Decision The Executive agreed:- 1. To note that the supermarket will be closed for refurbishment from 7 May to late July, offering a chance to complete the pipeline works within the car park with minimal disruption to the store’s users; 2. To note the risks as set out in section 3.8 of the report; 3. That formal business case approval is not appropriate for this part of the project; and 4. To give authority to proceed with a construction contract for the pipeline within the car park. (Reference: Report by Director of Operational Services dated 13 May 2009, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
This paper seeks authority to procure construction services to undertake the section of the overall Milton Burn Flood Prevention Scheme within the supermarket car park in John Street, Dunoon, in light of the temporary closure of the premises.
Recommendations
That it is noted that the supermarket will be closed for refurbishment from 7 May to late July and this offers a chance to complete the pipeline works within the car park with minimal disruption to the store’s users;
The risks as set out in section 3.8 are noted;
That it is agreed that formal business case approval is not appropriate for this part of the project;
That authority is given to proceed with a construction contract for the pipeline within the car park.
3. DETAILS
3.1The scheme for Milton Burn Flood Prevention has been in the Council’s Capital programme for several years with the construction currently planned for 2010, subject to the necessary consents being obtained. The current budget for the project is £2m. The overall scheme includes new training walls/inverts to various sections of the burn and the installation of a flood relief pipe below the supermarket car park and under John Street down to the sea. It is estimated that the overall cost of all of this work will be over £4m and consequently cannot be constructed from within the present allocation. To provide flood relief as soon as possible, the scheme is being considered in two phases – firstly the pipe and works in the burn upstream of the pipe and secondly works downstream of the pipe. The second part of the works could only proceed once funding has been secured. The supermarket is currently closed for renovations and the opportunity has arisen at very short notice to complete the pipework under the car park. The estimated cost of this is less than £200,000. Morrisons have recently taken possession of the shop from Somerfield and the premises will be closed for renovation works from 7 May until approximately late July 2009.
1 3.2 The closure means that there will be no customers using the car park and the opportunity exists to construct the pipeline works with minimal disruption to the users of the store. This will mean that there will be no compensation due for any loss of business provided that the works are completed within the timescale.
3.3Initial discussions with the store indicate that they would very much support the work being done during the closure rather than after the store has reopened. The local members also support taking this opportunity.
3.4The Milton Burn Flood Prevention Project has been on the Council’s capital programme for several years and the new business case process for such schemes has yet to be formally started for the project. The timescale of opportunity that has arisen does not allow for the approval of the business case. The proposed works would have no flood relief benefit in themselves. This would only be obtained when the remaining part of the pipeline and river works are completed which would follow on from the approval of the business case, which is planned for submission to the Executive in the summer of this year. Subject to approval of the necessary consents, a construction is expected to start in 2010.
3.5The timing of the works is crucial to meet with Morrison’s store closure period. There are many matters still to be resolved including formal permission and agreement of terms with Morrison, final design line and level of the pipeline, confirmation that the necessary materials can be delivered within the timescale and procurement of a contractor.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.