That, having noted: (a) the comments and advice submitted by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee following its special meeting on 4 February 2020; (b) the outcome of the meeting with the LEP on 11 February 2020 in which it was made clear that the LEP would not extend the delivery deadline in respect of this project; (c) that there is no scope to undertake the suggestions put forward by the O&S Committee without refunding the LEP monies; and (d) the considerations, advantages, and risks of each of the four options set out in the Supplementary Information Sheet circulated at the meeting the Executive confirmed its decision taken in respect of this matter on 7 January 2020. Reason: To ensure c ompliance with Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rule 16 . Alternative options considered and rejected by the Executive: To modify the decision taken on 7 January 2020. Details of any conflict of interest declared by a lead councillor or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
Leader’s response to Call-In of executive decision made on 7 January 2020
Introduction The report considered on the 7th January related to one element of a £23 million package of work that originates as far back as 2012. The purpose of the package of work was to improve sustainable travel around and through Guildford. This had been developed in conjunction with Surrey County Council and the LEP.
The Executive had previously considered reports and agreed that the replacement of the Walnut Bridge should proceed.
The report on the 7th January sought additional funding primarily due to the fact that the prices quoted by bidders to construct the bridge were significantly higher than had originally been estimated.
In response to the concerns raised (that are to be considered in the open part of this meeting) I would offer the following responses:
Supporting Evidence
(i) that there was insufficient, misleading, or inaccurate information available to the decision- maker;
The Executive decision was based upon the Report dated 7th January 2020 (the report) which
contains insufficient information on the background to the Bridge Project from July 2016 to the date of the Executive meeting on 7th January 2020
Response: This project has been in existence since 2012 and has been the subject of numerous Executive and other reports. These are referred to in the report considered on 7th January (reference para 3). It has also been the subject of a planning application which included public consultation in 2018.
contains insufficient information and detail concerning the works carried out and the costs incurred to progress the Bridge Project generally to date and in particular since July 2016
Response: This project has been reported to a number of Executive meetings: 21/07/15 Exec Item 8, 24/11/15 Exec Item 16, 19/07/16 Exec Item 8, 22/05/18 Exec Item 10, 28/08/18 Exec Item 4
These meetings have been in public and the reports made available on the Council’s web site.
The project has also been reported on at meetings of the Major Project Portfolio Board throughout its life. The MPPB comprises lead councillors, including the Leader, Deputy leader, Lead Councillor for Finance, Assets and Customer Services the lead councillor for Planning and the lead councillor for Regeneration. A summary report on all live projects along with individual reports are circulated and discussed where necessary or requested at each MPPB. MPPB has been held on a monthly basis since its inception around 2015 unless agreed otherwise with the Chair of the Board. Additionally, there have been at least 5 specific presentations (Jan & Sept 2019, Apr 2018, May, Jul & Nov 2017) on Walnut Bridge at MPPB and it has been referenced in a number of other more general presentations.
Finally, meetings were held with the lead councillors for Planning, Regeneration and Finance, Assets and Customers services prior to the Executive to answer any questions. the report was also considered by the management Team/Executive liaison meeting prior to the executive meeting.
All of the above show that Executive members have had the information needed or have had the opportunity to ask for additional information, if required, before making a decision.
The costs incurred are shown at paragraph 6 of the (exempt) appendix 3.
does not contain any evaluation of the risks and assumptions around the new funding requirement e.g. The virement could have to be increased if any of the s106 monies and/ or construction savings and / or consultancy reduction is not achieved.
Dealt with in the exempt section in Appendix 4.
Contains insufficient information about how the construction savings could be achieved and what would have to be sacrificed in order to do so.
Dealt with in the exempt section in Appendix 4.
States in para 10.1 ‘…however, the carbon cost of constructing a new bridge is currently not measurable.’ We believe that it is possible to estimate such costs. A quick look at google reveals a few different tools.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.