CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cheltenham Borough Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 22 June 2017 at 6.00pm

17/00365/FUL The Water Garden, Birchley Road

Decided Planning 3 papers

Planning Committee decided this item on Thursday 22 June 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item150

Resolved

Permit Letters of Rep: 94 Update Report: None MJC introduced this application, to demolish a single dwelling, The Water Garden, and replace it with two houses. It is at Committee at the request of Councillor Babbage, due to the level of interest. The recommendation is to permit. Public Speaking: [name removed], on behalf of local residents, in objection The application has been met with almost universal objection for several reasons. Firstly, it will breach the terms of the Battledown Trust Deed, which divided the estate into large ‘lots’, restricting the number of houses to be built on each lot, for density purposes and to avoid overloading the Victorian sewers and roads. This lot is already ‘full’. Officers say this is not a material consideration, but residents believe it is – because if this application is granted, other properties may follow suit, resulting in many additional houses which will destroy the Estate’s semi-rural character. This application is therefore contrary to Policies CP1 and CP3. Secondly, the application site is on a steep bend on a narrow road with no footpaths – an accident black spot. Not only will heavy construction traffic and machinery be a great worry, but the resulting increase in occupancy of the site will result if permanent additional traffic on this dangerous stretch of road. Highway officers have no objections, but the scheme relies on visibility splays on land not owned or controlled by the applicant. The application doesn’t comply with the requirements of CP4b and TP1. Thirdly, the brash, brutalist, four-storey design is not respectful of neighbouring properties, its ridge heights some two storeys higher than the properties to the north and south. It is disproportionate, overbearing, and will result in a significant loss of outlook from his property, all contrary to CP7, GE3 and GE2. To conclude, the development will be overbearing and inappropriately large; the highways risk will increase; the drainage system will be put under pressure, and consent could lead to the destruction of the Battledown estate as an asset to the town as a whole. It is contrary to CP1, CP3, CP4b, TP1, CP7, GE3 and GE2. [name removed], agent, in support There have been a substantial number of objections to this application, mostly relating to the Battledown covenant. Some say it should be taken into consideration in the determination of the application but that is not correct. As officers have made clear, a covenant is a legal matter between the Battledown Trustees and the applicant, not a ‘planning’ issue. It may be in the interests of some to draw this legal issue into the planning process, but this could be seen as manipulating the planning process, which would be deemed unreasonable. Knows and trusts that Members of the Planning Committee are able to distinguish material planning matters, and therefore relies ... view the full minutes text for item 150.
Word for word from the decision Cheltenham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cheltenham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cheltenham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

APPLICATION NO: 17/00365/FUL OFFICER: [name removed] REGISTERED: 22nd February 2017 DATE OF EXPIRY: 19th April 2017

WARD: Battledown PARISH: Charlton Kings

APPLICANT: Boo Homes Limited

AGENT: Brodie Planning Associates Ltd

LOCATION: The Water Garden, Birchley Road, Cheltenham

PROPOSAL: Demolition of existing building and garage and replacement with two new detached dwellings

RECOMMENDATION: Permit

This site map is for reference purposes only. OS Crown Copyright. All rights reserved Cheltenham Borough Council 100024384 2007 1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSAL 1.1 The application site relates to a detached property known as ‘The Water Garden’ located in a residential area on Birchley Road and located within the Battledown Estate.

1.2The applicant is seeking planning permission for the demolition of the existing building and garage and its replacement with two new detached dwellings, garages and associated landscaping.

1.3The application has been called to planning committee at the request of Councillor Babbage due to the level of local interest in the application.

