Recommendations from Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee - Sythwood EXE26-063
DecidedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryWoking Borough Council's Executive has asked officers to work with the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee to develop specific proposals arising from scrutiny of heating and hot water failures at a Sythwood apartment block, with a draft compensation policy targeted for October 2026.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedTo address scrutiny of service failure handling
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextOfficers to report backWith specific proposals in coming months
Who it affectsCouncil housing tenantsFollowing heating and hot water failures in Sythwood
What was decided
Officers asked to work with the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee to apply the Scrutiny's recommendations in practice.
Officers to bring specific proposals back to the Scrutiny Committee in the coming months.
A Complex Case Resolution Officer has been employed since the Scrutiny discussion to support communication and management of complex cases. Report 3.2
Why
To consider the recommendations of the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee following scrutiny of an urgent item. Report 2.2
The Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee raised concerns about the lack of heating and hot water at a Council owned apartment block in Sythwood, Goldsworth Park Ward. Report 1.1
Officers said the proposed communication timelines would be unworkable within current Housing service resources. Report 3.2
What happens next
Officers to work with the Scrutiny Committee on specific proposals applying the Scrutiny's recommendations in practice.
A new compensation policy is being developed as part of the Housing Improvement Programme, targeted for completion by October 2026. Report 3.1
The new policy is to align with Housing Ombudsman Compensation Guidance and industry best practice. Report 3.1
Options considered
Chosen: Work with the Scrutiny Committee to develop specific proposals applying the recommendations in practice. To consider the recommendations from the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee Report 2.2
Rejected: Adopt the Scrutiny Committee's recommendations as written. Officers said the proposed communication timelines would be unworkable within current Housing service resources Report 3.2
Implications
Financial: A new compensation policy is being developed, with proposed features including automatic suspension of communal heating and service charges after 28 days. Report 3.1, P6
Legal: The compensation policy is to align with Housing Ombudsman Compensation Guidance and benchmark against policies at Camden, Southwark, and Westminster. Report 3.1, P10
Staffing: A Complex Case Resolution Officer has been employed since the Scrutiny discussion to support communication and management of complex cases. Report 3.2
Risk: Officers warn that proposed communication commitments, including written updates within specific timeframes, would be unworkable within current Housing service resources. Report 3.2
Other: Much current communication with residents about repairs comes directly from contractors, which may limit the Council's ability to deliver proposed communication levels. Report 3.2
Who and where
Tenants of the Sythwood apartment block in Goldsworth Park Ward Report 1.1
Council tenants generally, who would be covered by any new compensation policy Report P5
Vulnerable tenants recorded in the housing management system Report P14
24 March 2026: Scrutiny Committee raised urgent item about heating and hot water failure at a Council owned apartment block in Sythwood, Goldsworth Park Ward Report 1.1
11 June 2026: Executive considered the recommendations and resolved to ask officers to work with the Scrutiny Committee on specific proposals
October 2026: Target for completion of the new compensation policy Report 3.1
28 days: Proposed threshold beyond which communal heating and service charges would be automatically suspended Report P6
72 hours: Proposed deadline for naming a single point of contact officer after a multi-property service failure Report P12
Plain English for the jargon
Sythwood: Location in Woking, Goldsworth Park Ward, containing a Council owned apartment block where heating and hot water failures occurred
Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee: Council committee that scrutinises housing and community matters
Housing Improvement Programme: The Council's planned work programme for housing service improvements, within which the new compensation policy is being developed
Complex Case Resolution Officer: A new role employed to support communication and management of complex housing cases
Housing Ombudsman Compensation Guidance: The framework the Council intends to align its new compensation policy with
Communal heating: A shared heating system serving multiple properties in a block
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item12
Resolved
The Executive Resolved That Officers be asked to work with Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee Members to understand how best to apply the Scrutiny Committee’s proposals in practice and to come back to the Scrutiny Committee with specific proposals in the coming months. Reason: To consider the recommendations from Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee.
Word for word from the decision Woking published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.woking.gov.uk
1.1At its meeting held on the 24 March 2026, an item of Urgent Business was raised by the Chair of the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee regarding the lack of heating and hot water at a Council-owned apartment block in Sythwood in the Goldsworth Park Ward.
1.2Through this scrutiny discussion, a series of recommendations were made by the Scrutiny Committee to the Executive for consideration.
1.3The Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee
Recommend to the Executive that:
i. the Executive adopt and publish a compensation policy for tenants affected by failures of essential services (heating, hot water, water supply), to include as minimum:
(a) Automatic suspension of communal heating and service charges for any service failure extending beyond 28 days, without requiring individual claims from residents.
(b) Upfront payment to cover additional electricity costs where temporary heaters are provided, issued within seven working days of heaters being provided.
(c) A published schedule of compensation for distress and loss of amenity, with higher rates for failures exceeding 28 days, and for repeat failures at the
EXE26-063 Recommendations from Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee - Sythwood
same property within 12 months. The schedule should be benchmarked against comparable policies at Camden, Southwark, and Westminster.
ii. Woking Borough Council make the following commitments, with regards to communications during service failures:
(a) Within 72 hours of a service failure affecting multiple properties, the council must designate a named officer as single point of contact for affected residents, with a direct phone number and email published in writing to every household.
(b) For any service failure lasting longer than seven days, the council must issue a written update to every affected household at least weekly, setting out: works completed, works outstanding, cause of any delay, and projected completion date.
(c) Within 48 hours of a service failure, the council must make direct welfare contact with every tenant recorded as vulnerable in its housing management system and record any alternative provision offered.
(d) Officers must commit to a projected completion date in writing within 30 days of a service failure being reported. If that date slips, a revised date and written explanation must be provided to residents within five working days.
(e) For any service failure affecting multiple properties and lasting longer than 28 days, the relevant portfolio holder must provide a written briefing to this committee within seven days of the threshold being reached, setting out the cause, the response, and the projected resolution - and copy all ward councillors on cases from within their ward specifically
Recommendations
2.1The Executive is requested to consider the above recommendations from the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee and resolve accordingly.
Reason(s) for Decision
2.2To consider the recommendations of the Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee following the scrutiny of this urgent item.
3.0Officer Comments
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Housing Operational Policies EXE26-051The Executive Resolved That (i) the Asbestos Policy be approved; (ii) the Lift Policy be approved; and (iii) the Stra...
Enforcement Agent Procurement EXE26-112The Executive Resolved That ( i ) the commencement of a procurement exercise for the provision of Enforcement Agent s...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.