Notwithstanding the Committee accepted this was prima facie inappropriate development in the green belt, the Committee considered there were very special circumstances that outweighed the potential harm to the green belt as follows: a. The extenuating circumstances during the consented conversion of the existing dwelling that led to the need to re-build; b. The sustainable nature of the new building which was being rebuilt using the stone from the barn that previously stood on the site, therefore to demolish this building would be wasteful and create harm to the environment, Accordingly the Committee resolved that the application should be approved subject to conditions 2. That authority be delegated to the Head of Development Services, in consultation with the Chair, to determine suitable conditions and informatives to attach to the approval to include a condition to require the re-use of the stone from the demolished barn; 3. That in the event of any changes being needed to the wording of the Committee’s decision (such as to delete vary or add conditions/informative/planning obligations or reasons for approval / refusal) prior to the decision being issued, the Head of Development Services be delegated authority to do so in consultation with the Chair of the Committee, provided that the changes do not exceed the substantive nature of this committee’s decision.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
HIGH PEAK BOROUGH COUNCIL PLANNING APPLICATIONS COMMITTEE
26th February 2024
Application HPK/2023/0541 No: Location Land adjacent to Stubbins House, Unnamed road from Stubbins Lane to Tithe Barn, Chinley, Derbyshire, SK23 6ED Proposal Erection of a stone building to provide a dwelling (part retrospective) and associated landscaping works
PART [name removed] MR BARRY CULLEN Parish/ward Blackbrook Ward Date registered 13/12/2023 If you have a question about this report please contact: Pet Twigg tel: [phone removed] [email removed]
REFERRAL
The application is brought before the Development Control Committee as the application is for retrospective development.
1. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATION
Refusal
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE AND ITS SURROUNDINGS
2.1The application site is located outside any recognised settlement boundary in the development plan, part way down an unnamed road from Stubbins Lane to Tithe Barn Farm, adjacent to Stubbins House.
2.2The applicant has laid foundations and started building the shell of a dwelling, blockwork up to first floor level, on land that formerly had an agricultural barn on it.
2.3The land lies within a cluster of residential properties comprised historic workers dwellings and agricultural buildings, some of which are in the process of being converted into dwellings.
2.4For the purposes of planning policy consideration, the application site is located within Blackwood Ward, it is in Green Belt, and it is not in a Conservation Area, there are no Listed buildings/structures or protected trees which need to be considered. The site does back onto fields and there is no defined curtilage. The site sits below road level (as do the established cottages on this side of the lane) is relatively flat, the rear part of the site slopes away. 2.5 The site lies within the open countryside and is constrained by Green Belt designation.
2.6The section of road fronting the site is adopted highway and it carry the route of a Public Right of Way (FP16 Chinley on the Derbyshire Definitive Map).
3. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL
3.1Full planning permission is sought to construct a replacement building on the site of a former agricultural building to be used as a 3 bedroom residential dwelling (part retrospective) to provide accommodation over two floors with associated driveway, parking area and garden. The barn which previously stood on the site had been approved for conversion under (HPK/2020/0152) A new boundary would be delineated by planting along the south side of the site which will form the new boundary between the domestic curtilage of the property and the rest of the field. This boundary is larger than the boundary approved when the former agricultural building was approved for conversion.
3.2The ground floor external footprint measures 124sqm (6.5m x 17.50m plus a side garden store measuring 4m x 2.47m). The first floor measures 83.72 sqm (12.88m x 6.5m). The height of the two storey building measures 6.65m to apex.
3.3The palette of material finishes will be blockwork with facing stone and slated roof.
3.4There clearly has been an agricultural building on site historically (as shown on Google Earth images). The former agricultural barn was, when it’s conversion was approved in 2020 (this permission was not implemented), previously described as a former historic threshing barn which lost its pitched roof and was truncated in height, with a smaller section alongside being lower in height with an open frontage to the road (as shown in the photographs that accompany the neighbour’s objection). This has now been demolished and the part built structure is new build.
3.5The application, supporting documents, and consultee comments can be viewed at
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.