2. CONSTRAINTS AND RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY Constraints: Airport safeguarding over 15m Residents Associations

Relevant Planning History: 16/02185/PREAPP 9th January 2017 CLO Erection of two new dwellings following the demolition of Existing dwelling

88/01353/PF 27th October 1988 PER Erection Of Extension

91/00079/PF 21st February 1991 PER Erection Of House And Garage With Access Drive From Battledown Drive In Accordance With The Revised Plans Received On 25th January 1991 And The Additional Drawing

08/01710/CLPUD 14th January 2009 WDN APPLICATION WITHDRAWN BY SUBMISSION OF 09/00031/FUL 14.01.2009 Proposed ancillary buildings to enclose hydrotherapy pool

09/00031/FUL 24th February 2009 PER Proposed ancillary buildings to enclose hydrotherapy pool

3. POLICIES AND GUIDANCE Adopted Local Plan Policies CP 1 Sustainable development CP 3 Sustainable environment CP 4 Safe and sustainable living CP 7 Design GE 5 Protection and replacement of trees GE 6 Trees and development TP 1 Development and highway safety

Supplementary Planning Guidance/Documents Development on garden land and infill sites in Cheltenham (2009)

National Guidance National Planning Policy Framework 4. CONSULTATIONS

Parish Council 8th March 2017 Objection: In our view the Battledown Estate is akin to our three Conservation Areas, in that it requires and benefits from special protection. One of our planning policies states that we 'seek to maintain the unique character and feel of Charlton Kings, particularly in the St Mary's, Bafford and Cudnall Street conservation areas' and we seek to do so for Battledown Estate.

Nationally, the status of the degree of protection afforded by deeds of covenant is uncertain and from time to time is tested in the courts. Locally, according to Appendix 3 (page 51) of Cheltenham Borough Council's own Local Development Framework, Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) of June 2009, the special nature of Battledown is recognised as follows: 'This area comprises large individual properties set into their own grounds climbing up the escarpment to the east away from town. There is much mature landscaping. The area benefits from a covenant which means that garden land is not subject to sub-division and intensification here'. The document is sub-titled 'Development of Garden Land and Infill Sites in Cheltenham'. This acceptance that the estate is 'special' and benefits from a covenant is clearly relevant to this application; in other words the Deed of Covenant of 1859 should be taken into account.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
17/00365/FUL The Water Garden, Birchley RoadReport 253 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
representations from Battledown Estate TrusteesAppendix 1 15 MB Withheld: personal details
PDF
The Water Garden: representationsReport 3 MB Withheld: personal details

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

16 of 22 attended
GB
Councillor Garth BarnesChair, present
BF
Councillor Bernard FisherVice-Chair, present
PB
Councillor Paul BakerCommittee Member, present
MC
Councillor Mike CollinsCommittee Member, present
CH
Councillor Colin HayCommittee Member, present
KH
Councillor Karl HobleyCommittee Member, present
AL
Councillor Adam LillywhiteCommittee Member, present
HM
Councillor Helena McCloskeyCommittee Member, present
CN
Councillor Chris NelsonCommittee Member, present
TO
Councillor Tony OliverCommittee Member, present
LS
Councillor Louis SavageCommittee Member, present
DS
Councillor Diggory SeacomeCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative

All 22 on the meeting page

On this subject at Cheltenham

Search all
  1. 17/00365/FUL The Water Garden, Birchley RoadThis decision
  2. 15/01086/FUL Garages and Parking at Ullswater RoadDecided
  3. 14/01681/FUL Land between 24 & 25 Ullswater RoadDecided
  4. 14/01700/FUL Garages at Haweswater RoadDecided

More from Cheltenham Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Aug 2025 Declarations of InterestIt was agreed that this does not constitute a prejudicial interest, and he was therefore not required to leave the Ch... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2021 Any other items the Chairman determines urgent and requires a decisionIt was agreed that it was not relevant, the Chair disagreed as he thought that it was good to see that it was a mix o... Agreed Open
17 Dec 2020 20/01371/FUL Balcarras School, East End Road, Charlton Kings, Cheltenham GL53 8QFAgreed that the proposal was positive and had to be supported to cover the capacity required. It was the best that co... Agreed Open
17 Sep 2020 Minutes of last meetingRESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 20 th August 2020 were approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
18 Jun 2020 ApologiesRESOLVED THAT Councillor McCloskey be appointed as Vice-Chair on a temporary basis. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies