Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons, subject to the Head of Planning appraising the local member with regard to the possibility of retaining the ancient boxtree hedge:- (1) The Manor House is a Grade II Listed late 18th Century three-storey house with sash windows and central pedimented doorway, which gives a symmetrical form to the principal (south) elevation. There is an existing modest two-storey extension added to the west elevation, set back from the front face of the building, and a large, flat roof single-storey extension attached to the east elevation which would be demolished to make way for the proposal. An existing mature hedge lies between the principal (south) elevation and the roadside boundary wall, providing screening of the rear elevation of the existing flat roof garage. The existing dwelling lies within Birlingham Conservation Area and occupies a prominent position within the streetscene, given that the dwelling is elevated above the level of the lane that lies adjacent to the eastern boundary of the application site. (2) Whilst no objection is raised to the demolition of the existing, modern garage that abuts the east elevation of the Manor House, it is considered the size, scale, design and siting of the proposal within close proximity to the eastern boundary of the site will disrupt the architectural symmetry of the principal elevation of the building and, given the elevated position of the Manor House, create a dominant feature within the streetscene. It is considered that the development proposed would be harmful to the special architectural qualities of the listed building and harm the character and appearance of the Conservation Area. Furthermore, the siting of the proposal would necessitate the removal of the existing mature hedge to the rear of the garage, harmful to the visual amenity of the locality. The proposal therefore fails to comply with Policies QE3 and QE5 of the West Midlands Spatial Strategy, Policies CTC19, CTC1, CTC5 and CTC20 of the adopted Worcestershire County Structure Plan, Policies GD2, ENV13, SUR1, ENV12, SUR6, ENV1 and ENV8 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan.