Resolved
Refuse Letters of Rep: 21 Update Report: Additional representations EP introduced this application, and explained some of its complex history: permission for extension of the existing dwelling was granted in 2014, and subsequent work has been done which falls under permitted development rights. Since work commenced, however, all that remained of the original dwelling has been demolished and new elements constructed without planning permission. As this work was not lawfully executed, this application seeks to rectify the situation. The resultant dwelling is the same size as that for which permission was granted in 2014, but with a side element, first floor addition, and fenestration amendments. The 2014 consent cannot be implemented, as nothing remains of the original dwelling, but officers consider that what has been built does not cause any additional harm, with regard to design, neighbouring amenity, or impact on the openness of the green belt. As such, the recommendation is to permit. Public Speaking: [name removed], neighbour, in objection The Hayloft site has been subject to a raft of applications since 2005, two of which are relevant to the current one. In 2012, Planning Committee gave permission for a replacement dwelling of contemporary design, approximately 4,000 square feet – similar to the original building. Constructions started and it soon became apparent that what was being done bore no relation to the approved plans. Work stopped, and in December 2014 a new application for extensions (part retrospective) was made, including a massive basement and ground floor extension to the rear, and major changes to the lay-out and orientation of the rest of the building. This increased the overall size to approximately 7,000 square feet, but the application was approved by the planning department without going back to Planning Committee. Construction started again, and it was soon clear that this building was not in accordance with approved plans; a stop notice was issued, and the current planning application was subsequently made. The proposed building is now over 8,000 square feet – a true monster – and totally inappropriate for an important site on the border of the green belt. This alone is grounds to reject the proposal. In view of the previous devious manoeuvrings of the developer, it is hard to believe that this building is intended to be a single dwelling: the word ‘dwelling’ no longer appears in the title of the application; the rooms are labelled ‘dining room’. ‘drawing room’ etc, but this doesn’t appear to be genuine attempt to design a house of this size and status – it would not be marketable; the design and lay-out is more suited to 12 or 13 self-contained apartments. The developer has ... view the full minutes text for item 149.