That the Executive agree to : (i) Confirm the introduction of pre decision scrutiny arrangements and their commitment more generally to involving scrutiny in improving the quality of decisions made by the Council . (ii) To endorse the proposed arrangements for pre decision scrutiny as set out in this report and described in the guide at Annex A. (iii) To invite the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committee to: a) Consider how best to involve Members of other Scrutiny Committees in its pre decision call in work b) Establish a Sub Committee to deal with urgent call ins c) To consider the remits of Scrutiny Committees and the membership of CSMPSC itself with a view to presenting proposals to Council (iv) To agree to review the new arrangements at the end of the Municipal Year. Reason : To enable revised decision making arrangements to be put in place That the Executive agree to : (i) Confirm the introduction of pre decision scrutiny arrangements and their commitment more generally to involving scrutiny in improving the quality of decisions made by the Council . (ii) To endorse the proposed arrangements for pre decision scrutiny as set out in this report and described in the guide at Annex A. (iii) To invite the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committee to: a) Consider how best to involve Members of other Scrutiny Committees in its pre decision call in work b) Establish a Sub Committee to deal with urgent call ins c) To consider the remits of Scrutiny Committees and the membership of CSMPSC itself with a view to presenting proposals to Council 1. (iv) To agree to review the new arrangements at the end of the Municipal Year. 2. Reason : To enable revised decision making arrangements to be put in place
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1.1At the last meeting of the Executive a report was considered in relation to proposals for new decision making arrangements allowing for greater pre decision scrutiny. That report is attached at Annex A for ease of reference. This report informs the Executive of the outcome of that consultation and makes proposals for implementation.
2. Recommendations 2.1 Members are recommended to:
a) Confirm the introduction of pre decision scrutiny arrangements and their commitment more generally to involving scrutiny in improving the quality of decisions made by the Council
b) To endorse the proposed arrangements for pre decision scrutiny as set out in this report and described in the guide at Annex A.
c) To invite the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committee to:
i) Consider how best to involve Members of other Scrutiny Committees in its pre decision call in work ii) Establish a Sub Committee to deal with urgent call ins iii) To consider the remits of Scrutiny Committees and the membership of CSMPSC itself with a view to presenting proposals to Council d) To agree to review the new arrangements at the end of the Municipal Year Reason: To enable revised decision making arrangements to be put in place
Background
3.1The report to the last Executive meeting has been considered by both the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Policy and Scrutiny Committee (CSMPSC) and the Audit and Governance Committee (A&G). In addition political groups and independent members have been consulted.
3.2There is very widespread support for the key principle of seeking to involve more Members in the process leading to decisions being made. It is also recognised that ultimately it is the Executive which has the legal responsibility for decision making on those matters which are statutorily within its remit.
3.3There is support for the specific proposal to allow Scrutiny Committees to comment on reports before a decision is made. There is also support for moving more generally to a system of earlier engagement with scrutiny before an issue reaches the decision making stage. Good dialogue between Executive Members and Scrutiny Committees on major decisions coming forward and key priorities will assist in this.
3.4There is a consensus that CSMPSC would be the appropriate Committee to deal with pre decision call in of items coming to the full Executive. It was recognised that this would lead to an increase in workload and CSMPSC would be prepared to meet monthly to accommodate this change.
3.5There is support for the suggestion that there should be arrangements made to enable members of the relevant “service area” scrutiny committees to participate when CSMPSC considers an issue relevant to the particular Committee. In this regard two options had support:
Establishing CSMPSC as a Committee of Chairs of the Scrutiny Committees (recognising that some extra Members may be required to achieve political balance) For CSMPSC to invite Members of the relevant Committees to participate in the debate when CSMPSC considers a call in relevant to that Committees work. 3.6 Ultimately Full Council would need to consider any change to the membership of CSMPSC. There are other proposals for a review of Scrutiny Committees and this matter might best be considered further as part of that review. In the interim the Executive is recommended to ask CSMPSC to consider whether it wishes to implement the second option and to determine exactly how that would work. One simple solution could be to invite the relevant Chair and Vice Chair or their nominees.
3.7There was recognition that there should be a filtering system so that not every executive decision will go through scrutiny before coming to an Executive Member or the full Executive. There was general support for the suggestion of replicating the post decision call in process requiring three Members to call the decision to Committee.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.