That approval be given to hold discussions with NYCC to explore the merging of coroner areas, in accordance with Option 2. Reason: To improve resilience and efficiency, with minimal financial impact and in line with the Chief Coroner’s guidance. That approval be given to hold discussions with NYCC to explore the merging of coroner areas, in accordance with Option 2. Reason: To improve resilience and efficiency, with minimal financial impact and in line with the Chief Coroner’s guidance.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. This report seeks member agreement to undertake discussions with North Yorkshire County Council (NYCC) to explore merging the CYC and NYCC coroner areas, at the request of the Chief Coroner and the Ministry of Justice (MoJ). Any merger would come into effect in April 2020.
2. The key driver for this is to improve standards of service. The Chief Coroner has a very clear view that larger coronial areas are more effective, allowing a senior coroner to manage work effectively, giving support staff the opportunity to work as part of a wider team providing enhanced support, resilience and a consistent service for relatives. This would also be likely to result in a small financial saving. Inquests would continue to be held in current locations, and would not be centralised.
3. If members agree to the discussions, it is envisaged that the assessment and consultation could be completed within 12 months, leading potentially to a merger from April 2020.
Recommendation 4. It is recommended that discussions be held with NYCC to explore merging coroner areas.
Reason : This would improve resilience and efficiency, with minimal financial impact and be in line with the Chief Coroner’s Guidance. Background
5. The coroner service is an anomalous service within local authorities. CYC is responsible for the appointment and payment of the coroner and meeting all reasonable costs of the service. This includes the cost of the provision of mortuaries, pathology services, forensic testing, and inquests.
6. Coroners are independent judicial officers and are not employees of the local authority. All appointments of coroners have to be agreed with both the Ministry of Justice and the Chief Coroner, and they effectively have a veto on any arrangements that do not meet their approval. Local authorities cannot remove or dismiss coroners, which effectively means that arrangements for a coroner’s service can only be revised when there is not a permanently appointed coroner in place.
7. The Chief Coroner has published guidance to local authorities on how to organise the coroner service (see Annex 1 – Chief Coroner’s Guidance Note 14 - Merger of Coroners Areas). The guidance states that:
a. it is the Chief Coroner’s view the number of coroner areas should be reduced in order to create sensibly sized coroner areas, taking into account the numbers of reported deaths, geographical size and types of coroner work in the area;
b. there are many part-time coroner jurisdictions which are too small for effective management and cost-efficiency; and
c. in many cases 3,000-5,000 reported deaths would be an appropriate number for a coroner jurisdiction.
8. Schedule 2 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 gives the Lord Chancellor the power to make orders altering coroner areas. To date all mergers have been made by agreement.
9. To merge coroner areas it has to apply to the Lord Chancellor with written reasons, effectively a business case for the merger. Before doing so it should consult with the Chief Coroner. 10. Where a new coroner area is created, it must consist of one or more whole upper-tier local authority areas.
11. York has a single coroner area, and a temporary part-time senior coroner. York’s last permanent part-time senior coroner retired in 2014, and the Chief Coroner and MoJ have only agreed to temporary replacements since then, pending merger discussions.
12. In 2014 CYC was asked to consider a merger with Hull & East Riding, which the York coroner and the North Yorkshire Police (NYP) did not support. CYC’s refusal was upheld on the understanding that it would explore a merger with NYCC when one of the NYCC senior coroners retires.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.