Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) covering Union Terrace, Clarence Gardens and The Groves
ApprovedExecutive7 papers
AI summaryExecutive approved reinstating a Public Space Protection Order for Union Terrace, Clarence Gardens and The Grooves. It permits alcohol seizure and dispersal of groups of three or more; penalties stay £100, or £75 if paid within the first 14 days. [D] [P12] [P15]
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedAlcohol seizure; dispersal of groups of three or more [D] [P15]
MoneyCosts within current budgets [P12] [P47]Penalty notice £100, or £75 within the first 14 days [P12]
What happens nextSign order and consult [D] [P16]Early 2026 work will consider groups of two or more [P29]
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
Executive approved Option 1 and the reintroduction of the original Public Space Protection Order. [D] Report P13
The order allows alcohol seizure where it is linked to antisocial behaviour affecting local quality of life. It also allows dispersal of groups of three or more causing antisocial behaviour. [D] Report P15
Authority is delegated for the Director of Housing and Communities to sign the order in conjunction with the Director of Governance on behalf of the Executive Member for Housing, Planning and Safer Neighbourhoods. [D]
Why
The council's stated reason is to ensure it actively addresses antisocial behaviour in York's communities. [D]
North Yorkshire Police and City of York Council's Resettlement Services supported the order, and 80 percent of survey respondents supported the alcohol and group measures. [P30] [P33] [P35] Report P30, P33, P35
The immediate aim is police and council action over the Christmas and New Year period, while the order supports a seamless boundary with the City Centre PSPO. [P24] [P29] Report P24, P29
What happens next
The Director of Housing and Communities is authorised to sign the order in conjunction with the Director of Governance. [D]
Further detailed consultation on dispersing groups of two or more will take place, with stakeholder and support service views. Early 2026 work will consider expanding the order. [P16] [P28] [P29] Report P16, P28, P29
The council will publicise the order and work with partners to raise awareness, focusing mainly on digital channels. It will produce further equality impact assessments for any expanded powers and review whether a data protection impact assessment is required. [P12] [P54] Report P12, P54
The money
£100 The Fixed Penalty Notice amount, unchanged by renewal. Report P12
£75 The Fixed Penalty Notice amount if paid within the first 14 days. Report P12
Options considered
Chosen: Reintroduce the order with alcohol seizure and dispersal of groups of three or more, and consult on wider powers. Recommended for an immediate response, with police and consultation support for wider powers. Report P29, P40, P41, P43
Rejected: Reintroduce the order with alcohol seizure and dispersal of groups of three or more, without consultation on wider powers. Police and first consultation outputs supported wider powers. Report P42, P43
Rejected: Decline the order and any consultation on wider powers. It would leave no powers to challenge antisocial behaviour and increase risks for residents, visitors and businesses. Report P44
Implications
Financial: The costs of publicity and further consultation can be met within existing budgets. [P12] [P47] Report P12, P47
Legal: The order does not prohibit responsible outdoor drinking or all gatherings. Enforcement requires officers to witness antisocial behaviour. [P23] [P33] Report P23, P33
Legal: Breaching the order is a criminal offence. Officers may issue a Fixed Penalty Notice or prosecute; responsibility for breaches and unpaid notices rests with the council. [P22] Report P22
Equalities: Stakeholders raised concerns about unequal treatment of homeless and rough sleeping people. Wider powers require further consultation with stakeholders and support services, and further equality impact assessments. [P28] [P54] Report P28, P54
Risk: Without the order, antisocial behaviour is likely to be displaced into Gillygate, Union Terrace and The Groves. [P9] Report P9
Climate: The report identifies no climate change implications. [P54] Report P54
Staffing: The report identifies no Human Resources implications. [P47] Report P47
Other: The data protection screening found no personal, special category or criminal offence data being processed for these recommendations, so no data protection impact assessment is required at present. This will be reviewed after approval. [P54] Report P54
Who and where
Residents, visitors and businesses in the covered area Report P5, P32, P44
Groups of three or more causing antisocial behaviour Report P15
Homeless and rough sleeping people Report P28, P54
Council enforcement officers and North Yorkshire Police Report P22, P29
University of York students and car park users Report P6
City of York Council Resettlement Services Report P30
People from other towns and cities targeted by proposed wider powers Report P27
Guildhall Ward Report P57
Timeline
20 October 2014: The 2014 Act came into force and changed the powers available to councils and police. [P19] Report P19
2022: The previous PSPO was reinstated. [P9] Report P9
August 2025: The latest PSPO expired. [P22] Report P22
2 September 2025: The Executive Member approved the consultation process. [P2] Report P2
20 November 2025: The report was approved. [P62] Report P62
2 December 2025: Executive approved reintroducing the order and undertaking further consultation. [P1] [D] Report P1
Christmas and New Year period: Police and council enforcement officers could use the order for immediate action on intimidation and excessive alcohol consumption. [P29] Report P29
