AI summaryCity of York Council Executive agreed a 2026 garden waste subscription fee of £52 per permit and kept the 50% Council Tax support discount. [D] The increase is intended to help cover rising service costs. [D][P4]
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreed50% Council Tax support discount remains [D]
Money£52 per permit [D]Expected circa £120k additional income if all subscribe again [P16]
What happens next2026 service expansion [P33][P35]331 established, circa 300 new build properties [P33][P35]
Who it affectsAll wards [P53]Subscribers and households seeking collections [P4][P13][P33][P34]
What was decided
The Executive noted the report and agreed to increase the garden waste subscription fee to £52 per permit for 2026. Report P18
The 50% discount remains for residents in receipt of Council Tax support. Report P18
The fee was set to enable the service's sustainability in 2026. Report P19
Why
Inflation and higher service delivery costs require a higher fee. The £52 rate also matches North Yorkshire Council's 2026 charge. Report P4, P37
Subscription income should cover operating costs. Wider service budgets currently subsidise a gap of circa £175k. Report P6, P15
A stable funding base supports expansion to more properties and makes the service more equitable. Report P6
What happens next
Waste Services will offer the service to 331 eligible established properties in 2026. Report P33
Waste Services will assess new registrations for suitability and consider circa 300 new build properties during 2026, subject to efficient and environmentally friendly rounds. Report P35, P36
The Council will communicate the increase, the discount, the environmental benefits, free alternatives and planned service expansion. Report P50
50% Discount retained for Council Tax support recipients Report P18
circa £120k Additional income if all subscribers subscribe again Report P16, P48
circa £175k Current gap between service delivery and income Report P15
£2,103k Current collection and disposal service cost Report P15
£1,929k Forecast 2025/26 subscription income if current subscribers subscribe again Report P12
£49 per year 2025 subscription fee Report P4, P12, P27
£46.50 Subscription fee introduced in 2024 Report P4, P25
Options considered
Rejected: No costs increase. Would provide no additional income to offset operational costs. Report P39, P40
Rejected: Increase £1. Would add circa £40k income. Report P41, P42
Rejected: Increase £1.50. Would add circa £60k income. Report P43, P44
Rejected: Increase £2.50. Would add circa £80k income. Report P45, P46
Chosen: Increase £3.00. This maximum option would add circa £120k and match North Yorkshire Council's charge. Report P37, P48, P52
Implications
Financial: The fee increase would provide £120k to help balance the 2026/27 budget; without it, savings elsewhere would be needed. Report P50
Risk: Without a fee increase, the operating cost and income gap would remain and could grow with inflation and an anticipated pay award, adding to the Council's wider budget gap. Report P50, P51
Legal: Local authorities may charge for garden waste as a discretionary service under the Controlled Waste Regulations 2012, but cannot make a profit from it. Report P50
Climate: Less garden waste may be composted through the Council, while uncollected waste may be composted at home or taken to a household waste recycling centre. Report P50
Equalities: Households unable to subscribe can use free alternatives or share a subscription with a neighbour. Report P50
Staffing: No human resources implications are identified. Report P50
Other: No procurement, health and wellbeing or economy implications are identified, and no DPIA is required. Report P50
Other: Clear and proactive communication is essential about the fee increase, discount, environmental benefits, free alternatives and service expansion. Report P50
Residents receiving Council Tax support Report P18
All city wards Report P53
Circa 40,000 current subscribers Report P12, P28
331 established properties eligible for service Report P33
Circa 300 new build properties Report P35
Properties without bin storage or vehicle access Report P34
Circa 1300 households registered for the free bin collection offer Report P26
Timeline
January 2024: Executive approved the scheme, and waste optimisation work was agreed. Report P14, P24
2005: Separate kerbside garden waste collection commenced in York. Report P20
February 2024: Full Council agreed the fully chargeable scheme as part of the budget process. Report P24
August 2024: The fully chargeable garden waste subscription service was introduced. Report P4
October 2025: North Yorkshire Council increased its 2026 garden waste charge to £52 per permit. Report P37
end of November 2025: A single free bin collection for households not subscribing was due to happen. Report P26
2 December 2025: The Executive agreed the 2026 fee of £52 per permit and the continuing 50% discount. Report P2
2026: The £52 fee applies, 331 established properties are offered the service, and circa 300 new build properties are considered. Report P33, P35
Plain English for the jargon
