That the application be approved as per the conditions in the Officer’s report (with the plans condition updated to refer to the last amendments) , and with an additional condition relating to managed public access through the site. Reason: i. The revised scheme would not harm on heritage assets. Where the proposed building is close to the Grade I listed City Walls due to the design of the scheme, and its massing and footprint, there would not be harm to the setting of the City Walls, and the extra massing on the Toft Green side would not harm the townscape and there are benefits to the character and appearance of the conservation area – enhanced connectivity and landscaping, provision of a mix of uses that would enhance viability, and built form of reasonable quality and sympathetic materials. ii. The absence of a five year housing land supply as required by the NPPF triggers the presumption in favour of sustainable development and the second part of paragraph 14 ... view the full minutes text for item 29b
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Date: 17 August 2017 Ward: Micklegate Team: Major and Parish: Micklegate Planning Commercial Team Panel
Reference: 17/00576/FULM Application at: Hudson House Toft Green York YO1 6JT For: Erection of 4 no. buildings comprising 127no. flats (C3), office (B1) use and office or restaurant (B1 or A3) uses following the demolition of existing office building By: Palace Capital (Developments) Ltd Application Type: Major Full Application (13 weeks) Target Date: 13 June 2017 Recommendation: Approve
1.0PROPOSAL
Application site
1.1The application relates to the office block known as Hudson House. The building was completed in 1968 and was intended to be the new headquarters for British Rail, Eastern Region.
1.2The building is concrete framed, and in the Brutalist style. It has 4 wings and is referred to as being pin-wheel in plan. The two blocks nearest Toft Green are 6 storeys in height; the two nearer the City Wall are 4 storeys. The building's scale is relative to the City Walls and buildings fronting Micklegate.
1.3The building is positioned between a late C20 office block - George Stephenson House and the C21 Hilton Hotel. The City Walls are to the west. On the opposite side of Toft Green are a mix of commercial buildings, including offices and the York Brewery.
1.4The site is within the Central Historic Core Conservation Area and is prominent from the grade I listed City Walls.
Proposals
1.5The application is to demolish the existing building with replacement development on a similar footprint. The scheme has been revised (primarily reducing the building height and re-considering the roof form) following consultation and in response to concerns raised by Historic England. The latest revision (reducing the scale of block 2) was received 7.8.2017. The scheme would have a public route, with level inclusive access, between Station Road and Toft Green; Application Reference Number: 17/00576/FULM Item No: 4d Page 1 of 35 there would be associated landscaping within the courtyard and around the development including the car park between the proposed building and West Offices, which would be reduced in size and reconfigured. The new building would be clad in brick and range in height between 5 and 7 storey. The updated design & access statement illustrates the existing and proposed massing. The maximum height of the proposed building, compared to its neighbours would be approximately as follows -
Proposed building - 24m George Stephenson House - 22m Hilton Hotel - 22m West Offices - 20m
1.6The development would accommodate the following uses -
Dwellings - 127 (15 x studios, 34 x 1-bed ,73 x 2-bed, 5 x 3-bed Office space - 4,252 sq m Commercial units - 475 sq m
1.7The scheme has been subject to an environmental screening and it was concluded an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) would not be required (see application 17/00183/EIASN).
1.8The developers undertook their own public consultation in January 2017 prior to making the application. Details of the exercise and the feedback is detailed in the applicants’ Statement of Community Involvement report which has been submitted with the application.
Relevant planning history
1.9The building has prior approval for conversion to 139 dwellings (application 15/02965/ORC). Permission has also been granted for part conversion to 82 dwellings, refurbished office space and external alterations (application 15/01256/FULM).
2.0POLICY CONTEXT
2.1Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compensation Act 2004 requires that determinations be made in accordance with the development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. There is no adopted Local Plan in York. In the absence of a formally adopted local plan the most up-to date representation of key relevant policy issues is the NPPF and it is against this Framework and the statutory duties set out below that the application proposal should principally be addressed.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.