That Members recommended Cabinet to: Approve Option 1 and reduce the affordable housing target for rural sites between 2 and 15 units in line with the Councils evidence base (targets identified in Table 2 of this report), until such a time as it is superseded by the adopted Local Development Framework Core Strategy. REASON: This will ensure that the interim approach is consistent and in line with the Councils own approved evidence base (Affordable Housing Viability Study). It will also publically reduce the affordable housing requirement to a level that has proven achievable through recent planning applications and discussions.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. A report on a proposed interim approach to affordable housing was considered by the Council’s Executive on 14th December 2010. This endorsed the reduced affordable housing targets in line with the Fordham’s Affordable Housing Viability Study (AHVS, July 2010), as amended following consultation with the York Property Forum and Developers, as an interim measure in advance of the LDF Core Strategy examination in 2012. The AHVS has previously been adopted as part of the LDF evidence base.
2. However, whilst Members approved the recommendation, the minutes exempted the reduction of the rural affordable housing target on sites between 2 and 15 homes from the interim approach. This resulted in an affordable housing target of 25% on brownfield and 35% on Greenfield sites on urban and rural developments above 15 units, but retained a 50% target on rural sites between 2 and 15 homes. This report seeks to clarify and amend this anomaly, reducing the rural target in-line with the study recommendations and current interim approach for sites above 15 homes.
Background
3. The LDF Working Group considered the findings of the Affordable Housing Viability Study, conducted by Fordham Research and dated July 2010, at the meeting of 5th July 2010. The study is an LDF evidence base for setting affordable housing targets and the thresholds which trigger the requirement and will support the LDF affordable housing policy. 4. The AHVS provides the levels of affordable housing at which the majority of sites will be viable, based on a detailed assessment of viability on a range of types of site in York. The targets are linked to a dynamic viability model which enables them to be updated on an annual basis so they align with market conditions. The review mechanism is based on house prices, build costs and alternative use values of land. Sensitivity testing of the Dynamic Model matrices is currently being undertaken in preparation of re-running the model following adoption as part of the LDF Core Strategy.
5. In following this methodology the study has identified the realistic and appropriate level of affordable housing that is viable in York, as set out in Table 1 below. The targets set out will be linked to the dynamic viability model in order to ensure accuracy over time:
Table 1 – Recommended targets for adoption through LDF Nature of target Urban/Rural Target Short term targets (Target 1): Broad-brush (brownfield) PPS3 target 25% on sites of 15+ dwellings Greenfield target on sites of 15+ 35% dwellings Sites 11-14 dwellings 25% Sites 5-10 dwellings 20% Off-site financial Sites of 2-4 dwellings contribution Long term need requirement target (Target 2): 50% Plan-long and including grant expectations
6. There is a recognition that the generally higher costs associated with brownfield development will lead to lower affordable targets than greenfield, and also that smaller sites will generally be less viable than larger ones. However, the study recommends abolishing the current distinction between urban and rural areas as it concludes that the targets are viable in all locations. This will mean that, once the LDF is adopted, all sites of 2 homes and above would contribute to affordable housing at the levels identified in Table 1.
7. Given the findings of the AHVS, Officers considered it would be inappropriate to continue to pursue a 50% affordable housing target when the Council’s own LDF evidence base concluded that this percentage was currently unviable. Consequently officers tabled a report proposing that the recommendations of the AHVS were adopted as an interim approach in advance of adoption through the LDF.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.