That having considered the Goose Management Scrutiny Review Task Groups final report, the Executive agrees to refer back the report and recommendations listed at paragraph 2 ( i to v) to the Communities and Environment Policy & Scrutiny Committee for further examination in order to refine the recommendations, in line with budget constraints, prior to consideration by the Executive Member for Culture, Leisure & Tourism. Reason: To conclude the Scrutiny Review in line with CYC Scrutiny procedures and protocols. That having considered the Goose Management Scrutiny Review Task Groups final report, the Executive agrees to refer back the report and recommendations listed at paragraph 2 (i to v) to the Communities and Environment Policy & Scrutiny Committee for further examination in order to refine the recommendations, in line with budget constraints, prior to consideration by the Executive Member for Culture, Leisure & Tourism. 1. Reason: To conclude the Scrutiny Review in line with CYC Scrutiny procedures and protocols.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Communities & Environment Policy & Scrutiny 15 March 2016 Committee
Report of the Goose Management Scrutiny Review Task Group
Goose Management Scrutiny Review – Final Report
Background to Review 1. At a meeting in September 2015, the Communities & Environment Policy & Scrutiny Committee agreed to proceed with a scrutiny review of Geese Management across the city following submission of an associated scrutiny topic by Cllr Kramm.
2. A Task Group made up of Cllrs Kramm, Gunnell and Richardson was set up and tasked with identifying a suitable review remit and carrying out the review. The Task Group met for the first time in early December 2015 and the following was agreed:
Aim:
To improve the experience of residents and visitors to public parks, gardens and open spaces by examining the geese (and other water fowl) related problems affecting Rowntree Park, the University and other sites.
(NB: All references thereafter to Geese, relate to both Geese and other water fowl).
Objectives:
i. To understand previous examinations of the geese related problems in York, lessons learnt, cost to the city, associated health risks etc.
ii. To examine best practice nationally and elsewhere.
iii. To consider technical options for dropping removal, the associated costs and external funding possibilities. iv. Consult all interested parties on geese population management and control practices, to understand the requirements for different species and animal protection issues.
v. Identify appropriate solutions and options for funding.
3. Furthermore, the Task Group agreed to co-opt two members on to the Task Group, one a member of the ‘Friends of Rowntree Park’ group and one a representative from the University of York.
4. They also identified a number of meetings dates and drafted the following methodology for their review:
Meetings Tasks Meeting 1 - Formal Objective 1 – To consider information relating to: Tuesday 26th • The geese population in York January 4pm • All previous related work undertaken by the (West Offices) Council • The associated cost to the city • Lessons learnt • Any associated health risks Meeting 2 – Formal Objective 2 - To examine best practice nationally Tuesday 2nd and elsewhere. February 5.30pm (West Offices) Objective 3 - To consider technical options for dropping removal, the associated costs and external funding possibilities. Meeting 3 – Objective 4 – Consultation Meeting Informal Tuesday 9th February 5.30pm (West Offices) Meeting 4 – To consider findings and consultation feedback, Informal and identify appropriate review conclusions Wednesday 17th February 5.30pm (West Offices) Meeting 5 – Formal To consider draft final report. Thursday 3rd March 5.30pm (West Offices) 5. The remit and methodology above was subsequently agreed by the Community & Environment Policy & Scrutiny Committee on 20 January 2016.
Information Gathered
6. In support of objective (i), at their first formal meeting on 26 January 2016, the Task Group received introductory information on the law protecting wild geese in the UK, together with a detailed presentation on goose management from the Councils Public Realm Operations Manager (Strategy & Contracts). The presentation confirmed:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.