Resolved that an ‘Equality Impact Assessment’ be applied to all projects (or initiatives) which fall into all of the following categories - (i) the development of a new service/and or significant changes to an existing service with a capital expenditure of £1m or more and/or revenue expenditure of £500k pa or above; (ii) the development of any new policies/procedures which have been assessed as relevant to the ‘General Duty’. (In terms of effectively managing this process it is advisable to focus on the key improvement priorities already identified within service plans); (iii) decisions involving areas of public concern (and evidence that exists which has previously indicated that adverse impact, or potential adverse impact, on any specific racial group(s)), for example; where information from a monitoring exercise or an inspection has indicated there is an adverse impact on a community in terms of lack service provision; and (iv) within wards with a significant BEM population over around 10%. For the City of Liverpool the breakdown is as follows:- · Central 16.9% - this represents a population size of 1517 which covers 0.3% of the total population of Liverpool; · Picton 17.9% - this represents a population size of 2900 which covers 0.6% of the total population of Liverpool; · Princes Park 31.9% - this represents a population size of 4334 which covers 0.89% of the total population of Liverpool; · Greenbank 11.1% - this represents a population size of 1553 which covers 0.31% of the total population of Liverpool; and · Kensington / Fairfield 9.6% - this represents a population size of 1369 which covers 0.2% of the total population of Liverpool.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
1. The amended Race Relations Act came into force in May 2002. As a result all local authorities were required to publish a Race Equality Scheme. They were also required to identify how they would assess their policies and functions in the areas of employment and service delivery for an adverse effect to communities.
As a result a report was presented to the Customer and Corporate Select Committee on the 18 March 2003. The report outlined the legal requirements and the criteria by when an impact assessment could be carried out. More importantly the report recommended that the City Council pilot the roll out of ‘equality impact assessments’ on two areas of the City Council’s business and report back before any decisions around City Council policy were taken.
2. CRITERIA FOR SELECTING THE PILOT AREAS
(1) One Stop Shops – The OSS were selected as being customer focussed and the view was that a retrospective impact assessment was required to examine whether or not the original roll out of the OSS service would have benefited from an impact assessment at its conception, in terms of providing a real service to the Black and Ethnic Minority (BEM) of Liverpool.
(2) Strategic Investments Area, Eastern Approaches – This area was selected as it was a policy yet to be implemented (where as the OSS are up and running). In addition to this the Eastern Approaches geographical location concentrated its activities in a part of the City where a sizeable percentage of the BEM community live. 3. FEEDBACK FROM THE PILOT IMPACT ASSESSMENTS
(1) OSS
• There was only limited information readily available on the needs of the BEM community in relation to the provision of a OSS Service.
• Impact Assessment process was found to be very time consuming due to the amount of initial research involved.
(2) SIA
• There was a general lack of information available on the needs of the BEM community in relation to the various components of the SIA.
• Lack of relevant information in relation to the adverse effects of running employment programmes and other aspects of the SIA programme for the range of racial groups in the SIA areas.
• Impact assessments process would have been more beneficial if the specific projects contained within the SIA carried out their own impact assessments. For example the JET services as the local knowledge and expertise surrounding the needs, barriers and anticipated outcomes by different racial groups would have already been captured by that particular service.
• The SIA programme was too large for one person to carry out an impact assessment and should have been broken down on a project by project basis. However the process would have been very time consuming.
(3) CRE (Commission for Racial Equality) – Each assessment underwent a number of re-drafts in response to comments from the CRE (see attached final drafts). However the CRE still indicated that the final drafts could have been further improved. The CRE highlighted the following:-
• Each reports contained data based on inequalities between ethnic groups but could have gone further in considering whether any adverse impact has been identified.
• The CRE also indicated that the following key questions needed to be more fully addressed within the reports (specifically in relation to any proposed policy):
¾ Does the quantitative data or qualitative date show differences between racial groups? ¾ Do the differences between racial groups amount to adverse impact and for which groups?
¾ Could the policy be directly or indirectly discriminatory?
¾ What measures will be put in place to combat any adverse impact and / or any potential discrimination whether direct or indirect?
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.