(i) To agree that the capital sum should be allocated between the Local Committees per head of population in the relevant area (option (ii) in paragraph 2.1 of the report); (ii) To delegate authority to the Local Committees to decide how their allocated capital budget should be spent, adhering to Council policy and the criteria set out (option (ii) in paragraph 2.10 of the report): (iii) To agree that the Local Committees set priorities to inform the s106 Local Investment Programme. RECOMMENDED: To refer this matter to full Council to debate in conjunction with the report on Local Committees and Changes to the Constitution elsewhere on the Agenda (Minute 626/07 refers).
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
Governance procedure for investing capital – SWOT Analysis
Option (i) – Bids to the Strategy Committee
Strengths Opportunities
• Ultimate decision lies with executive • Strategy Committee currently ensuring corporate policy is considers all Section 106 spending. adhered to. Would place them in a better position for aligning the spending • Producing bids makes Local between the two. Committees thoroughly work through their thinking and criteria. • Greater co-ordination of investment may lead to economies of scale. • Greater co-ordination of investment across Local Committees.
Weaknesses Threats
• Does not devolve power to Local • Bid process may become too Committees. They only hold an bureaucratic. advisory role. • May lead to large amount of • Does not empower ward Strategy Committee time being councillors. spent on bids.
• Resident’s who attend Local • Break down between Strategy Committees will see a slower, Committee and Local Committees bureaucratic process. This may where bids fail. make it harder to engage residents in the process.
• Writing bids would be time consuming for officers.
c:\program files\neevia.com\document converter\temp\6d09dbaa-f204-499a- b8cc-77416c3a26c8.doc SWOT Analysis – Option (ii) Devolvement of power to Local Committees Strengths Opportunities • Truly devolves power to Local • Greater opportunity for area Committees. working not just with residents but businesses and other stakeholders. • Residents are more likely to attend and take part if capital for • Residents, once at Local improvements in their area is on Committees may get involved with discussion. the wider agenda, not just the public realm issues. • Empowers ward councillors and • Larger attendances at Local increases their role. Committees would make them a better medium for dissemination of • Ward councillors attending should information from the council. have best knowledge of what investments are required in the local area. • A process, which is less bureaucratic than options (i) and • Residents will be able to see (iii), may allow officers more decisions affecting their area taking resource to consult and engage place. residents on public realm issues.
• Provides Local Committees with a • Possibility of devolving Section 106 new remit following removal of spending to Local Committees planning to development control. could further enhance the ability of Local Committees to be place shapers.
Weaknesses Threats • Local Committee is in total control • Local Committees may be able to of the budget, Strategy Committee take a course of action contrary to will have no direct control over how council policy if stringent guidelines the allocated budget is spent. for investment are not incorporated. • How would Local Committees deal • If Local Committees are able to with situation when residents favour spend as they wish the borough as once course of action and a whole may lose any sense of councillors favour another? Could place through disparate spending. be tricky in such an open debate. • Single interest groups may • Not all residents may be able to dominate Local Committees. express their views sufficiently • Local Committees become only through Local Committees. Some interested in public realm and its capacity building may have to take associated budget. place • Situation could arise where some Local committees are more efficient • May lose some economies of scale at spending than others. Officer if not co-ordinated fully. time may be needed to raise capacity. c:\program files\neevia.com\document converter\temp\6d09dbaa-f204-499a- b8cc-77416c3a26c8.doc Option (iii) – Local committees must seek approval for spending over a certain threshold. Strengths Opportunities • Both Local Committees and • The threshold could be increased or Strategy Committee retain some faded out as Local Committees involvement in the project. capacity and ability increases.
• Strategy Committee can ensure that any large investment adheres to council policy.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Domestic Violence - Strategic Options(i) That the proposals set out in paragraphs 4 to 6 in the report be endorsed; (ii) To agree to forward the report to...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.