To note that a Standing Order Exemption has been used to continue work on the Sidmouth and East Beach BMP to the value of £62,514.50 REASON: 1. Central Government updated their spending rules making them more favourable, and the current OBC no longer matches these rules and would not be accepted. 2. Keeping the existing consultant to update their own figures and documents is both quicker and cheaper than procuring another consultant to start from scratch. The consultant’s price breakdown is similar to their original competitive tender for like for like activities.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Contract Standing Orders (CSOs) requires certain steps to be followed when carrying out procurement exercises. Exemptions to CSOs can be authorised by Council / Cabinet upon report and separately by officers with the approval of certain senior officers. An exemption can only be relied upon in certain circumstances (as detailed in CSOs Rules 3.1 – 3.5) but in any event cannot be used where the EU Procedure applies.
This form is intended to be used by officers to obtain an exemption to using CSOs.
Name: Tom Buxton-Smith Date: 03.08.2020
Service: Streetscene Team: Engineers
Total contract value: £ 62,514.50
Background (including product and supplier details, costs etc:
Sidmouth and East Beach BMP is EDDC’s project to better protect homes and businesses from storm flooding and erosion. The scheme has been much delayed primary due to lack of funding, however now the project is likely to be fully funded, so we can move forward.
Due to changes in government funding, we need to update the business case to match the revised funding metholody. This includes further study to enable claiming of additional benefits which will likely mean more central government grant available. The current consultant (Royal HaskoningDHV) has completed a draft business case for the previous funding, so is best placed to update the business case. Appointing a new consultant would increase delivery time, and risk a knowledge gap. The current consultant hold all the models and data to ensure a quick turnaround of the project. Of the £62k package, approximately £30k is updating the business case to the latest requirement, including additional study and updating the environmental impact assessment. £6k is for a series of pubic exhibitions (virtual) to help inform and design the splash wall. £5k is for assistance in putting together tender documents to deliver the next phase of the project (to help speed up delivery) £22k is for a further study into beach shingle volume analysis. This was originally due to be in addition to the previous project, but has been brought into this contract. It’s addition was supported by the Sidmouth and East Beach BMP Sub-Finance group. The aim of the analysis is to identify at which trigger points the beach will need to be replenished in the future to maintain the standard of protection. This will help plan future maintenance, and is hoped will bring whole life costs down. The current programme for an updated business case is to be signed off by the end of October 2020. East Devon District Council – July 2017
Business Reasons for an Exemption:
Although the following are justifiably accepted as valid reasons for an exemption to Contract Standing Orders, they are closely monitored and should be applied only in cases where a full procurement exercise is not a viable option. (Tick appropriate boxes)
Which CSO rule?
An Emergency
Goods or Services to existing systems or kit
Purchase or repair of patented or proprietary articles sold only at a fixed price
Effective competition is prevented by government control
Goods and/or Services recommended by a Central Government Department
Extension to an existing contract for the purpose of achieving Best Value
Purchase or Sale by Auction Where the Contract is with a Public Utility Company or other organisation which will assume liability for the works on completion e.g. sewer adoption
Other Reasons (please provide details)
Business Benefits for an Exemption:
We could open tender this work, however it is likely to add another 3 months of procurement time onto the project, which will delay the BMP further. Going to open tender has no guarantee of reducing costs, as other consultants will come in from a cold start so require more time to get up to speed, repeating a lot of the existing work that has been carried out.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.