That Cabinet agree Option 1 to release funding from capital contingency to undertake the physical works arising from the recommendation from the RoSPA report as outlined in paragraph 7, of the report, under the headings Provision of Rescue Equipment and Public realm design, including edge protection and physical barrier. Reason: To ensure that the council’s river safety measures are up to date and reduce the potential for harm associated with river incidents. That Cabinet agree Option 1 to release funding from capital contingency to undertake the physical works arising from the recommendation from the RoSPA report as outlined in paragraph 7, of the report, under the headings Provision of Rescue Equipment and Public realm design, including edge protection and physical barrier. 1. Reason: To ensure that the council’s river safety measures are up to date and reduce the potential for harm associated with river incidents.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Page 1 04Sept 14 | v3 | Final RoSPA would like to thank the numerous volunteers, council officers and elected members, emergency services, companies and staff whom work alongside the rivers, for their time, insight and assistance.
Page 2 04Sept 14 | v3 | Final Table of Contents
Executive Summary 4 Introduction and Terms of Reference 5 Methodology and Sources of Data 6 Results 7 …York, demography, river and existing practice 7 … Community level risks 8 … Fatal and critical near miss drowning events 9 … Observations on identified cases 14 … Findings from other reports 18 … Stakeholder discussions 21 … Site review findings 24 Discussion 26 Conclusions 28 Recommendations 29
Annex Site assessment findings 33-69 Incident map 2009 to mid 2014 70 Assessment score map 71 Unintentional injury profile for York 72
Issue Date Originator Reviewer Authority Details 1 14/06/14 ND DW RoSPA Draft for comment 2 18/07/14 DW ND RoSPA - 3 04/09/14 DW ND RoSPA Structure and reflect w/g feedback
Page 3 04Sept 14 | v3 | Final Executive Summary RoSPA were engaged by City of York Council to conduct an inland water safety review. The overall aim of the review was to identify any areas where physical controls need to be changed to meet current safety expectations and to identify any overall management arrangements that need to be implemented to maintain an acceptable level of public safety across the Councils’ portfolio.
In order to complete the review, a RoSPA consultant visited the Rivers Ouse and Foss in addition to a number of ponds across the city centre. Following the visit, water related injury data was compiled from various sources and a consultation programme was conducted with stakeholders.
Overall we found numerous low level slip/trip/fall features that increase the likelihood of a fall into water. The activities of people around the water increase the risk of accidental slipping tripping and intentional entry into the rivers. Further, to this, at many locations, self rescue is expected to be difficult.
The fatality rate along the city centre stretch reflects the conditions; our information shows that over the past five years there has, on average, been a serious incident every three months. Due to a mixture of rescues and good fortune, not all of these incidents have resulted in deaths. However, the drowning/submersion deaths rates for York are over three times the regional and national average.
We believe that there are multiple opportunities to reduce the likelihood of future fatalities. Our recommendations cover a number of common themes:
Leadership and coordination The Council need to establish a clear water safety policy which takes into account the needs of all stakeholders. The policy should include waterfront developments, edge protection, rescue arrangements, education of high risk groups (see below) and monitoring of physical assets. That every effort should be made to ensure both prevention efforts and emergency response is coordinated.
Education and campaigns Refresh and renew the community safety work that has been delivered in the past, including supporting and encouraging the community groups that have voiced interested and involvement in developing water safety in the region.
Physical improvements and design Renew and repair the physical aspects identified, including post and chain fencing Renew and repair signage and life rings along both rivers. Ensure that the emergency services can access all river areas quickly on the water,
It should be noted that the swift response and good actions of the rescue emergency services and staff/public that work, live and enjoy the waterfront have saved several lives in the city. These are all highly commendable - their local knowledge and efforts should be built upon to limit future preventable harm.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.