RESOLVED that Cabinet; 1. Pause the project for 6 months to look at viability of other previously dismissed options, given they may now be affordable. 2. Approve the investigation of temporary planning permission and installation of rock armour at East Beach. RECOMMENDED to Council; 3. that the council’s budget contribution be raised from £375k to £500k (£125k increase) to match the figure discussed throughout the BMP process 4. the approval of a further £125k ‘forward loan’ budget should it be required. REASON: The Advisory Group were polled on the following: 1. Pause the project to explore other options, which would include investigating and delivering as appropriate temporary protection for East Beach should the delay in delivering protection at East Beach pass the current 2 year time scale envisaged. 2. Continue with Option A, the revised preferred option proposal. The poll outcome was as follows 12 votes for investigating alternative options due to greater affordability. 3 Votes for continuing with Option A. 1 Vote Abstain.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Date of Meeting 31 March 2021 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release N/A
Sidmouth and East Beach BMP – Option to pause the revised preferred (Working Draft) option Outline Business Case (OBC) and reconsider alternative options. Report summary: Following further funding eligibly for the Sidmouth and East Beach BMP, there is a decision to be made on whether to continue with the preferred (working draft) option and submitting the OBC to the Environment Agency soon to enable the project to start construction within 2 years, or to pause the project and revisit previous options in the BMP dismissed on unaffordability grounds when first proposed. Section 1-6 outlines the background, changes and arguments for and against the various options.
Should a pause be chosen, the report in section 7-11 details how a temporary solution of rock armour placed at the base of East Beach cliffs could be investigated and implemented.
Financial risks for both are detailed in section 12.
Is the proposed decision in accordance with: Budget Yes ☐ No ☒ Policy Framework Yes ☒ No ☐ Recommendation: That Cabinet;
1. consider and resolve to either:
- Continue with the Preferred (Working Draft) option (S1) meaning construction should start within two years (Option A), or
- Pause the project for 6 Months to look at viability of other previously dismissed options, given they may now be affordable (Option B).
2. Cabinet approve the investigation of temporary planning permission and installation of rock armour at East Beach if Option B is chosen.
Cabinet recommend to Council;
3. that the EDDC budget contribution be raised from £375k to £500k (£125k increase) to match the figure discussed throughout the BMP process (as outlined in section 11.10).
4. the approval of a further £125k ‘forward loan’ budget should it be required (see section 11.11). Reason for recommendation: The Advisory Group were polled on the following: 1. Pause the project to explore other options, which will include investigating and delivering as appropriate temporary protection for East Beach should the delay in delivering protection at East Beach pass the current 2 year time scale envisaged. 2. Continue with Option A, the revised preferred option proposal The poll outcome was as follows 1. 12 votes for investigating alternative options due to greater affordability. 2. 3 Votes for continuing with option A. Abstain 1 Vote
Portfolio(s) (check which apply): ☐ Climate Action and Emergencies ☒ Coast, Country and Environment ☐ Council and Corporate Co-ordination ☐ Culture, Tourism, Leisure and Sport ☐ Democracy and Transparency ☐ Economy and Assets ☐ Finance ☐ Strategic Planning ☐ Sustainable Homes and Communities
Equalities impact Low Impact Climate change High Impact Risk: High Risk; There is both political and financial risk to EDDC on either continuing or pausing the project. Links to background information Link to Sidmouth & East Beach BMP Options appraisal report Sidmouth Pennington Point Short Term Works report (Note: Report is dated 07/07/20 and reflects the situation at that time. Potential dates and scope of work not updated) Link to Council Plan: Priorities (check which apply) ☒ Outstanding Place and Environment ☐ Outstanding Homes and Communities ☐ Outstanding Economic Growth, Productivity, and Prosperity ☐ Outstanding Council and Council Services Report in full 1. Background 1.1. Sidmouth and East Beach BMP (Beach Management Plan) was adopted in 2017, following many years of work focussing on the concerns of erosion to East Beach and the threat to residential property from erosion, but also increased storm flood risk to Sidmouth Town by being more exposed to the East. The scope was further widened to include storm flood protection to Sidmouth town from the Esplanade.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.