CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
East Devon District Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 1 February 2023 at 6.00pm

Sidmouth and East Beach BMP - OBC approval, Risk Gap Funding, Project Board Reinstatement and Detailed Design Tender Stage

Agreed Executive 1 paper

Cabinet agreed this item on Wednesday 1 February 2023. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item149

Resolved

the reformation of the Project Board as detailed in the report, with them signing off the final OBC be agreed, 3. that EDDC can start a tender process to appoint a new design consultant for the detailed design stage be agreed, 4. That the Hybrid Option for submission to the Environment Agency be approved. The OBC is based on this option and final amendments to this will be approved by the Project Board to also be submitted to the Environment Agency. REASON: 1. The project cannot proceed into the detailed design stage without being fully funded on paper. Due to many unknowns the project has a large risk budget which needs to be funded, however it is expected some major cost savings could be realised with further work. 2. A project board was required to make quick decisions for the project, and due to a period of it being inactive, the wish was to reinstate it with Cabinet’s agreement. 3. EDDC was out of contract with the current consultant who has delivered the OBC to date. Therefore there was a need to tender a new contract as per the procurement rules to a new consultant. This would ensure value for money and involvement from the Advisory Group to help develop the project forward. 4. The project was as well placed as it has been to proceed to the detailed design stage. However the current hybrid option still featured some risks, some unknowns and was still not universally liked, but provides the best option to progress. It was important to note that submitting the OBC was a funding allocation stage and did not commit EDDC to build the option presented. There would be additional time and resource into developing the detailed design option including consultation and planning prior to construction.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from East Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Report to: Cabinet

Date of Meeting Wednesday 1 February 2023 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release N/A

Sidmouth and East Beach BMP – Outline Business Case (OBC) approval, Risk Gap Funding, Project Board Reinstatement and Detailed Design Tender Stage Report summary: 1. EDDC to fund current project funding gap. The hybrid option was priced using construction figures from 2020 and 2021, however due to rapid construction inflation the project cost has ballooned, and the previous available funding is insufficient to progress the project. A significant rise in the project cost is the required risk budget, so it has been suggested that EDDC put £1.7m towards the project, but to sit in the risk budget, so it may not ultimately be used, or central government funding rules may change so it may not be fully needed.

2. Restarting of Project Board, and delegate authority to sign off the Outline Business Case on behalf of EDDC. The project previously had a project board made up of members, EDDC officers and other partners to guide the project through the decision making process, however the board has not been used for many years, and we want to confirm its remit and membership and place in the decision making process.

3. Requesting authority to start a tender process with a consultant to provide the detailed design and further modelling and consultation to enable us to tender a contractor in the future. The scope for the detailed design stage will be consulted on via the Advisory Group.

4. Approval of the revised Hybrid Option, now known as option 6 for submission to the Environment Agency. The OBC document is being finalised for the Project Board to approve should item 1 be approved. Option 6 has been created following feedback from the advisory group and is the best compromise for most group member’s wishes of an outline plan for a project. Once the OBC is submitted and approved, it will release central government funding to enable the project to move into the detailed design stage where elements can be modelled, investigated further and consulted further.

Is the proposed decision in accordance with: Budget Yes ☒ No ☐ Policy Framework Yes ☒ No ☐ Recommendation:

1. That Cabinet recommend to Council that £1.7m of funding is allocated to the Sidmouth and East Beach Project to complete funding within risk budget subject to the caveats detailed in the report, as outlined in annual budget papers. 2. That Cabinet agree to the reformation of the Project Board as detailed in the report, with them signing off the final OBC

3. That Cabinet agree that EDDC can start a tender process to appoint a new design consultant for the detailed design stage

4. That Cabinet approve the Hybrid Option for submission to the Environment Agency. The OBC is based on this option and final amendments to this will be approved by the Project Board to also be submitted to the Environment Agency

Reason for recommendation: 1. The project cannot proceed into the detailed design stage without being fully funded on paper. Due to many unknowns the project has a large risk budget which needs to be funded, however it is expected some major cost savings could be realised with further work. Although not confirmed, for other national projects to progress, the national funding rules will likely need to be changed, which may lead to a reduction in the additional funds EDDC needs to put forward.

2. A project board is required to make quick decisions for the project, and due to a period of it being inactive, we wish to reinstate it with Cabinet’s agreement.

3. We are out of contract with the current consultant who has delivered the OBC to date. Therefore we will need to tender a new contract as per our procurement rules to a new consultant. This will ensure value for money and involvement from the Advisory Group to help develop the project forward.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Sidmouth and East Beach BMP: OBC approval, Risk Gap Funding, Project Board Reinstatement and Detailed Design Tender StageReport 393 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 24 attended
PA
Councillor Paul ArnottChair, present
PH
Councillor Paul HaywardVice-Chair, present
GJ
Councillor Geoff JungCommittee Member, present
DL
Councillor Dan LedgerCommittee Member, apologies
MR
Councillor Marianne RixsonCommittee Member, present
JR
Councillor Jack RowlandCommittee Member, present
JL
Councillor John LoudounCommittee Member, present
SJ
Councillor Sarah JacksonCommittee Member, apologies
NH
Councillor Nick HookwayCommittee Member, present
TB
Tom Buxton-SmithOfficer, in attendance
AC
Amanda CoombesOfficer, in attendance
SD
Simon DaveyOfficer, in attendance

All 24 on the meeting page

On this subject at East Devon

Search all
  1. Sidmouth and East Beach BMP - OBC approval, Risk Gap Funding, Project Board Reinstatement and Detailed Design Tender StageThis decision
  2. Sidmouth and East Beach Coastal Defence Scheme - Contract above £100kDecided
  3. Sidmouth and East Beach BMP: Direction for OBC development and submissionApproved
  4. Sidmouth and East Beach BMPApproved
  5. Sidmouth and East Beach BMP Exemption to standing ordersNoted

More from East Devon Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
16 Sep 2026 LGR in Devon: Government Decision and Implications for EDDCRESOLVED that Cabinet: 1. Notes the Government’s July decision and the subsequent review 2. Notes the concerns regard... Agreed Open
16 Sep 2026 Financial Strategy 2027 - 2029RESOLVED that Cabinet : 2. Agrees that the 2027/28 budget process should continue to be developed within the principl... Agreed Open
16 Sep 2026 Financial Monitoring Report and Annual Treasury Management Review 2025/26RESOLVED that Cabinet: Acknowledge the variances identified as part of the Revenue and Capital Monitoring process up ... Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Woodbury Neighbourhood Plan to be formally 'made'RESOLVED that Cabinet: 1. Agree that the Woodbury Parish Neighbourhood Plan be ‘made’. 2. Note that once made the Pla... Agreed Open
16 Sep 2026 Green Team Project Standing Order ExemptionRESOLVED that Cabinet: 1. Notes and supports the exemption to Contract Standing Orders under the provision relating t... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies