Resolved
Confirmed the decision made at Cabinet on 23 October 2012. Reasons for Decision This is an in principle decision, which will be subject to consultation and a robust business case.
Cabinet decided this item on Tuesday 27 November 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Confirmed the decision made at Cabinet on 23 October 2012. Reasons for Decision This is an in principle decision, which will be subject to consultation and a robust business case.
Item 5a
COMMUNITIES SELECT COMMITTEE
Item under consideration: Support for National Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Celebrations
Date considered: 14 November 2012
The Communities Select Committee held a Call In Meeting to review Surrey County Council’s Cabinet decision of 23 October in relation to support for the National Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Celebration.
The members of the Select Committee support and endorse all of the recommendations in the model resolutions 1-20 , which includes the proposal for a National Holiday on 15 June 2015 to celebrate the 800th anniversary. The Call In related to the £5,000,000 contribution to the funding for a new visitor centre. The full details of the Call In are set out below.
Reason for the Call In
The Communities Select Committee views with concern the decision of the Cabinet to make a contribution of £5,000,000 towards the funding of a new visitor centre in Runnymede in connection with the 800th Magna Carta anniversary celebrations. It asks the Cabinet to review its decision with a view to supporting these celebrations in a way that involves a very significantly reduced financial contribution from the County Council.
The Committee asks the Cabinet to take particular account of the following points in reviewing its decision : -
1. In difficult financial circumstances, with many County Council services under strain £5,000,000 (which represents nearly 1% of our annual Council tax yield) is perhaps better spent on other key Council services.
2. Whatever benefits may accrue from this development will principally benefit the Borough of Runnymede yet the Borough Council is making no direct financial contribution towards the estimated £8,000,000 costs. This might reasonably be considered to be unbalanced by the many Council Tax payers in other parts of Surrey who will bear most of the costs.
3. Many of the financial arguments advanced in favour of the development seem to be based on untested and potentially optimistic assumptions about tourism numbers and employment. It is of concern that no detailed business case or environmental impact assessment have been prepared or considered by Cabinet before this decision was taken. Consideration should be given to asking the Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee to undertake an investigation of the financial assumptions underlying this proposal before approval of any County Council funds is given.
4. There is little clarity about exactly how the £8,000,000 figure has been arrived at and exactly what the County Council would be getting for its investment.
Page 1 The report also refers to the need for ‘requisite local improvements to the highways’. It is unclear if this expenditure is in addition to the £8,000,000 project cost. It Is also unclear if it is a reference to fairly minor local highways expenditure or major roundabout works ,costing several £million, which it has been argued would be necessary if the Visitor Centre project went ahead. There is a need for transparency on this point so that any impacts on the County’s overall highways budgets and priorities can be assessed.
5. There does not seem to have been proper consideration given to other alternative proposals which would be less costly and potentially more appropriate in celebrating the 800th Anniversary celebrations. (Details of some of these are included in the written representations made to the Select Committee which are included in the background papers) Attention is also drawn to the fact that this project was rejected for funding by the Heritage Lottery Fund as it was considered ‘not a strong match’ against the necessary criteria of conservation, learning, participation benefits, need and value for money. It is suggested that the Cabinet should seek further information on this assessment as part of its own reconsideration of support for the project.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
item 05: call in report final (cabinet) /12aReport | 30 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Cabinet at Surrey and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 27 Nov 2012 | Members' QuestionsSix Members questions and their responses are attached as Appendix 1. | Decided | Open |
| 27 Nov 2012 | Public QuestionsSix questions from members of the public and the responses were tabled (Appendix 2) | Decided | Open |
| 27 Nov 2012 | School Organisation PlanThat the 2012 – 22 be approved for recommendation to Council. Reasons for Decisions The is a key contextual document ... | Approved | Open |
| 27 Nov 2012 | Public Value Review Programme Closing ReportThat the achievements delivered through the Public Value Review Programme be acknowledged. 2. That officers, Members ... | Agreed | Open |
| 27 Nov 2012 | One County, One Team - Strengthening the Council's Approach to InnovationThat the strategic framework for innovation set out in the report in order to build on the council’s recent achieveme... | Agreed | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.