CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Executive, Thursday 20 March 2008 at 9.30am

TOWN CENTRE AND WATERFRONT PROJECT - SCORING CRITERIA

Agreed Executive 1 paper

Executive agreed this item on Thursday 20 March 2008. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item11

Resolved

Decision To agree to revise the criteria for assessing OBCs as outlined in the report. (Reference: Report by Head of Strategic Finance dated 20 March 2008, tabled).
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Recommendations

2.1The Executive are asked to consider revising the criteria for assessing OBCs as outlined in this report.

3. DETAIL

3.1The Council at its meeting on 26 September 2007 agreed to take each of the town centre and waterfront projects to OBC stage. It also agreed that the OBCs would be “subject to a process of independent scrutiny based on the weighting and scoring criteria approved by Council in February 2007”.

3.2Further to the above the Executive on 20 December 2007 agreed to a process whereby one firm would be appointed to prepare the OBCs for all of the town centre and waterfront projects and a separate firm would be appointed to carry out the scoring of OBCs.

3.3Consultants have now been appointed to carry out preparation of the OBCs. Owing to the mix of skills required the successful consultants are Smiths Gore, Cogent SI and Melica who will work in partnership on the OBCs.

3.4During the preliminary stages of the project over the last few weeks the consultants have proposed a different approach to the assessment of the OBCs. This will be based on establishing a ratio of benefits (impact) per £1m of expenditure rather than a weighted scorecard covering benefits (impact), affordability, deliverability and risk. It would still be the consultants intention to assess benefits (impact) on the same principles as proposed in the approved weighting and scoring criteria: Impact on Corporate Plan Impact on Service Plans Impact on Area Plan Impact on Corporate Strategies Impact on compliance, with legal and national priorities In addition the assessment of benefits (impact) would be adjusted for deliverability and risk.

3.5The scoring of impact (benefits) will still require an assessment of a range of different potential outcomes in monetary and non monetary terms. This will be a complex exercise.

3.6The assessment of expenditure would need to encompass capital and ongoing revenue costs and would be based on NPV of the costs being borne by the Council.

3.7The consultants proposals should not result in different assessments of benefits (impact), deliverability and risk. The financial assessment will differ slightly as the consultants proposals are based on a simple linear comparison of expenditure whereas the weighting and scoring criteria is skewed to projects with lower costs.

3.8If a change is to be made to the criteria for assessing OBCs then this should be agreed before the appointment of separate consultants to assess the OBCs commences.

4. CONCLUSION

4.1It is not anticipated a change to the assessment approach proposed by the consultants would result in a radically different outcome to the assessment stage, however the ratio approach may make the end result clearer and more understandable.

Bruce West Head of Strategic Finance 20 March 2008 Report/20marchtowncentre&waterfrontprojects

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
TOWN CENTRE AND WATERFRONT PROJECT: SCORING CRITERIAReport 51 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
2MINUTESOn the agenda 3LEADER'S REPORTNoted 4EDUCATION AND LIFELONG LEARNINGNoted 5CONSULTATION ON THE PROPOSED RURAL SCHOOLS (SCOTLAND) BILLNoted 6MEMBERSHIP OF LOCAL ATTENDANCE COUNCILSAgreed 7REVENUE BUDGET MONITORING TO 31 DECEMBER 2007Noted 8CAPITAL BUDGET MONITORING TO 31 DECEMBER 2007Noted 9OPERATION OF CAPITAL FUNDApproved 10TREASURY MANAGEMENT MONITORING TO 31 DECEMBER 2007Noted
11TOWN CENTRE AND WATERFRONT PROJECT - SCORING CRITERIAThis decision
12SOCIAL SERVICESNoted 13ARTS, LEISURE AND CULTURENoted 14HOUSING DEVELOPMENT AT KILMUNAgreed 15FORMER LOCHGILPHEAD HIGH SCHOOL/MID ARGYLL SPORTS CENTRE SITEPrivate 16ARROCHAR HALL - THREE VILLAGES COMMUNITY CAMPUSAgreed 17LOCAL HEALTHCARE BILL - CONSULTATIONAgreed 18SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT NEW RELOCATION POLICY AND ASSET MANAGEMENT REPORTAgreed 19CROFTERS (SCOTLAND) ACT 1993 AND CROFTING REFORM ETC ACT 2007: CONSULTATION ON DESIGNATION OF NEW AREAS FOR CROFTINGAgreed 20SIGNIFICANT WATER MANAGEMENT ISSUES IN THE SCOTLAND RIVER BASIN DISTRICT: CONSULTATION BY SEPANoted 21JURA LANDSCAPE CAPACITY STUDYNoted 22SCOTTISH PLANNING POLICY 3 - PLANNING FOR HOUSINGApproved 23DRAFT REGULATIONS ON PLANNING HIERARCHY - CONSULTATIONNoted 24aRoad Equivalent Tariff (RET) - Proposed Pilot SchemeNoted 24bInquiry into Ferry Services in ScotlandNoted 24cExtract from Minutes of Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Area Committee 5 March 2008Noted 25STRATEGIC BEST VALUE REVIEWS: PROGRESS REPORT AT END FEBRUARY 2008Noted 26SINGLE OUTCOME AGREEMENTAgreed 27ARGYLL MARINE SAC FORUMDecided 28JOHN DICKIE HOMES (HELENSBURGH) LIMITED - OPTION TO PURCHASE EXISTING HERMITAGE ACADEMY SITENoted 29CHIEF EXECUTIVE - APPOINTMENT OF RECRUITMENT PANELDecided 30DELIVERY OF COMMUNTY BASED ADULT LEARNING: TENDERING PROCESSPrivate 31SUPPORT FOR SERVICES FOR CHILDREN AFFECTED BY DISABILITY - ARDLUI RESPITE CENTREPrivate 32IONA FERRY TERMINALPrivate 33COMMUNITY EDUCATION OFFICE, 170 EDWARD STREET, DUNOONPrivate 34COMPULSORY PURCHASE ORDERPrivate 35ARGYLL AIR SERVICESPrivate

Who was there

17 of 21 attended
CH
Charlotte HanburyMember, apologies, sent representative
MA
Maureen ArthurMember, apologies
RC
Councillor Robin CurrieMember, present
VD
Councillor Vivien DanceMember, present
FF
Fiona FisherMember, present
GF
Councillor George FreemanMember, apologies
AH
Councillor Alison HayMember, present
DK
Councillor Donald KellyMember, present
DM
Councillor Donald MacdonaldMember, present
DM
Councillor Duncan MacIntyreMember, present
RM
Councillor Robert MacintyreMember, present
FM
Fiona McCallumSecretary, expected

All 21 on the meeting page

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. TOWN CENTRE AND WATERFRONT PROJECT - SCORING CRITERIAThis decision
  2. Lochgilphead town centre to joint campus active travel route: developed design and future external fundingDecided
  3. Oban Town Centre, North Active Travel ReportAgreed
  4. Scottish government town centre fund and place based investment fund updateNoted
  5. Dunoon town centre spaces for people medium to long-term proposalsNoted
  6. Town centre fund updateNoted

More from Argyll and Bute Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Apr 2012 Leader's reportDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Leader of the Council dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 EnvironmentDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Spokesperson for Environment dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 European affairsDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Spokesperson for European Issues dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 Social affairsDecision 1. Noted the report; and 2. Agreed that adoption of the Learning Disability Service Users Conference should ... Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 Education capital programme 2012/13 to 2014/15Decision Approved the proposed projects to invest the additional capital allocation of £2.126m in asset sustainabilit... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies