That the Executive welcome the suggestions put forward in respect of the new decision making arrangements, including the comments of the Audit and Governance and the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committees and await feedback from consultation with the political groups and independent members on the proposals, prior to a decision by the Executive in August. Reason: To enable revised decision making arrangements to be put in place . That the Executive welcome the suggestions put forward in respect of the new decision making arrangements, including the comments of the Audit and Governance and the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committees and await feedback from consultation with the political groups and independent members on the proposals, prior to a decision by the Executive in August. Reason: To enable revised decision making arrangements to be put in place .
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1.1A key priority of the new council leadership is to ensure there is greater cross-party involvement in the decision making process and that these decisions are taken in a more open and transparent way.
The new leadership want policy and scrutiny committees to have the opportunity to debate and make recommendations on matters requiring an executive decision before a final decision is taken. This report sets out proposals for how such a system could be introduced and identifies some issues which may arise. It is proposed that this report form the basis for consultation with Audit and Governance Committee, Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committee, political groups and independent members.
1.2The proposals seek to balance three key principles:
That there should be an opportunity for scrutiny of executive decisions before they are made
That proper decision making should not be unduly delayed or fettered
That there should be greater transparency not only of what decisions are made but by whom.
2. Who will undertake pre decision scrutiny?
2.1It is proposed that the arrangements for scrutiny will vary according to whether the decision is proposed to be taken by the full Executive or an Executive Member acting alone. 2.2 For an Executive Member decision it is suggested that the policy and scrutiny committee within whose remit the issue lies will have the scrutiny responsibility. For matters coming to the Executive it is proposed that CSMC will be the scrutiny committee.
2.3The suggestion that CSMC have oversight of Executive reports is made simply for reasons of effective administration. There may be concerns that this means that members of the relevant scrutiny committee will not get to scrutinise the most significant decisions relating to their area. This concern could be mitigated by one or more of the following:
Scrutiny committees asking for early reports on significant issues in advance of Executive reports being drafted and thereby influencing policy development and the contents of the final Executive report
Arrangements for representatives of the scrutiny committee to have a right to participate in the debate at CSMC
Considering the make up of CSMC – could it, for example, be largely made up of the Chairs of the other scrutiny committees?
3. How will a decision come for scrutiny?
3.1It has always been possible for a Scrutiny Committee to identify issues which will, in due course, require an Executive decision and for the Committee to review those issues. Such scrutiny at an early stage of policy development can help frame future debates and reports and is not in any way affected by these proposals.
3.2What these proposals do seek to achieve is to give Scrutiny and Policy Committees the opportunity to see a report in its final (or close to final) form and to debate recommendations on the report prior to the final decision being made.
3.3There are various ways that the Council could arrange to bring a report to the relevant scrutiny and policy committee including:
All decisions coming for scrutiny routinely Any Member being able to request a proposed decision be added to the Scrutiny agenda Replicating the post decision “call in process” requiring three Members to call the decision to Committee Have the Chair/Vice Chair operate as a filter for Member requests in much the same way as Planning Committee operates in bringing to Committee matters which would normally be decided under delegated powers.
3.4Having all matters come for scrutiny routinely may not be the best use of Committee or Officer time and so some filter system is recommended. That in use for planning matters works well and may be an appropriate model.
4. How will Members know what decisions are to be made?
4.1The Forward Plan is key to this and there will need to be considerable discipline in adding matters to the Plan in good time and with sufficient detail as to what is to be decided.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.