Decision 1. Noted the Best Value 2 proposals for consultation as detailed at Appendix 1 of the report; 2. Approved the draft response for submission to the Accounts Commission as detailed at Appendix 2 of the report; and 3. Noted the aspects where the Council may need to take early action to prepare for future audits. (Reference: Report by Chief Executive dated 28 April 2009, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
1. SUMMARY Audit Scotland has completed the first round of Audits of Best Value and Community Planning (now referred to as BV1). The Accounts Commission is now consulting on the process for the next round of audits, Best Value 2 (BV2). There are significant changes to the audit process and most of these are to be welcomed, but there are some changes where the Council should express concern. There are also some specific questions where options are presented and respondents asked to indicate their preference. All responses have to be returned by 31 May 2009. 2. RECOMMENDATIONS That the Executive: • consider the draft response and make amendments as necessary • approve the response for submission to the Accounts Commission • note the aspects where the Council may need to take early action to prepare for future audits 3. BACKGROUND AND KEY POINTS The Accounts Commission are proposing changes to the Best Value audit process to take account of lessons learned during the first set of audits, the Crerar review and the report from the Reducing Burdens Action Group (RBAG). The proposed changes include: more attention paid to service impacts; greater integration with other scrutiny bodies (HMIE, SWIA, SHR, Care Commission, NHS QIS and HMICS); a risk based approach based on a Scrutiny Risk Assessment by the scrutiny bodies; and greater self evaluation/assessment by councils. Most of the proposed changes are to be welcomed; in particular proportionate audits based on assessed risk and the shift in balance to include more information and evidence on what is delivered by council services. The amount of information required by the scrutiny bodies is unclear. 4. EARLY ACTIONS
1 The proposed changes to the audit process will be tested by five pathfinder councils – Angus, Dundee, East Ayrshire, Highland and Scottish Borders. There are some aspects where the Council might want to consider early action – especially as some are already flagged up by the New SPI1 Direction. The New SPI Direction has two main aspects where early action may be beneficial: • The greater emphasis on public performance reporting. In effect the Council is expected to publish more comprehensive information more often and to ensure that the information that is published is relevant to the needs of local people • Expected developments focused on measures about the cost of services. These are not part of the Direction at present, but will be coming in future The Scrutiny Risk Assessment and evidence to be used by scrutiny bodies places a much greater emphasis on self evaluation/assessment. The Accounts Commission is not concerned about the method used, but does expect to see more self evaluation activity. Some of the self evaluation may be completed in partnership with scrutiny bodies as “assisted self-evaluation” One possible consequence of these changes is that whilst councils may experience fewer audits, there will be more activity to prepare and provide information to keep the Scrutiny Risk Assessment low. Without a detailed assessment, the implication is that there are probably no resource savings for the Council from the new approach and potentially additional demands to publish more information. 5. CONCLUSIONS Overall the changes proposed by the Accounts Commission appear to offer an improved Best Value audit process. There are other related aspects where early action to prepare for future audits would be beneficial. 6. IMPLICATIONS
Policy: None Financial: The financial impact is unclear, although the Accounts Commission have committed to keep overall costs within existing levels. Lower risk councils should experience a reduction in costs to service audits. Personnel: None Equality Impact Not required Assessment:
1 SPI – statutory performance indicator
2 SALLY REID Chief Executive 28 April 2009
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.