That the marketing of the Old Rectory, Festival Walk, Carshalton (“the Property”) be authorised for sale freehold with proposals from interested parties to be considered by the Strategic Director for Resources in consultation with the Lead Member for Resources. That the Assistant Director (Asset Management and Capital Delivery) will take all steps necessary to effect the sale of the Property in the event of a satisfactory proposal coming forward. That authority be delegated to the Strategic Director of Resources in consultation with the Lead Member for Resources for the consideration of any objections received under the process set out in 6.4 of the report.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1The Old Rectory is a Grade II* listed heritage asset in Carshalton previously used for service delivery. The Strategy and Resources Committee previously approved the grant of a long lease for conversion to apartments for letting. This scheme could not go ahead due to viability and heritage constraints. Discussions have since been undertaken with a national specialist in historic buildings as holiday lets but they have declined to take on the property.
1.2It is now advised that the best option for the property is to find a new owner by open marketing. This can include scrutiny of the resources and experience of bidders to carry out the necessary work. The Council will not be obligated to sell until the point of exchanging contracts. The recommended decision helps to deliver the Council’s ambitions for Sutton through the corporate plan seeking the optimum use of a surplus asset as the Council has no service use for the building,
Recommendations
2.1To authorise the marketing of the Old Rectory, Festival Walk, Carshalton (“the Property”) for sale freehold with proposals from interested parties to be considered by the Strategic Director for Resources in consultation with the Lead Member for Resources.
Report page 1 Agenda Item 12 Page 110 Update on The Old Rectory, Carshalton
2.2To note that the Assistant Director (Asset Management and Capital Delivery) will take all steps necessary to effect the sale of the Property in the event of a satisfactory proposal coming forward.
2.3To delegate the consideration of any objections received under the process set out in 6.4 below to the Strategic Director of Resources in consultation with the Lead Member for Resources.
3. Background and Key Information
3.1The Old Rectory was originally acquired in the 1940s by Carshalton Urban District Council and used as offices for many years. More recently the building housed an Ecology Centre. Disposal plans have been agreed previously by the Committee but none came to fruition due to challenges of financial viability and the heritage status of the building.
3.2The agreed disposal to Sutton Living was affected by financial viability challenges and the building’s heritage status being promoted from Grade II to Grade II*, a much higher level of protection with consequent costs and risks. This placed the Old Rectory into the most protected 10% of historic buildings nationally, and made it the second highest graded heritage property in Council ownership.
3.3The Council obtained external valuation advice that the property would have potential for sale for refurbishment as a single dwelling, or potentially two dwellings. These options would need a much lower level of internal alteration than a scheme of conversion to flats.
3.4Discussions took place in early 2024 with a national organisation specialising in the conversion/repair of historic properties for use as holiday lets. The organisation decided not to proceed. In line with previous advice it is now proposed to revert to offering the property for sale on the open market.
3.5Due diligence would be undertaken on buyers and their resources as well as expertise to refurbish the Old Rectory. The future use and maintenance of the property would be in the hands of a new owner but with the protection of its heritage status. These issues would be considered carefully before entering into any binding commitment to sell.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.