Garden waste subscription service: A separate kerbside garden waste collection provided by annual subscription and not directly included in the Council Tax bill. [P24][P25]
Permit: The annual subscription for the service, set at £52 for 2026. [D][P18]
Council Tax support: A qualifying support that gives residents a 50% garden waste subscription discount. [D][P18]
Household waste recycling centre: A free option for disposing of garden waste without subscribing. [P10][P50]
PAS100 certified compost: Compost made from garden waste collected in York, described as PAS100 certified. [P11]
Controlled Waste Regulations 2012: The rules that include garden waste among services a local authority may charge for. [P24][P50]
DPIA: Data protection impact assessment. Screening found no requirement to complete one. [P50]
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item182
Resolved
Resolved – That Executive notes the content of the report and agrees to increase garden waste subscription service at a fee of £52 per permit with the 50% discount to remain for those in receipt of Council Tax support. Reason: To set the subscription fee for 2026 to enable sustainability in the service.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Meeting: Executive Meeting date: 2 December 2025 Report of: Director of Environmental and Regulatory Services Portfolio of: Executive Member for Environment and Climate Change
Decision Report: Garden Waste update Subject of Report 1. To meet the City’s outcomes around the environment and maximising reuse and recycling to support a circular economy, the Council operates a garden waste subscription service.
2. The Council introduced a fully chargeable garden waste subscription service in August 2024. The subscription fee was introduced at £46.50 and increased to £49 per year for 2025 to cover increases in costs to the services and to bring in line with the rest of North Yorkshire with whom the Council share disposal arrangements. It is proposed, given inflationary increases and impact on the service delivery cost of the service, that the fee is set at £52 per year for 2026 to further offset the cost for the delivery of the service.
Benefits and Challenges Benefits
- In economically challenging times, charging for a garden waste subscription service would secure the continuation of a much- valued service to residents. - The income generated from the subscriptions should seek to cover the costs of operating the garden waste service. - Providing a stable funding base for the service enables the foundation for extending to additional properties across the city making it more equitable. Previously garden waste service was not offered to all households across the city as previously when not chargeable the operational rounds were over capacity, however Waste Services are looking at opportunities to expand the offer of garden waste collections following the Bags to Bins scheme, new build properties and reassessing established areas to see if garden waste collections can be offered safely and efficiently. - Whilst it is recognised that a subscription-based service means an increased cost to residents, there is a 50% discount for residents who are receive Council Tax support. - Complementary services, such as home composting are supported. 185 compost bins were provided in the last 12 months to residents, this is cost neutral to the service. - Aligning costs with North Yorkshire Council provides equity for residents across the wider region.
Challenges:
- The necessary increases in costs of the service are passed onto subscribers, but will be mitigated by expanding the service across the City. There is a balance to be struck in terms of growing the service and providing an affordable fee and covering the cost of the service. - The service isn’t currently offered to every resident, so it is important that the fee is set at a level that matches the service cost and that the service is extended more widely across the City.
Policy Basis for Decision 3. Equalities and Human Rights – Equality of opportunity – At this current time the garden waste service is not available to all households and the fact that some properties remain on a bagged waste service means we cannot provide garden waste collections to these properties.
4. Affordability – Whilst imposing a charge for garden waste collections may have some negative impacts for those on a low income there are environmentally friendly, cost effective and free alternatives to subscribing to a garden waste collection service such as home composting and/or disposal at a household waste recycling centre;
5. Climate – Environment and the climate emergency – Providing a garden waste service ensures recyclable waste doesn’t end up in residual bins, and as collected as a separate stream garden waste collected in York is locally recycled into PAS100 certified compost. Reducing the mileage and making the service more efficient through optimising collection routes and rounds will have benefits for the environment and carbon and other emissions will be reduced.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.