early 2026: Further work will consider expanding the order. [P29] Report P29
Plain English for the jargon
PSPO: A Public Space Protection Order. It can stop antisocial behaviour in a public space and may be enforced by the council or police. [P20] [P21] [P68]
ASB: Antisocial behaviour. [P68]
FPN: Fixed Penalty Notice, available for officers when a PSPO is breached. [P22] [P68]
EIA: Equalities Impact Assessment. [P54] [P68]
NYP: North Yorkshire Police. [P68]
CYC: City of York Council. [P68]
DPIA: Data protection impact assessment. [P54]
VAWG: Violence Against Women & Girls. [P68]
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item180
Resolved
Resolved – T hat, in accordance with Option 1 in paragraph 29 of the report, Executive approves: a) the reintroduction of the original PSPO as follows: · seizing alcohol where it is associated with anti-social behaviour that is impacting on the quality of life for people in that area; and · the ability to disperse large groups of three or more people who are causing ASB. b) a further detailed consultation relating to the following: · The ability to remove large groups of two or more people who are causing anti-social behaviour (as opposed to three or more as contained in the September report ); c) Delegated authority for the Director of Housing and Communities to sign the PSPO on behalf of the Executive Member for Housing, Planning and Safer Neighbourhoods in conjunction with the Director of Governance (Monitoring Officer). Reason: To ensure that the council actively addresses the issue of antisocial behaviour in York’s communities.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Meeting: Executive Meeting date: 2 December 2025 Report of: Director of Housing and Communities Portfolio of: Executive Member for Housing, Planning & Safer Communities
Decision Report: Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) covering Union Terrace, Clarence Gardens and The Groves Subject of Report 1. The purpose of this report is to consider the responses from a recent consultation process undertaken, as approved by the Executive Member for Housing, Planning and Safer Communities on 2 September 2025, and determine whether to re-introduce a PSPO covering Union Terrace, Clarence Gardens and The Groves.
2. The decision to undertake consultation regarding a potential PSPO was developed jointly in conjunction with North Yorkshire Police, and the process followed is in accordance with the guidance as set down by the Local Government Association available here: https://www.local.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/10.21%20PS PO%20guidance_06_1.pdf.
3. The recommendations and actions relating to the renewal of the existing PSPO and deeper consultation of further powers will contribute to the council’s and its partners’ collective commitment to making York’s city centre and public spaces safe and welcoming for all.
Benefits and Challenges 4. Union Terrace is a car park situated just outside the City Walls (the area within is also subject to a Public Space Protection Order). It is one of the main parking areas for coaches bringing visitors into the city and as such is the first impression of the city for those visitors travelling by coach. A temporary accommodation hostel is situated adjacent to the car park and opposite the campus buildings of the University of York St Johns. This area attracts a high daily footfall throughout the year.
5. Feedback from university students, users of the car park and businesses in the area has been that people feel intimidated by the behaviour of groups who gather in Union Terrace.
6. Clarence Gardens is a park area situated close to the Union Terrace Car Park. It is opposite part of the university campus and is adjacent to the hospital. Issues of anti-social behaviour are also experienced along Clarence Street itself which runs alongside Union Terrace Car park and leads to Clarence Gardens.
7. Some of the same individuals who have caused issues at Union Terrace Car Park have also been responsible for issues within the gardens.
8. Numbers of calls for service to North Yorkshire Police in relation to issues in Union Terrace have been lower in recent times following intensive partnership working, part of which included the reinstatement in 2022 of the PSPO in this area (a PSPO has been in place here since 2014). This has been evident from the daily reviews of ASB Police Data by Police Officers in the Community Safety Hub (which is the routine catalyst for a decision to take multi- agency action within emerging hot spot locations). It is not possible to extract data from Police systems to evidence this due to the range of information included within the crime recording category of ASB. It should be noted that incidents tend to be seasonal and peak at times of highest footfall from the car park (Christmas Market and Summer Tourist Season). That said, there has not been an increase during the Summer 2025 which is likely to be a result of the ongoing partner actions delivered through the Problem Solving approach implemented in 2022. Whilst this may raise a question as to the need for a PSPO, based on direct volume of incidents, it should be noted that this PSPO is directly adjacent to the City Centre PSPO and therefore without it, there is likely to be displacement of anti-social behaviour from the City Centre into the area of Gillygate, Union Terrace and The Groves. Policy Basis for Decision 9. The renewal of the PSPO in the area, supports the priorities within the Council Plan 2023-27, One City For All as follows:
Build Community Pride Make the City Centre Work for Everyone.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.