refusal. Report 2.22
  • Staffing: The Development Management team faces a backlog and limited resources, requiring prioritisation of applications; a further report on this will follow. Report 2.26
  • Risk: NRW has not challenged the substantive arguments but says there is no scope to alter the 2024 assessment; EA data can be considered in the 2027 review. Report 2.30

Who and where

  • Applicants for net new housing and employment in the Lower Dee catchment, including settlements such as Wrexham, Chirk, Ruabon, Coedpoeth, Rhos, Gwersyllt, Gresford, Rossett, Marford and Holt (see Appendix 1 for the full list) Report P42, P43, 2.25, 2.27
  • Applicants for development upstream of the Lower Dee (for example Cefn Mawr or the Ceiriog), for whom the existing nutrient neutrality requirement continues to apply Report 2.27
  • Natural Resources Wales, which will be consulted on each Appropriate Assessment Report 2.23, 2.28
  • Wrexham Council's Development Management team, which will need to prioritise a backlog of held applications Report 2.26

Timeline

  • 2020 to 2024: NRW compliance data for this period shows the Lower Dee not meeting its phosphorus target Report 2.1
  • March 2025: NRW published data classifying the Lower Dee as failing the 50 µg/l phosphorus target with low confidence Report 2.5
  • 2018 to 2026: Combined Environment Agency monitoring recorded 97 datasets at the Farndon Bridge location
  • 2027: Next NRW review, in which EA data can be considered Report 2.30

Plain English for the jargon

  • SAC: Special Area of Conservation, a European protected habitat site.
  • NRW: Natural Resources Wales, the Welsh environmental regulator.
  • EA: Environment Agency, the English environmental regulator, which monitors the River Dee at Farndon Bridge.
  • Lower Dee: The downstream section of the River Dee and Bala Lake Special Area of Conservation.
  • Phosphorus target: A water quality limit of 50 µg/l (micrograms per litre) set for the protected waterbody.
  • Eutrophication: Excessive algal growth caused by elevated nutrient levels that can harm water quality and biodiversity.
  • Nutrient neutrality: A development approach ensuring a project adds no net increase in nutrients to a protected waterbody.
  • Appropriate Assessment: A case-by-case Habitats Regulations assessment of whether a plan or project would adversely affect a protected site.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item12

Resolved

RESOLVED – That the report be noted.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Wrexham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Purpose of the report

2.0INFORMATION

Lower Dee Phosphorus Compliance and Implications for Development

Current Compliance Position

2.1According to compliance data published by Natural Resources Wales (NRW) for the period 2020–2024, the Lower Dee waterbody is not meeting its phosphorus (P) conservation target. The recorded concentration was 56.5 exceeding the target threshold of 50 µg/l (micro-grams per litre).

2.2Elevated nutrient levels, particularly phosphorus and nitrogen, can lead to excessive algal growth in freshwater environments. This process, known as eutrophication, can degrade water quality and harm biodiversity within protected habitats.

2.3New development, including housing, new employment and agricultural schemes, can increase nutrient inputs through wastewater discharges, surface water runoff and diffuse pollution. Where a protected site is already failing its conservation targets, any additional nutrient loading may adversely affect the integrity of the site.

2.4The Lower Dee forms the downstream section of the River Dee and Bala Lake Special Area of Conservation (SAC). In the absence of evidence demonstrating that a development proposal would not adversely affect the SAC, the Local Planning Authority have been refusing planning permission or delaying determination of applications.

Review of Compliance Data

2.5In March 2025, NRW published data indicating that the Lower Dee exceeded the phosphorus target of 50 µg/l and was therefore classified as failing.

2.6However, NRW assigned a low confidence rating to this assessment. The classification was heavily influenced by a single outlier sample result of approximately 335 µg/l, which is approximately three times as high as the next available outlier and ten times as high as the average results from other recordings.

2.7Although NRW considers the result technically valid and has no basis for excluding it, its exceptional nature significantly influenced the overall average and contributed to the failing classification. This unusual result is the primary reason NRW expressed low confidence in the assessment.

2.8Correspondence with the Welsh Government indicates that diffuse rural pollution i.e. from non-specific sources such as field run-off, are the most likely explanation for the phosphorus spike. The sample was taken during increasing river flows associated with snowmelt following a period of dry weather, conditions that can wash nutrients from land. Continuous and intermittent sewage discharges will also have contributed to overall phosphorus levels and the 2024 compliance outcome. Although Welsh government were not explicit, it is implicit the sample was not likely to be caused by discharges from a wastewater treatment works.

2.9While the outlier result cannot be ignored, understanding its context is important for assessing the true condition of the waterbody and the impact of development. To provide additional evidence, Wrexham Council commissioned an independent review of the available phosphorus monitoring data.

Evidence Review

2.10NRW’s compliance assessment only considered a limited dataset of samples, those taken by NRW. However, because the River Dee crosses the England– Wales border, the review considered monitoring data and assessment methodologies used by both NRW and the Environment Agency (EA). 2.11 NRW took 13 samples over 3 years (2021-2023), a reduction from the 60 samples taken for the period 2017-2019. The consultants we engaged discovered the EA utilise the same monitoring location (Farndon Bridge) and used the same methodologies for phosphorus recording and data analysis as NRW and had a data set of 36 across the same time period 1 as NRW, with a total of 97 data sets recorded between 2018 and 2026.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Information Report: Phosphorus UpdateReport 128 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

12 of 20 attended
BA
Councillor Bryan ApsleyCommittee Member, present, as expected, virtual
TB
Councillor Trevor BatesCommittee Member, present, as expected, virtual
ID
Councillor I David Bithell MBECommittee Member, present
BB
Councillor Beryl BlackmoreCommittee Member, absent
AD
Councillor Annette DaviesVice-Chair, apologies
FH
Councillor Frank HemmingsCommittee Member, present
SJ
Councillor Steve Joe JonesCommittee Member, present
JM
Councillor John McCuskerCommittee Member, present
MM
Councillor Michael MorrisChair, present
JN
Councillor Jeremy NewtonCommittee Member, present, as expected, virtual
JP
Councillor John PhillipsCommittee Member, present
RR
Councillor Rondo RobertsCommittee Member, present, as expected, virtual

All 20 on the meeting page

More from Wrexham Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
7 Sep 2026 Confirmation of MinutesRESOLVED – That the Minutes of the Meeting held on 27 July 2026 be signed as a correct record. Decided Open
7 Sep 2026 Application No: P/2025/0573 - Car Park, Tesco Stores Limited, Crescent Road, Wrexham, LL13 8HFRESOLVED – That planning permission be refused. Reason for decision (i) The proposal would introduce an additional ho... Refused Open
7 Sep 2026 Variation in Order of AgendaRESOLVED – That Agenda Item 4c – P/2026/0364 – Colliers Park, Wrexham AFC Training Ground, Chester Road, Gresford, Wr... Decided Open
7 Sep 2026 Application No: P/2026/0364 - Colliers Park, Wrexham AFC Training Ground, Chester Road, Gresford, Wrexham, LL12 8PWRESOLVED – That consideration of the application be deferred. Reason for decision To request the applicant to provide... Deferred Open
7 Sep 2026 Application No: P/2026/0174 - First and Second Floor Flat, 36 Brook Street, Wrexham, LL13 7LLRESOLVED – That planning permission be refused. Reasons for decision (i) The development will result in an overconcen... Refused Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies