Resolved that subject to the receipt of an agreeable offer letter from Mersey Waterfront Regional Park - (i) the City Council’s capital programme be adjusted to reflect increased expenditure in this financial year of £179,621; (ii) authority be granted for the Executive Director (Regeneration) to accept a Mersey Waterfront Regional Park grant approval in the sum of £ 179,621 for the financial year 2004/2005. The City Council will thereby agree to act as accountable body for the Mersey Waterfront Regional Park grant with the Divisional Manager (Regeneration Initiatives) taking the lead responsibility in ensuring the duties of the accountable body are administered appropriately; and (iii) authority be granted to the Executive Director (Regeneration) to commit expenditure within available resources to progress the further development of the Cruise Liner Facility project in terms of site investigation, survey and tender award.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
1.1Members of the Board will be aware of the Cruise Liner facility proposal which is a strategic project within the City Centre IDP, the Pier Head Masterplan and the Mersey Waterfront Regional Park Commencement Plan. The project aims to provide a world class facility at Princes Dock to enable the efficient and sustainable berthing of large cruise, naval and other vessels (e.g. Tall Ships).
1.2Members of the Board may also recall the description of the market gap which the project is seeking to fill. This market gap relates to the projected income from the facility which - whilst forecast to cover cost by Year 4 of operation - is insufficient to justify the capital investment from a commercial perspective.
1.3Principally for this reason, grant funding is required to deliver the physical facility in respect of which European Commission state aid rules and UK Port Competition rules apply; together:
• Prohibiting Mersey Docks and Harbour Company (MDHC) from obtaining grant to deliver a Cruise Liner facility. This has been tested previously by MDHC;
• Requiring the City Council to act as accountable body and owner of the project cash flow.
1.4The cost of project development and procurement of initial design work – representing the Stage 1 of the scheme - was funded as follows:
£130,000 – Northwest Development Agency £130,000 – City Focus SRB
1.5This funding enabled the following work to be undertaken:
£s Business Plan 20,000 Designs to Planning Application Stage 160,000 Application for Planning Permission & 15,000 Conservation Area Consent Environmental Statement & Application for Harbour 65,000 Revision Order Total 260,000
1.6The design work at that stage represented approximately 1.4% of total construction cost which is a comparatively small outlay to planning application stage. This has been testimony to the approach taken by the project, which has been to phase capital spend as much as possible in order to minimise financial risk – particularly given:
a) The requirement for clearance of the submitted public funding bid from both the DTi (state aid) and the DfT (port competition).
b) The various development consents required, namely:
i. Planning permission. ii. Conservation area consent. iii. Highway Stopping Up Order. iv. Harbour Revision Order.
1.7Following the approval of planning permission and conservation area consent, further authority was granted by the Executive Board to accept Stage 2 development funding required specifically to progress tender documentation, site surveys and investigation in the sum of £137,000; to be funded as follows:
£68,500 – Mersey Waterfront Regional Park (MWRP) £68,500 – Northwest Development Agency retrospective approval
1.8The Stage 2 cost estimates were based on similar work that had been undertaken as part of the Twelve Quays development. The Stage 2 costs have exceeded the cost estimates significantly, however, as a consequence of:
i. Firstly, the tender prices for undertaking the ground investigation within the River Mersey (necessary to establish the requisite depth of the restraint and berthing piles) exceeding budget. The lowest and recommended contract sum for the carrying out of the ground investigation in the River Mersey stands at £132,025.50.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.