Resolved
Resolved to: (1) spend up to £9.975m on the award of a 3 year plus 1 plus 1 replacement security services contract for the outsourced element of the Council’s existing hybrid security delivery model; (2) delegate authority to the Corporate Director for Communities, Environment and Resident Services, in consultation with the Executive Member for Community Protection, Neighbourhoods and Equalities, to procure, award, and enter into a call off contract for the above purpose from the Procure Public Security Services Framework (CPV 79710000 Security Services). Reason for decisions: the Council’s current outsourced security contract expires in October 2026. Failure to procure replacement arrangements would create significant operational, financial, and reputational risks, including the potential loss of security provision at critical Council sites; maintaining the current hybrid model, combining in-house and outsourced provision, enables the Council to retain its existing in-house security capability and operational knowledge, while continuing to benefit from the flexibility, capacity and specialist expertise provided through outsourced security provision; procurement will maintain the Council’s existing security specification and meet operational requirements; the proposed procurement route provides a compliant, efficient and proportionate route to market. Conducting a mini-competition under the framework will enable the Council to test the market, ensure transparency, promote competition and secure best value while reducing procurement timescales compared with undertaking a full open procurement process; the contract value represents the anticipated maximum expenditure over the life of the contract and provides sufficient flexibility to respond to future changes in operational demand across the Council’s estate; delegating authority will enable timely decision-making throughout the procurement process, ensuring delivery within required timescales and continuity of service beyond the expiry of current arrangements; the proposed approach will enable the Council to secure value for money through competitive procurement while maintaining a resilient, flexible and sustainable hybrid security service. Other options considered: move to a fully outsourced model. This option was rejected as it was not considered to provide sufficient additional benefit to justify the level of organisational change required, including transferring the remaining in-house workforce, and removing in-house operational capability and experience, increasing reliance on a single external provider; move to a traded services model, in which the council delivers security services in competition with the external market. This option was rejected as the Council is not currently recognised under the industry’s approved contractor scheme, and without this the Council could not competitively challenge established providers. Additional investment and time would be required to establish a competitive trading model, with no guarantee of market viability ; move to a fully insourced model. This option was rejected as it would significantly reduce the flexibility required to respond to highly variable operational security demands, requiring the Council to recruit, train and retain a larger permanent workforce, and increasing the Council’s exposure to recruitment challenges, sickness absence, annual leave cover, overtime costs, and workforce management responsibilities. A fully insourced model was considered not to provide sufficient operational flexibility, resilience, or value for money when compared to the current hybrid model.