Resolved
Permit Letters of Rep: 94 Update Report: None MJC introduced this application, to demolish a single dwelling, The Water Garden, and replace it with two houses. It is at Committee at the request of Councillor Babbage, due to the level of interest. The recommendation is to permit. Public Speaking: [name removed], on behalf of local residents, in objection The application has been met with almost universal objection for several reasons. Firstly, it will breach the terms of the Battledown Trust Deed, which divided the estate into large ‘lots’, restricting the number of houses to be built on each lot, for density purposes and to avoid overloading the Victorian sewers and roads. This lot is already ‘full’. Officers say this is not a material consideration, but residents believe it is – because if this application is granted, other properties may follow suit, resulting in many additional houses which will destroy the Estate’s semi-rural character. This application is therefore contrary to Policies CP1 and CP3. Secondly, the application site is on a steep bend on a narrow road with no footpaths – an accident black spot. Not only will heavy construction traffic and machinery be a great worry, but the resulting increase in occupancy of the site will result if permanent additional traffic on this dangerous stretch of road. Highway officers have no objections, but the scheme relies on visibility splays on land not owned or controlled by the applicant. The application doesn’t comply with the requirements of CP4b and TP1. Thirdly, the brash, brutalist, four-storey design is not respectful of neighbouring properties, its ridge heights some two storeys higher than the properties to the north and south. It is disproportionate, overbearing, and will result in a significant loss of outlook from his property, all contrary to CP7, GE3 and GE2. To conclude, the development will be overbearing and inappropriately large; the highways risk will increase; the drainage system will be put under pressure, and consent could lead to the destruction of the Battledown estate as an asset to the town as a whole. It is contrary to CP1, CP3, CP4b, TP1, CP7, GE3 and GE2. [name removed], agent, in support There have been a substantial number of objections to this application, mostly relating to the Battledown covenant. Some say it should be taken into consideration in the determination of the application but that is not correct. As officers have made clear, a covenant is a legal matter between the Battledown Trustees and the applicant, not a ‘planning’ issue. It may be in the interests of some to draw this legal issue into the planning process, but this could be seen as manipulating the planning process, which would be deemed unreasonable. Knows and trusts that Members of the Planning Committee are able to distinguish material planning matters, and therefore relies ... view the full minutes text for item 150.