CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Executive, Tuesday 15 May 2012 at 5.30pm

Exploring Opportunities for the Future of the Guildhall

Agreed Executive 3 papers

Executive agreed this item on Tuesday 15 May 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item144

Resolved

That Cabinet agree option 1 as set out in the report, to proceed with an RIBA Open Ideas Competition. REASON: To facilitate the exploration of options for the future of the Guildhall in an innovative and cost effective way – that will generate publicity for the City and the site; facilitate a level of consultation and with the potential for securing interest in progressing a solution. That Cabinet agree option 1 as set out in the report, to proceed with an RIBA Open Ideas Competition. 1. REASON: To facilitate the exploration of options for the future of the Guildhall in an innovative and cost effective way – that will generate publicity for the City and the site; facilitate a level of consultation and with the potential for securing interest in progressing a solution.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Summary

1. The purpose of this report is to :

• provide Cabinet with a summary of the recent options appraisal and heritage significance / views analysis study undertaken for the Guildhall complex – the complete reports are available (in the members library and on line with this report)

• confirm Cabinet support for running a Royal Institute of British Architects RIBA Open Ideas Competition where the timetable would see the results available in December 2012 to coincide with the first moves in the new council office.

Background 2. Cabinet resolved on 4 December 2011 to minimise the council’s future use of the Guildhall and authorised the director of City Strategy to investigate options for the future of the Guildhall.

3. This generated some debate in The Press (30/1/12) which necessarily confirmed the strength of local feeling about this important and historic public building in the City.

4. Following a tender exercise in autumn 2011, architects Purcell Miller Triton PMT were commissioned to undertake an assessment of heritage significance, a views analysis and an informed options appraisal of the Guildhall complex*. The study was funded by Yorkshire Forward, English Heritage and CYC and has delivered on the brief objectives – setting out : • The Heritage Significance of the Guildhall Complex • A views analysis with respect to the Guildhall’s location on the Riverside. • An options appraisal highlighting opportunities for possible future uses / configurations.

5. *For the purposes of the study we defined the Guildhall complex as :

• The Guildhall itself (the medieval Hall) • The Council Chamber, committee rooms and ancillary offices • The C20th office annex and hutments. • The surrounding spaces including the Guildhall Yard and the Riverside.

6. The Guildhall and associated riverside committee rooms are listed grade I and the council chamber and associated offices are listed grade II.

7. The headline findings :

• Overall the fabric of the buildings is of national significance, but the Guildhall itself was extensively re-built post-war following the bomb damage so it is not a pristine medieval guildhall. • The complex has very high communal value and significance reflecting its integral role in the History of the City. • The Guildhall is an important part of the York Riverside and is seen in views from City Bridges and across / along the river. • There are some genuinely exciting opportunities and possibilities for creative re-use and the potential for redevelopment of parts of the site where there are lower levels of heritage significance in the existing fabric. Summary of Key Issues 8. Planning for the future of the Guildhall complex is critical for the council where the costs of continuing to operate the buildings are significant, and where the future use options for the majority of the office floorspace and the intensity of use of meeting rooms beyond the move the new HQ are uncertain.

9. The ‘do nothing option’ simply does not exist, because of the future cost to the council and the need to secure beneficial use for this key heritage asset and to ensure that there is no longer term deterioration in condition.

10. The council must therefore plan pro-actively to secure the future of the complex. The relationship with the Mansion House is recognised and has been integral to the options appraisal study.

11. Where ‘the guildhall’ is actually a complex of buildings the options appraisal clearly splits the guildhall complex into 4 elements :

• The Guildhall itself (the medieval Hall) • The Council chamber, committee rooms and ancillary offices • The C20th office annex and hutments. • The surrounding spaces including Guildhall Yard and the Riverside.

12. The study highlights the strengths and weakness of each aspect

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Exploring Opportunities for the Future of the GuildhallReport 118 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
RIBA Open Ideas format for cab report inc timetableReport 156 KB Download
PDF
York Guildhall Options Appraisal 24.02.12Report 5.2 MB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 18 attended
JA
Councillor James AlexanderChair, present
SC
Councillor Sonja CrispCommittee Member, apologies
SF
Councillor Sandy FraserCommittee Member, present
JG
Councillor Julie GunnellCommittee Member, present
JL
Councillor Janet LookerCommittee Member, present
DM
Councillor Dave MerrettCommittee Member, present
TS
Councillor Tracey Simpson-LaingVice-Chair, present
DW
Councillor Dafydd WilliamsCommittee Member, present
CR
Councillor Carol RuncimanAttendee, in attendance
MW
Councillor Mark WartersAttendee, in attendance
KA
Councillor Keith AspdenAttendee, in attendance
IC
Councillor Ian CuthbertsonAttendee, in attendance

All 18 on the meeting page

More from York Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Nov 2026 Minutes (4:46pm)That the Minutes of the Executive meeting held on 6 October 2026 be approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Capital Programme Monitor Update 2 Report (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. In relation to the overall programme: · Recommended to Full Council the adj... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Q2 2026-27 Finance and Performance Monitor (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. Noted the finance and performance information. ii. Noted that work will con... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Treasury Management Quarter 2 Prudential Indicators (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Noted the 2026/27 Treasury Management activity up to the period ending 30th ... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Medium Term Financial Strategy Update (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Agreed the Medium Term Financial Strategy as outlined in this report · In re... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies