Resolved
Permit Letters of Rep: 31 Update Report: None EP introduced the application to build a single-storey dwelling between two semi-detached, two-storey properties on Bouncers Lane. The area is characterised by semi-detached dwellings, making the proposal out of keeping, cramped, and contrary to the SPD on garden land, as outlined in the report. Public Speaking: [name removed], applicant, in support Has taken all officer comments on board regarding the street scene, taking account of the location in the street. The previous comments of the Architects’ Panel have been taken into consideration, and neighbours and parish council are fully supportive of the scheme. Councillor Payne, in support Has been asked to bring this application to Planning Committee because of a difference of opinion on the impact on the streetscape. This is the third version of the scheme, with changes to the design requested by the planning officer. The Architects’ Panel commented previously that the design was acceptable in principle – innocuous and acceptable - and supported the application. The second application was withdrawn, and the design further modified with the help of the planning officer. As noted by the office, Cheltenham cannot demonstrate a 5-year supply of building land, and the NPPF therefore promotes a presumption in favour of development unless the impact significantly and demonstrably outweighs the benefits. Regarding the impact, it is important to consider the setting: the report references Page 33 of the SPD, relating to the rhythm of the street scene, and in particular the 12 semi-detached houses on the west of Bouncer’s Lane, originally built with a clear pattern and separated by large gaps. Now, however, five of the 12 dwellings have significant side and/or rear extensions, which although well-designed and constructed have obliterated the gaps. There are over 100 dwellings in Bouncer’s Lane, demonstrating a wide range of sizes and styles, including single-storey dwellings, the WI Hall, Prestbury Hall, and most of St Mary’s School. The officer report comments on the impact of the dwelling on neighbouring properties, referencing Policy CP4, but has never met an applicant who has taken the concerns of his neighbours to such length – has visited every neighbour who may be affected, none of whom have objected – the views of 31 neighbours should carry significant weight under the Localism Act. There are no highways objections either. As a ward councillor, is passionate and protective of his ward, and has been critical of certain developments in the past, but has no hesitation in supporting this one. There is no substantive evident to support the view that this development will have significant and demonstrable adverse impact on the neighbourhood. It is sustainable and well-designed, and demonstrably respects its setting. Member debate: PB: has sympathy with planning officers having to interpret applications in line with planning policy and guidelines; Members are more lucky and can take different ... view the full minutes text for item 151.