CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Executive, Thursday 19 April 2012 at 10.00am

HOUSE OF COMMONS SCOTTISH AFFAIRS COMMITTEE - THE CROWN ESTATE IN SCOTLAND

Noted Executive 1 paper

Executive noted this item on Thursday 19 April 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item15

Resolved

Decision Noted the content of the report. (Reference: Report by Executive Director – Development and Infrastructure Services dated April 2012, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Summary

1.1In January 2011 the Scottish Affairs Committee launched their inquiry into the Scotland Bill with a specific focus on the provision in the Bill for increased tax raising and borrowing powers for the Scottish Parliament. As a consequence of the volume of submissions that were received which specifically related to the Crown Estate Commission (CEC) and the issue of tax raising and borrowing powers, the Committee decided to launch a separate inquiry into the Crown Estate in Scotland.

1.2The formal terms of reference for the inquiry were published on 12 May 2011 and related to:

• The management and governance of the Crown Estate in Scotland • The role and mandate of the CEC and • The interaction between the CEC and UK, devolved and local government

In addition the inquiry invited responses to a number of specific questions relating to the CEC. The Committee also visited Inverness, Orkney, Shetland, Caithness, Stirling, Tiree, Barra, the Isle of Lewis, Glasgow and Edinburgh and took evidence from a number of individuals and organisations including the Highlands and Islands Convenors

1.3The purpose of this report is to inform members as to the findings of the inquiry by the House of Commons Scottish Affairs Committee into the Crown Estate in Scotland.

. 2.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

2.1It is recommended that Members: (i) Note the contents of this report.

1 3.0 BACKGROUND

3.1The Official report by the Scottish Affairs Committee was published on Monday 19 March 2012. The report examines the Crown Estate Commissioner’s ( CEC’s) management of Crown estate property, rights and interests which make up the Crown Estate (CE) in Scotland. For the purposes of the inquiry the CEC’s operations are split into two categories:

• Ancient possessions/responsibilities and • Modern activities relating to the buying and selling and management of property and land

3.2The report recognises that there are major issues relative to the CEC’s management of its responsibilities, particularly in relation to the seabed and foreshore (these were not found to apply to the urban and rural estate). The issues identified include:

• lack of accountability, communication and consultation with communities • inappropriateness of the CEC’s statutory remit for its responsibilities in the marine environment • cash leakage from the local economies and • other adverse impacts arising from the way the CEC operates

These were identified together with a limited benefit in Scotland from the CEC’s involvement.

3.3In conclusion the report states that the only way to address these issues is for the CEC’s responsibility for the administration and revenues of the ancient Crown property, rights and interest in Scotland to be ended, these responsibilities to be devolved and then decentralised as far as possible. The report recognises that simple centralising these responsibilities in Edinburgh would be insufficient and would not address the fundamental problems identified.

3.4The inquiry concludes that devolution to Holyrood should be conditional upon an agreement between the Secretary of State for Scotland and the Scottish Government on how such a scheme of subsidiarity to local authorities and local community levels should be implemented.

3.5It is recommended that the CEC continue to operate as a commercial developer on a UK wide basis

3.6The report recognises that the basis for the arrangements as regards the Scottish Crown property rights and responsibilities requires further consultation however it is stated in the report that this consultation should proceed on the basis of the proposal’s set out by the Highlands

2 and Islands local authorities in regard to providing a clear framework on which to base discussions relative to future arrangements.

3.3The Scottish Affairs Committee have recommendation that:

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
HOUSE OF COMMONS SCOTTISH AFFAIRS COMMITTEE: THE CROWN ESTATE IN SCOTLANDReport 79 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
3aExecutive - 8 March 2012On the agenda 3bEducation Joint Negotiating Committee - 20 March 2012On the agenda 4LEADER'S REPORTNoted 5ENVIRONMENTNoted 6EUROPEAN AFFAIRSNoted 7SOCIAL AFFAIRSNoted 8EDUCATION CAPITAL PROGRAMME 2012/13 TO 2014/15Approved 9SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT - FUNDING OF SCHOOLS FOR THE FUTURE PROJECTS; PROPOSED NEW SCHOOL FACILITIES FOR DUNOON AND CAMPBELTOWN; GOVERNANCE AND OTHER MATTERSNoted 10NPDO SCHOOLS PROJECT PROGRESS REPORTNoted 11EARMARKING OF THE GENERAL FUND RESERVEApproved 12MAXIMISING ATTENDANCE POLICY AND PROCEDURESAgreed 13SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION IN THE EUROPEAN COMMISSIONS' PROPOSALS FOR THE FUTURE COMMON AGRICULTURAL POLICY 2014 - 2020Approved 14COUNCIL RESPONSE TO THE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT DRAFT FERRIES PLANNoted
15HOUSE OF COMMONS SCOTTISH AFFAIRS COMMITTEE - THE CROWN ESTATE IN SCOTLANDThis decision
16PUBLIC TRANSPORT - DISCRETIONARY FUNDINGNoted 17PROPOSALS FOR DISBURSEMENT OF INCREASED FUNDING FOR COMMUNITY COUNCILSDecided 18COASTAL COMMUNITIES FUNDDecided 19ARGYLL AND BUTE LANDSCAPE WIND ENERGY CAPACITY STUDYApproved 20CHIEF SOCIAL WORK OFFICERNoted 21EXTERNAL INSPECTION / AUDIT REPORTING: JULY TO DECEMBER 2011Noted 22CARBON MANAGEMENT PLAN (2009 - 2014) - 2011 UPDATENoted 23SCOTLAND'S CLIMATE CHANGE DECLARATIONNoted 24STRATEGIC HOUSING INVESTMENT PLAN (SHIP) 2012 - 15Noted 29TheOn the agenda 26STRATEGIC HOUSING FUND LOAN APPLICATIONPrivate 27DUNOON CHORD WATERFRONT PROJECT - BUSINESS CASEPrivate 28ACTUAL REALITY - OCCUPATION OF ARDENTINNY - CASTLE TOWARDPrivate 29WASTE PPP - CURRENT POSITION WITH SHANKS - VARIATIONS IN PRACTICAL EFFECTPrivate

Who was there

15 of 22 attended
MA
Maureen ArthurMember, present
RC
Councillor Rory ColvilleMember, present
WC
William CrossanMember, present
RC
Councillor Robin CurrieMember, present
VD
Councillor Vivien DanceMember, present
LG
Councillor Louise Glen-LeeMember, present
WH
William HamiltonMember, apologies
AH
Councillor Alison HayMember, present
DM
Councillor Duncan MacIntyreMember, present
RM
Councillor Robert MacintyreMember, apologies
NM
Councillor Neil MackayMember, apologies
DM
Councillor Donald MacMillan BEMMember, absent

All 22 on the meeting page

More from Argyll and Bute Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Apr 2012 Leader's reportDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Leader of the Council dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 EnvironmentDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Spokesperson for Environment dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 European affairsDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Spokesperson for European Issues dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 Social affairsDecision 1. Noted the report; and 2. Agreed that adoption of the Learning Disability Service Users Conference should ... Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 Education capital programme 2012/13 to 2014/15Decision Approved the proposed projects to invest the additional capital allocation of £2.126m in asset sustainabilit... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies