CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Nottingham City Council
Executive Board, Tuesday 21 July 2026 at 2.00pm

Security Delivery Model options review

Refused Executive 2 papers

AI summaryNottingham City Council Executive Board approves spending up to £9.975m on a 3+1+1 year replacement outsourced security services contract, maintaining the existing hybrid delivery model.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefused3 year plus 1 plus 1 replacement, hybrid model kept
MoneyUp to £9.975m over contract lifeAnnual cost up to £1.995m outsourced
What happens nextProcurement to start immediatelyMini-competition under framework, award by October 2026
Who it affectsAll wardsCouncil estate including Loxley House, Broadmarsh, Byron House

What was decided

Spend up to £9.975m on a 3+1+1 year replacement security services contract for the outsourced element of the Council's hybrid security delivery model, via mini-competition under the Procure Public Security Services Framework (CPV 79710000 Security Services). Report 1.8, 2.8

Delegate authority to the Corporate Director for Communities, Environment and Resident Services, in consultation with the Executive Member for Community Protection, Neighbourhoods and Equalities, to procure, award, and enter into the call-off contract. Report 2.9

Maintain the existing hybrid model: approximately 75% outsourced and 25% in-house provision, with no changes to the in-house workforce. Report 1.1, 2.1, 2.3, 7.6

Why

The current outsourced security contract expires in October 2026 and replacement arrangements are needed to avoid significant operational, financial and reputational risks and loss of security at critical sites. Report 1.3, 2.2

The hybrid model retains in-house capability and operational knowledge while providing flexibility, capacity and specialist expertise through outsourced provision, and is supported by Corporate Landlord Services. Report 2.4, 7.9

Using the established framework with a mini-competition offers a compliant, efficient route to market, tests competition, secures value for money and reduces procurement timescales compared with a full open process. Report 2.7, 7.2, 7.3

What happens next

Commence the procurement exercise immediately to enable contract award and mobilisation before the current contract expires in October 2026. Report 1.16

Conduct a mini-competition among framework suppliers, evaluate against quality and cost criteria, and confirm final contract value through the procurement process. Report 2.8, 7.3

Consider social value in the procurement, in line with Council policy, including local employment and community benefit opportunities. Report P64

The money

  • up to £9.975m Total contract value over 3+1+1 year term for outsourced security Report 1.10, 2.8, 5.1, 5.3
  • up to £1.995m per annum Annual baseline cost of outsourced security Report 1.11, 5.2
  • £1.226m per annum In-house security element retained Report 5.4
  • £3.221m Combined annual cost of security services (outsourced plus in-house) Report 5.5

Options considered

  • Chosen: Maintain the existing hybrid security delivery model (approximately 75% outsourced, 25% in-house). Provides continuity, retains in-house capability and operational knowledge, and benefits from outsourced flexibility and specialist expertise; supported by Corporate Landlord Services. Report 2.1, 2.4, 7.9
  • Rejected: Fully outsourced model: single outsourced contract covering all frontline security including current in-house provision. Would require TUPE transfer of the in-house workforce, remove in-house operational capability, increase reliance on a single provider, and benefits not considered sufficient to justify organisational change. Report 3.2
  • Rejected: Traded services model: Council delivers security in competition with the external market. Council is not recognised under the Security Industry Authority Approved Contractor Scheme, so it could not competitively challenge established providers; additional investment and time required with no guarantee of market viability. Report 3.3, P29
  • Rejected: Fully insourced model: replace outsourced provision with an expanded in-house security service. Would significantly reduce flexibility to respond to variable demand, require recruiting and retaining a much larger permanent SIA-licensed workforce, increase exposure to sickness, leave cover and overtime costs, and could create redundancy liabilities if demand falls. Report 3.4, P31, P32, P33, P34, P35

Implications

  • Financial: Total decision value is revenue expenditure of up to £9.975m; sufficient budget is available in the MTFP provided prior-year cost recovery is maintained or increased. Report 5.1, 5.2, 5.3
  • Legal: Call-off will be governed by PCR 2015; the framework may be used for call-off awards up to 2nd September 2028; a standstill mechanism under PCR 2015 regulation 99 is recommended to reduce challenge risk. Report 6.1, 6.2
  • Staffing: No direct HR implications: the proposal does not change the in-house workforce. Future changes to the delivery model would require separate consultation. Report 7.5, 7.6, 7.7
  • Risk: Key risks include failure to complete procurement before October 2026, market capacity, cost pressures, Local Government Reorganisation impact, supplier failure, void asset risk, and demand volatility; mitigated by project governance, framework use, competitive mini-competition, flexible contract terms, KPIs, and retained client-side oversight. Report P37
  • Equalities: Equality Impact Assessment screened out because the proposal maintains the existing hybrid model and does not change service provision, staffing or access to services. Report P64
  • Climate: A Carbon Impact Assessment has been considered and is included as Appendix 1. Report P64, 9.1
  • Other: Visible guarding and patrolling reduce crime, ASB, vandalism, damage and theft; a Social Value element will be built into the procurement in line with Council policy. Report P64

Who and where

  • All wards across Nottingham City Council Report P73
  • Council security staff (in-house provision retained, no workforce changes) Report 7.6, 7.7
  • Users of council operational sites including Loxley House, Broadmarsh Bus Station and Car Park, Byron House and void assets Report 1.2
  • Corporate Landlord Services and Parking Services as key stakeholders Report 1.15, 7.9
  • Suppliers on the Procure Public Security Services Framework (CPV 79710000 Security Services) invited to the mini-competition Report 7.2, 7.3

Timeline

  • June 2026: Finance business partner sign-off (22.06.2026), IT support confirmed (12.06.26), Head of Building Service and Facilities Management comments (30.06.26) Report 5.6, 7.11, 7.13
  • 1 July 2026: Legal and HR sign-off (Senior Solicitor 01.07.2026; HR Business Partner 01.07.2026) Report 7.7
  • 21 July 2026: Executive Board decision to approve procurement and delegated authority
  • October 2026: Current outsourced security contract expires; replacement must be in place to maintain service continuity Report 1.3, 1.16, 2.2
  • Initial 3 years, plus option to extend up to 2 further 1-year periods (3+1+1): Proposed contract term, subject to satisfactory performance, continued service need and relevant approvals Report 1.8, 2.8
  • Up to 2nd September 2028: Latest date the framework may be used for call-off awards under PCR 2015 Report 6.1

Plain English for the jargon

  • Hybrid security delivery model: Nottingham City Council's current arrangement combining approximately 75% outsourced and 25% in-house security provision.
  • TUPE: Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006, which transfer employees when a service is outsourced or changes provider.
  • SIA Approved Contractor Scheme: Security Industry Authority scheme that accredits private security suppliers; the Council is not currently recognised under it.
  • LGR: Local Government Reorganisation, the ongoing programme expected to alter the size and composition of the Council's operational estate.
  • Mini-competition: A competitive process run among suppliers already appointed to an established framework agreement, used here to test the market and secure best value.
  • CPV 79710000: Common Procurement Vocabulary code for Security Services, the category covering the framework used.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item51

Resolved

Resolved to: (1) spend up to £9.975m on the award of a 3 year plus 1 plus 1 replacement security services contract for the outsourced element of the Council’s existing hybrid security delivery model; (2) delegate authority to the Corporate Director for Communities, Environment and Resident Services, in consultation with the Executive Member for Community Protection, Neighbourhoods and Equalities, to procure, award, and enter into a call off contract for the above purpose from the Procure Public Security Services Framework (CPV 79710000 Security Services). Reason for decisions: the Council’s current outsourced security contract expires in October 2026. Failure to procure replacement arrangements would create significant operational, financial, and reputational risks, including the potential loss of security provision at critical Council sites; maintaining the current hybrid model, combining in-house and outsourced provision, enables the Council to retain its existing in-house security capability and operational knowledge, while continuing to benefit from the flexibility, capacity and specialist expertise provided through outsourced security provision; procurement will maintain the Council’s existing security specification and meet operational requirements; the proposed procurement route provides a compliant, efficient and proportionate route to market. Conducting a mini-competition under the framework will enable the Council to test the market, ensure transparency, promote competition and secure best value while reducing procurement timescales compared with undertaking a full open procurement process; the contract value represents the anticipated maximum expenditure over the life of the contract and provides sufficient flexibility to respond to future changes in operational demand across the Council’s estate; delegating authority will enable timely decision-making throughout the procurement process, ensuring delivery within required timescales and continuity of service beyond the expiry of current arrangements; the proposed approach will enable the Council to secure value for money through competitive procurement while maintaining a resilient, flexible and sustainable hybrid security service. Other options considered: move to a fully outsourced model. This option was rejected as it was not considered to provide sufficient additional benefit to justify the level of organisational change required, including transferring the remaining in-house workforce, and removing in-house operational capability and experience, increasing reliance on a single external provider; move to a traded services model, in which the council delivers security services in competition with the external market. This option was rejected as the Council is not currently recognised under the industry’s approved contractor scheme, and without this the Council could not competitively challenge established providers. Additional investment and time would be required to establish a competitive trading model, with no guarantee of market viability ; move to a fully insourced model. This option was rejected as it would significantly reduce the flexibility required to respond to highly variable operational security demands, requiring the Council to recruit, train and retain a larger permanent workforce, and increasing the Council’s exposure to recruitment challenges, sickness absence, annual leave cover, overtime costs, and workforce management responsibilities. A fully insourced model was considered not to provide sufficient operational flexibility, resilience, or value for money when compared to the current hybrid model.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting. Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Nottingham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board

Executive Board – 21 July 2026

Subject: Security Delivery Model Options Review (Key Decision)

Executive Member(s): Cllr Matthew Shannon – Neighbourhoods, Waste and Equalities

Corporate Colin Parr (Corporate Director) – Communities, Environment and Director(s)/Director(s): Resident Services Colin Wilderspin – (Strategic Director) Communities Summary of issues:

This report seeks approval to procure and award a contract for the provision of security services across Nottingham City Council's estate following the expiry of the current contractual arrangements in October 2026.

The Council’s security service supports a diverse estate, including high-profile public buildings, operational offices, transport assets and void or transitional properties, each of which presents differing operational and risk requirements. Effective security provision is therefore critical to maintaining public safety, service continuity, asset protection and the Council’s reputation.

The Council currently delivers security services through a hybrid operating model, a combination of outsourced provision (approx. 75%) and in-house services (approx. 25%), with the in-house service delivering response and static guarding functions.

The current contractual arrangements for the outsourced provision expire in October 2026, requiring a decision to ensure continuity of service.

As part of the development of this proposal, a number of alternative delivery models were considered, including a fully outsourced model. Following assessment of operational, financial and workforce implications, the recommended approach is that the Council maintains the current hybrid operating model through the procurement of replacement outsourced security services, whilst retaining the existing in-house provision. This will maintain a resilient and effective security service for Nottingham City Council and its residents.

Due to the expiry of the current security contract in October 2026, the Council is required to undertake a procurement process to ensure continuity of security service provision.

The council’s existing security specification will continue to be delivered in line with current operational requirements. Security services will continue to support a range of Council functions, including civic and corporate buildings, parking and transport facilities, markets, depots, leisure facilities, parks, heritage sites and other operational assets. The service also supports a number of external public sector organisations, including the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), the National Health Service (NHS), the Government Property Agency (GPA) and the Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner, where these arrangements currently exist. The proposals set out within this report relate to the delivery model through which security services are provided and do not represent a reduction in security provision.

The existing contract value for the current delivery model is estimated at approximately £1.995m, and subject to final validation through the procurement process. The overall contract value may vary over time in line with changes to the Council’s operational estate and service demand. Examples of this would be the Broadmarsh Shopping Centre and Guildhall which have now been sold by the council which had a spend of over £0.700m between them. However, we have recently taken on John Caroll Leisure Centre and Lenton Business Park with annual spend of circa £0.300m.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
CIA Security Delivery Model Options Review (Key Decision)Appendix 1 99 KB Download
PDF
Security Delivery Model options reviewDecisions 174 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

11 of 21 attended
BB
Beth BrownOfficer, apologies, sent representative
MC
Michael CareyClerk, in attendance
SF
Stuart FairOfficer, in attendance
JH
Councillor Jay HayesCommittee Member, present
PU
Councillor Patience Uloma IfedioraCommittee Member, present
NJ
Nicki JenkinsOfficer, in attendance
HK
Councillor Helen KalsiCommittee Member, present
NK
Councillor Neghat KhanChair, present
LL
Lucy LeeOfficer, expected
SL
Councillor Sam LuxCommittee Member, present
SM
Councillor Sulcan MahmoodCommittee Member, present
NM
Neil McArthurOfficer, expected

All 21 on the meeting page

More from Nottingham Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
22 Sep 2026 Corporate Plan Delivery – Tranche 3Resolved to: (1) approve the proposals included within the paper; (2) delegate authority to the Section 151 Officer t... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 Quarter 1 (Q1) Delivery Plan Performance ReportResolved to: (1) note the Q1 Delivery Plan Performance Update presented at Appendix A; (2) receive future updates of ... Noted Open
22 Sep 2026 Adult Social Care Strategy - Enabling Gloriously Ordinary LivesResolved to: (1) endorse, approve and adopt the Adult Social Care Strategy – Enabling Gloriously Ordinary lives 2026-... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 HRA funded capital adaptations - Stairlifts, Step lifts, through-floor lifts and hoistsResolved to: (1) approve the request to procure and award a framework for HRA Specialist Equipment – mechanical; stai... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 Recommissioning of Changing Futures Services in Nottingham - Key DecisionResolved to: (1) note that the Director of Public Health will vary the contract for the Changing Futures Main Deliver... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies