CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Executive, Tuesday 7 October 2014 at 5.30pm

The Punch Bowl Public House, Lowther Street, York - Article 4 Direction

Decided Executive 6 papers

Executive decided this item on Tuesday 7 October 2014. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item50

Resolved

( i ) That, as a matter of urgency, the Director of City and Environmental Services and the Director of Customer and Business Support Services be requested to further investigate options in relation to the request for action to preserve the Punch Bowl public house, Lowther Street, York as a public house; (ii) That the Cabinet Members for Environmental Services, Planning and Sustainability and Finance and Performance, each be asked to consider the options identified by the Directors under ( i ) above and, if satisfied that action is justified, to take such action under his delegated powers. (iii) To confirm the delegation of powers to the Cabinet Member for Environmental Services, Planning and Sustainability to make an Article 4 direction to remove permitted development rights for the change of use of The Punch Bowl public house, Lowther Street, York from its existing use as a public house (Class A4) to a shop (Class A1) if satisfied that sufficient evidence exists to justify the making of such a Direction. (iv) That Officers be requested to bring a report back to a future Cabinet meeting outlining a long term strategy to assist with similar future requests. Reason: In order to allow further work to evidence if exceptional circumstances exist to show that a change of use would harm the amenity or the proper planning of the area, and whether there is a need to remove permitted development rights for the change of use of The Punch Bowl public house, Lowther Street, York from its existing use as a public house (Class A4) to a shop (Class A1) by the making of an Article 4 Direction. (i) That, as a matter of urgency, the Director of City and Environmental Services and the Director of Customer and Business Support Services be requested to further investigate options in relation to the request for action to preserve the Punch Bowl public house, Lowther Street, York as a public house; (ii) That the Cabinet Members for Environmental Services, Planning and Sustainability and Finance and Performance, each be asked to consider the options identified by the Directors under (i) above and, if satisfied that action is justified, to take such action under his delegated powers. 1. (iii) To confirm the ... view the full minutes text for item 50.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive, 23 pages

Planning Services

Interim Planning Policy Guidance on The Protection of Public Houses in the City of Cambridge

October 2012

Cambridge City Council Contents

Section Page

1. Introduction 4 Scope and Purpose 4 Status of the IPPG 4 Process of Preparation 5 2. Context 5 Area covered by this IPPG 5 Planning Policy Context 5 Need for the IPPG 8 3. The Importance of the Public House 9 4. Development Management Principles 10 Proposals affecting properties currently or last used as a Class 10 A4 public house Proposals affecting other Class A uses which were previously in 12 a Class A4 pub use Proposals for new Public Houses (A4 uses) 13 Proposals affecting pub gardens and car parks 13 5. List of Safeguarded Existing and Former Pub Sites 15 6. Glossary 18 7. Background Documents 21

Annexes

1 – Marketing Strategies 22 2 - Viability Appraisals 24 3 - Community Catchments and Consultation 26

-2- 1. INTRODUCTION

Scope and Purpose of this Guidance

1.1In recent years more than twenty pubs in Cambridge have been lost to alternative uses, most commonly for residential development or conversion to restaurants or have simply closed and are currently vacant. A number of factors can be cited and attributed to the decline in public houses. These include competition from supermarket discounting of alcohol, changes to people’s drinking habits, a ban on smoking in public areas, pressure to realise higher value housing development and the ability of public houses to change use to restaurants without the need for planning permission.

1.2Many public houses occupy large plots and have capacity for several dwellings to be built on site or for conversion to apartments, making them attractive residential development investments. In a declining market, some breweries and pub companies have sought to take poor performing pubs out of the pub market (providing a better market for the remaining pubs in their portfolio) and realise their alternative use value. However, some closed public houses may still be commercially viable if managed by a different pub company or under a different system (e.g. as free houses).

1.3Public houses can play a crucial social role in supporting local community interaction and activities to help maintain sustainable neighbourhoods; an economic role in contributing to the vibrancy and vitality shopping and commercial areas; and an environmental role in their intrinsic value to the cultural and historic heritage of local areas. This is reflected by the recent National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), which encourages a positive approach towards the delivery and “use of community facilities (such as local shops, meeting places, …, public houses and places of worship) … to enhance the sustainability of communities and residential environments;” (NPPF, Para 70).

1.4This Interim Planning Policy Guidance (IPPG) addresses the current concerns raised by local community groups to guide the protection of public houses in Cambridge. The IPPG therefore provides a supplement to the ‘saved’ policies in the Cambridge Local Plan (2006). The IPPG will be a material consideration in determining any planning applications for existing public houses in the City of Cambridge district.

Status of the IPPG

1.5The plan led system would normally require a revised statutory planning policy to be prepared where a new approach to development is proposed. However, in the context of current development trends and local public concerns, the Council has agreed that the most appropriate policy approach is to develop an IPPG and for this to broadly follow the same process to that of developing a Supplementary Planning Document or SPD (see section below). It is intended that the policy approach in this IPPG (and the accompanying evidence base) is incorporated into the Council’s forthcoming Local Plan Review at the earliest opportunity in order to provide a robust policy to protect public houses in the future.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Cambridge protection-of-public-houses-ippgReport 23 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
Cambridge-public-house-studyReport 78 pages Download
PDF
Local Government Information Unit: Public Houses BriefingReport 10 pages Download
PDF
Map -Punch BowlReport 1 pages Download
PDF
Punch Bowl application for Article 4 Direction: City of York CouncilReport 9 pages Download
PDF
The Punch Bowl Public House, Lowther Street, York: Article 4 DirectionReport 13 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 16 attended
JA
Councillor James AlexanderChair, present
SC
Councillor Sonja CrispCommittee Member, present
LC
Councillor Linsay Cunningham-CrossCommittee Member, present
DL
Councillor David LeveneCommittee Member, present
JL
Councillor Janet LookerCommittee Member, present
DM
Councillor Dave MerrettCommittee Member, present
TS
Councillor Tracey Simpson-LaingVice-Chair, present
DW
Councillor Dafydd WilliamsCommittee Member, present
CS
Councillor Chris StewardAttendee, in attendance
MW
Councillor Mark WartersAttendee, in attendance
IC
Councillor Ian CuthbertsonAttendee, in attendance
PH
Councillor Paul HealeyAttendee, in attendance

All 16 on the meeting page

On this subject at York

Search all
  1. The Punch Bowl Public House, Lowther Street, York - Article 4 DirectionThis decision
  2. Application for Community Right to Bid under Localism Act 2011 - The Punch BowlApproved
  3. Confirmation of Article 4 Direction, The Punchbowl Public House, Lowther Street, YorkDecided
  4. Request for Article 4 Direction - Punch Bowl Public House, YorkAgreed
  5. Request for an Article 4 Direction relating to The Punch Bowl public house, Lowther Street, YorkAgreed
  6. Request for an Article 4 Direction relating to The Punch Bowl public house, Lowther Street, YorkDeferred

More from York Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Nov 2026 Minutes (4:46pm)That the Minutes of the Executive meeting held on 6 October 2026 be approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Capital Programme Monitor Update 2 Report (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. In relation to the overall programme: · Recommended to Full Council the adj... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Q2 2026-27 Finance and Performance Monitor (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. Noted the finance and performance information. ii. Noted that work will con... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Treasury Management Quarter 2 Prudential Indicators (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Noted the 2026/27 Treasury Management activity up to the period ending 30th ... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Medium Term Financial Strategy Update (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Agreed the Medium Term Financial Strategy as outlined in this report · In re... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies