It was agreed that as neither the MO nor HoLS were present a written response would be provided. The Chair, in response to response to [name removed] question stated that as a member of the Values & Ethics Sub-Committee he was aware that concerns about the data in the Complaints Summary and the Independent Persons had been voiced. A working group had met to review the process and to find ways of improving reporting for greater transparency. The revised process would come back to future meeting of the Sub-Committee for consideration. Supplementary Question – [name removed] asked what guidelines were used to evaluate whether the complaint was politically motivated and were the guidelines shared with the Independent Person? It was agreed that as neither the MO nor HoLS were present a written response would be provided.
Word for word from the decision Bristol published for this meeting.Source: democracy.bristol.gov.uk
How would the Chair/ Audit Committee rate the work of the Value & Ethics committee in managing the Member complaints process, given that :
• the Monitoring Officer and Head of Legal Services (Tim O'Gara / Nancy Rollason) have appointed 3 Independent Persons unlawfully • the Head of Legal Services failed to mention a critical Ombudsman report in her annual case management report • the Head of Legal Services failed to mention that this Ombudsman report required the authority to amend its Members' complaints policy, which was to be discussed at a V&E meeting • the Head of Legal Services misled Councillors at V&E committee by stating, when questioned by Cllr Goodman, that the annual case management report was in the same format as previous years. This is untrue, and as the author of that report, every year for the past 5 + years she would know that. The HOLS omitted key dates from this year's report to obscure the fact that some complaints are taking over 5 months just to be assessed ( that is just to decide whether the matter is a valid complaint) • the Independent Member who chairs V&E ([name removed]) told the public raising concerns that he thinks the management of the member complaints process is "very good".
For the Audit Committee to respond
Q2. What are the names of the 3 individuals that the Monitoring Officer says that he appointed to member complaints cases since 2019 ( in his response to my supplementary question to V&E committee 3 November 2023)?
Why are these names being kept secret by the Monitoring Officer and the Head of Legal Services, who appointed them unlawfully? The public, who have been subject to their decisions, have a right to know who they are.
Response – 1 March 2024.
The IPs who advised the MO were Roger Morris ( IP appointed by BANES) Tony Drew ( ditto and now Bristol) Nick Carter Brown ( N Somerset) END
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Internal Audit Annual Report 2025/26Decision Notices would be subject to reaudit in the first half of 2026/27. ACTION: Officersto (1)improve accessibilit...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.