CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Executive, Monday 18 March 2019 at 5.30pm

Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review Final Report

Noted Executive 2 papers

Executive noted this item on Monday 18 March 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item136

Resolved

That the findings of the Scrutiny Task Group be noted and that the recommendations from the review, as set out in paragraph 44 of the Task Group’s final report at Annex 1 and paragraph 8 of the cover report, be approved. Reason: To conclude the Scrutiny Review in line with the council’s Scrutiny procedures and protocols. That the findings of the Scrutiny Task Group be noted and that the recommendations from the review, as set out in paragraph 44 of the Task Group’s final report at Annex 1 and paragraph 8 of the cover report, be approved. Reason: To conclude the Scrutiny Review in line with the council’s Scrutiny procedures and protocols.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive, 6 pages

Summary

1. This cover report presents the final report from the Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review and asks the Executive to approve the recommendations arising from the review.

2. The final report is subject to approval of the Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee (CSMC) at its meeting on 11 March and this paper has been published prior to that meeting in view of the statutory timescales for publication of reports. CSMC’s decision and any changes to the report or the review recommendations arising from that meeting will be circulated to Executive.

Recommendation

3. Having considered the Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review Final Report at Appendix 1 the Executive is asked to approve the recommendations as shown in paragraph 8, below.

Reason: To conclude this scrutiny review in line with CYC scrutiny procedures and protocols.

Background

4. In June 2018 CSMC considered an update report on the implementation of changes to the Council’s scrutiny function resulting from the review of ‘Future Ways of Working in Scrutiny’ completed in March 2017.

5. Specifically the Committee considered the operation of a trial in relation to establishing two Economy and Place Committees, the alignment of Scrutiny Committees to Directorates and concerns raised regarding the increased workload faced by the Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee now that the housing and community safety elements of the Directorate has been included in the remit of the former Health and Adult Social Care policy and Scrutiny Committee.

6. CSMC agreed to review how the scrutiny function moves forward for the next administration and to appoint a Task Group comprising Councillors Williams, Galvin, Reid and D’Agorne to carry out this work on the Committee’s behalf. The Task Group met for the first time in August 2018 and agreed the remit below, which was approved by CSMC in September 2018.

Aim:

To propose operational arrangements and a structure for scrutiny to improve engagement and outcomes, ensuring that the function is as effective as possible. Objectives:

Structure

 To address the balance of committee workloads

 To evaluate the current functions of Scrutiny Committees, including pre and post decision call-in, overview and the performance management role Engagement

 To assess the current level of officer and member engagement and explore ways to improve it

 To explore ways to establish robust and measurable work planning

Training

 To assess the need for member training and on-going development on scrutiny topics

Consultation 7. Over a series of meetings the Task Group met with the Chairs and Vice- Chairs of the Council’s scrutiny committees and members of the Corporate Management Team. In addition the Task Group took into account the Local Government Committee’s recommendations to Central Government on the Effectiveness of Local Government Overview and Scrutiny Committees and the Local Government Association’s ‘Scrutiny for Councillors’ Workbook 2015.

Review Recommendations

8. The information gathered from the Task Group’s consultations and considerations led to the following review recommendations:

Structure:

i. That the Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee be split into:

 Health and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee;

 Housing and Safer Neighbourhoods Policy and Scrutiny Committee. Reason: The Committee’s extended remit is too large to allow effective scrutiny. ii. That the Economy and Place Policy Development and Scrutiny Committees are rejoined.

Reason: To end the uncertainty around the roles of each committee and to provide Economy and Place with a comprehensive scrutiny function Engagement

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Scrutiny Operations and Function Review Final ReportAppendix 1 13 pages Download
PDF
Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review Final ReportReport 6 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at York

Search all
  1. Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review Final ReportThis decision
  2. Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review - Draft Final ReportDecided
  3. Update Report from Scrutiny Operations and Functions ReviewNoted
  4. Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review Update ReportAgreed

More from York Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Nov 2026 Minutes (4:46pm)That the Minutes of the Executive meeting held on 6 October 2026 be approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Capital Programme Monitor Update 2 Report (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. In relation to the overall programme: · Recommended to Full Council the adj... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Q2 2026-27 Finance and Performance Monitor (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. Noted the finance and performance information. ii. Noted that work will con... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Treasury Management Quarter 2 Prudential Indicators (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Noted the 2026/27 Treasury Management activity up to the period ending 30th ... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Medium Term Financial Strategy Update (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Agreed the Medium Term Financial Strategy as outlined in this report · In re... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies