That approval be given to accession the two Centaurs sculptures into the council’s museum collection (Option 1). Reason: In order to resolve the issue of ownership of the sculptures and ensure that they can be put on public display for the benefit of York residents. That approval be given to accession the two Centaurs sculptures into the council’s museum collection (Option 1). Reason: In order to resolve the issue of ownership of the sculptures and ensure that they can be put on public display for the benefit of York residents.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Report of the Director of Children, Education and Communities Portfolio of the Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Communities
Future of Centaurs
Summary 1. This report concerns the future of a pair of marble sculptures purchased by the council in the 1940s: Young Centaur (tempted by love) and Old Centaur (bound by love), both probably carved by Bartolomeo Cavaceppi (1716-1799) in Rome in around 1755. Recommendations 2. The Executive is asked to agree to accession the Centaurs into the council’s museum collections.
Background 3. These two marble sculptures were commissioned by the Marquis of Rockingham in the 18th Century and housed at Wentworth Woodhouse. They were purchased by York City Council at auction in 1949 as the Wentworth Woodhouse estate was broken up. They were placed in the Assembly Rooms in 1950 in two of the wall niches. 4. In 1975 they were formally loaned to York Art Gallery by the Estates Committee of the council as the Assembly Rooms location was not judged to be appropriate to display them effectively. They were not, however, formally accessioned to the city’s museum collections. At some stage the council’s museum service put them in storage.
5. In 2012, when reviewing and cataloguing the stored collections, YMT noted that the statues in their storage were not part of the museum collections and sought to return them to their correct owner. It seems that, because the sculptures had once been displayed in the Assembly Rooms, and because the Assembly Rooms had been sold, in 2002, to York Conservation Trust (YCT), YMT transferred them to YCT. 6. The Council’s records, however, show that the sculptures were not on site when the Assembly Rooms were transferred, and had not been for many years; they were not mentioned in the sale particulars and they were not listed in the inventory. Nonetheless, YCT have, since 2012, worked on the basis that the sculptures belong to them and have subsequently asserted their ownership of them. The situation was compounded in 2016 when the original wooden plinths for the figures were requested by YCT. As the items were not accessioned into the YMT collections, YMT agreed to transfer the plinths to YCT. YMT informed CYC of this.
7. With the agreement of both YCT and CYC the sculptures were recently sent on temporary loan to YMT for display in the National Gallery Masterpiece Tour 2019: Poussin’s ‘Triumph of Pan’ exhibition at York Art Gallery between 13 July and 22 September 2019. After this exhibition they will be returned to YCT. Proposal 8. In discussion between council officers and York Conservation Trust it has been established that the YCT board would be willing to transfer the sculptures to the city’s museum collections. These collections are owned by the council, and managed by YMT under a long-term loan and management agreement.
9. This would resolve the ownership question in the council’s favour and ensure that these works can be publically displayed for the benefit of York residents. These are eye-catching and impressive works that relate to a long history of connoisseurship and collecting, especially in relation to the Grand Tour, and of the attraction of discovering ancient sculpture, of making copies, and of reimagining and combining classical designs. The local links of these works are also important including their previous ownership by Wentworth Woodhouse, prior to their purchase at auction by the council in 1949, and their display history within both the Assembly Rooms and York Art Gallery.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.