That the Executive agree to: ( i ) Note and agree the actions the Council is taking and proposes to take in order to address the Auditor’s recommendations in their report, as set out in paragraph 9 onwards; (ii) Refer to Audit & Governance Committee for consideration the changes suggested in paragraph 23 of the report to both the Council Procedures Rules and the Council’s Webcasting Protocol, in the interests of clarity and transparency of approach. Reason: In order to address the recommendations highlighted in the Public Interest Report. That the Executive note and agree the actions the Council is taking and proposes to take in order to address the Auditor’s recommendations in their report, as set out in paragraph 9 onwards. Reason: In order to address the recommendations highlighted in the Public Interest Report.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. This report provides a summary of the actions the Council have either taken or are planning in order to address the 10 specific recommendations in the Public Interest Report. The recommendations are set out within this report following agreement of the Public Interest Report at Full Council on 24th March 2016.
Background
2. This report is submitted in response to the Public Interest Report issued by Mazars, the Council‟s External Auditor, on 26th February. This is included in the Full Council papers of 24th March 2016. The Recommendations in the Public Interest Report were welcomed and approved by Council at that meeting, after a full debate in which elected Members (included the Leader, Deputy Leader and Chair of City of York Council Trading Company CYT) reiterated the role of CYT in recruiting and retaining quality staff whilst ensuring front line services profit and thrive. Most importantly, they emphasised the Council‟s ongoing commitment to fair and transparent governance. Changes had already been introduced to ensure CYT Shareholder‟s meetings took place in public. In furtherance of this commitment, this report proposes further steps to balance and enhance transparency and openness within an effective and appropriate operating framework. These include revisions to the Council Procedure Rules. In addition to the revisions implemented at the start of the current Municipal Year and the Council‟s Webcasting Protocol.
Recommendations
3. The Executive is asked to:
(i) note and agree the actions the Council is taking and proposes to take in order to address the Auditor‟s recommendations in their report, as set out in paragraph 9 below onwards; (ii) refer to Audit & Governance Committee for consideration the changes suggested in paragraph 23 below to both the Council Procedures Rules and the Council‟s Webcasting Protocol, in the interests of clarity and transparency of approach.
Reason: In order to address the recommendations highlighted in the Public Interest Report.
Council Approval of the Payments
4. R1 The Council should take steps to rectify the omission of the Council approval for the payments made to the two directors of City of York Trading Ltd in March 2015 for work for the company in 2013/14.
5. CYC response - The two directors have voluntarily agreed to repay the payments made to them. Therefore no further action is required. The External Auditor has agreed with this. In the interests of public clarity and transparency, the letter received from the Auditor on this point is attached at Annex 1 to this report.
Governance Arrangements
6. R2 Where the Council envisages a role for a committee within a Council-owned trading company to fulfil a Council function, as appears to have been the case with the Shareholder Committee of City of York Trading Ltd, the Council should ensure that the Constitution is amended to reflect this role and that the composition of the Committee is consistent with the Council‟s decision making and governance arrangements.
7. R3 The Council should review its approach to the establishment and governance of Council-owned companies to ensure that it fully reflects good practice and the lessons from this report. 8. R4 In the light of the conclusions of the review recommended in R3, the Council should prepare specific guidance to members and officers on their involvement in Council-owned companies.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.