CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Blaby District Council
Council, Tuesday 18 November 2014

Recommendations of the Scrutiny Commission: Review of Reports to Council Committees & Council Agendas

Approved Committee 1 paper

Council approved this item on Tuesday 18 November 2014. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item173

Resolved

DECISIONS 1. That the new report template attached at Appendix 1 be adopted and implemented for use at all Council Committee; 2. That the running order of the agenda template for Council be amended as follows: a) That Presentations to Council be given after the Leaders Statement; b) That Section 5 – Members’ Questions be moved to follow ‘Questions from the Public’ c) The title of Section 6 be amended to read ‘Motions, Consultations and Members’ Feedback’ 3. That the notice period required for Members to place a question to Council be amended to five working days and that the Portfolio Holder be required to table a written response at the meeting. 4. That appropriate training for Officers is arranged to enable the new report format and content to be introduced from January 2015, with all reports to Committees using the new format from March 2015. 5. That delegated authority be given to the Corporate Services Group Manager to make minor amendments as lessons are learned from the introduction of the report templates. Reasons: 1. To improve the readability and accessibility of reports to all Council Committees. 2. The report will help the Council meet the increasing requirement for greater transparency in providing information and decision making. 3. Members’ feedback to the Scrutiny Working Group was that 3 Days was not enough notice to submit a question to Council.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting. Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Blaby's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council

Purpose of report

1.1This report provides information on a Scrutiny review into the content and appearance of reports to Council and its committees. This review also considered the running order of agenda for Council.

1.2The Review sought to address concerns from members that too many reports were written in a way that made them difficult to understand and therefore both members and the public might not understood their implications.

1.3Democratic Services’ Officers supported Scrutiny in this work and together have developed a new report template that will, if adopted, produce an improvement in the ‘readability’ and appearance/accessibility of reports.

2. Recommendations to Council:

2.1That the new report template attached at Appendix 1 be adopted and implemented for use at all Council Committees;

2.2That the running order of the agenda template for Council be amended as follows:

a) That Presentations to Council be given after the Leaders Statement; b) That Section 5 – Members’ Questions be moved to follow ‘Questions from the Public’

c) The title of Section 6 be amended to read ‘Motions, Consultations and Members’ Feedback’

2.3That the notice period required for Members to place a question to Council be amended to five working days and that the Portfolio Holder be required to table a written response at the meeting.

2.4That appropriate training for Officers is arranged to enable the new report format and content to be introduced from January 2015, with all reports to Committees using the new format from March 2015.

2.5That delegated authority be given to the Corporate Services Group Manager to make minor amendments as lessons are learned from the introduction of the report templates.

3. Reason for Decision Recommended

3.1To improve the readability and accessibility of reports to all Council Committees.

3.2This report will help the Council meet the increasing requirement for greater transparency in providing information and decision making.

3.3Members’ feedback to the Scrutiny Working Group was that 3 days was not enough notice to submit a question to Council.

4. Forward Plan

4.1Yes, this report has been included on the Forward Plan.

5. Key Decision

5.1No, this is a matter reserved for Council.

6. Matters for Consideration

Background

6.1The existing report has been in use for many years and is dated in appearance. The concerns that too many Council reports were overly complex and difficult to understand was initially raised at Council in December 2013, when members were considering the Council Tax Base report. Since then it has been raised as a concern at other meetings.

6.2The Scrutiny Performance Working Group noted that on occasion a complex report had been clarified by the introduction from the Portfolio Holder at Cabinet or Council but this helpful clarification is not universal practice and not accessible to the public or Members who may not be at the meeting.

6.3In May and July 2014 the Scrutiny Performance Working Group had detailed discussions on the issues and reviewed a range of reports from other authorities. All members of the Working Group agreed that improvements were long overdue and essential.

Requirements of the Scrutiny Performance Working Group

6.4Officers from Democratic Services supported this Review and were given a clear brief as to what was required by the working group:

 Reports should present a clear and uncluttered appearance;

 Each report had to ‘tell the story’, so members and anyone else reading the report could understand from the outset the report’s context, purpose, scope and implications;

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Recommendations of the Scrutiny Commission: Review of Reports to Council Committees & Council AgendasAgenda 128 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

32 of 47 attended
DR
Councillor D. R. ClementsChairman, present
MG
Councillor M. G. BroomheadVice-Chair, present
JB
Councillor J. BlackwellMember, present
R.
Councillor R .J. BerringtonMember, apologies
LM
Councillor L. M. BreckonMember, present
KD
Councillor K. D. ColesMember, present
JA
Councillor J. A. DickinsonMember, present
JA
Councillor J. A. DolbyMember, present
DJ
Councillor D. J. FindlayMember, present
JF
Councillor J. ForeyMember, present
JM
Councillor J. M. FoxMember, present
DF
Councillor D. FreerMember, present

All 47 on the meeting page

On this subject at Blaby

Search all
  1. Recommendations of the Scrutiny Commission: Review of Reports to Council Committees & Council AgendasThis decision
  2. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Commission Recommendations on the Administrations 2026-27 Draft Budget ProposalsApproved
  3. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Recommendations: Review into Recruitment and Retention of StaffAgreed
  4. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Commission Recommendations on the Review into Recruitment and Retention of StaffApproved
  5. Recommendations of Scrutiny Commission: Review into Recruitment and Retention of StaffDecided
  6. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Commission Recommendations on the Administrations 2025-26 Draft Budget ProposalsAgreed

More from Blaby Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Sep 2016 Outcome into the feasibility of setting up a new company or other vehicle to support the generation of income streams for the CouncilDECISIONS 1. That the findings of the report be accepted and that the Council does not proceed with the establishment... Decided Open
20 Sep 2016 Blaby District Local Plan (Delivery) Development Plan Document - Preferred OptionsDECISIONS 1. That the Blaby District Local Plan (Delivery) Development Plan Document - Preferred Options, be approved... Approved Open
20 Sep 2016 Demolition of Former Depot Site, LittlethorpeDECISION That the budget expenditure of £167,582 for the demolition of the former Depot at Warwick Road, Littlethorpe... Approved Open
20 Sep 2016 Croft Conservation Area DesignationDECISION That the designation of a Conservation Area, as identified on the Croft Conservation Area, as identified on ... Approved Open
20 Sep 2016 Community Governance Review - Leicester Forest EastDECISION That the Reorganisation Order to reduce the number of seats in Leicester Forest East Parish Council from 14 ... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies