Decision Agreed to approve the use of MEAT applied in accordance with EU Tendering Law as the basis of the award of all school bus contracts. (Reference: Joint report by Director of Community Services and Director of Development Services dated 30 April 2009 (Amended), tabled)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
1.1This report provides further clarification on issues raised at the meeting of 16 April 2009 when members decided to continue this matter. The issues addressed herein are:
(i) Current arrangements for tendering of pupil transport
(ii) Proposed assessment factors to reflect additionality inherent in certain tenders.
1.2The purpose of this report is to recommend that instead of allocating the contracts referred to on the basis of price alone, these should be awarded on the grounds of the Most Economically Advantageous Tender (MEAT).
Recommendation
2.1Members are asked to:
Approve the use of MEAT applied in accordance with EU Tendering Law as the basis of the award of all school bus contracts.
3.0DETAIL
3.1The recommendations agreed by the Council’s Social Affairs PPG of 9th March were as follows:-
(a) To note the outcome of the initial tendering round
(b) In light of this, agree that the tender evaluation criteria should be revisited and re-drafted to take account of factors such as:
(i) The impact on availability of Pupil Transport minibuses for use by schools in delivering curricular/extra curricular activities. (ii) The impact on the availability of Pupil Transport minibuses for community use outwith operational periods. (iii) Incorporating like for like service requirements in tender specifications; and
(c) Agree a further report on revisions to tender evaluation criteria come to a future meeting
D:\moderngov\data\published\Intranet\C00000376\M00003657\AI00046521\AmendedreporttabledatmeetingBus21509SchoolTransportTenderingv53 an20.doc 3.2 Table 1 below sets out the current transport contracts in place:
Table 1 Breakdown of Transport provision Joint local bus service and school transport 39 Local service and community transport 15 Total schools pupils only transport 185 In house school pupil service (55 ) External school pupil contractors (130) Total transport contracts 238
3.3The current arrangements for tendering are as follows: • Contract end dates are staggered so that only a certain number of contracts require to be renewed each year. • Specifications for all contracts advise prospective tenderers of: - number of pupils to be transported, where they are to be picked up and set down - specified times (usually based on an optimum time) but being allowed to deviate within a fifteen minute time band. • Tenders must be compliant tender for the contract as specified • Tenderers may submit any other option tenders or variations which they wish the Council to consider. • Tenderers can often offer the Council a more economic price by inter alia operating to a slightly different time, packaging two or three contracts together to give economies of scale, merging journeys by use of a larger vehicle. • All tenders received are subjected to the same equitable evaluation process.
3.4In addition, the Internal Audit report of August 2007 requires: • That the in-house work be tested on the open market to ensure best value • That Community Services submit a benchmark price for every contract involving the transport of school pupils. This applies for both exclusive school transport contracts and the school transport portion of joint contracts involving local bus services. • In house service prices have to be calculated regardless of whether or not Community Services can actually undertake the work. This is to provide a benchmark.
3.5A separate procedure already exists for Members to deal with deciding the joint school and local service contracts in cases where the Community Services price for the school portion of the contract is less than the private sector tender.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.