Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- Z001 The site is situated within the countryside outside any defined Settlement Boundary as set out in the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan. Whilst there is an existing twin unit mobile home stationed on the site, with an extension, all of which benefit from a lawful use certificate, the mobile home is not a building and so is not a permanent dwelling although it has residential use. The proposal is therefore considered as an application for a new permanent dwelling within the open countryside and not for the replacement of an existing dwelling. The evidence submitted is not considered sufficient to justify allowing a permanent dwelling in this unsustainable rural location in the open countryside. The proposal is therefore contrary to policy D10 of the adopted Worcestershire County Structure Plan, policies GD1, ENV1 and RES9 of the Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006) and fails to comply with the guidance contained in PPS7. Z002 The proposed permanent bungalow by way of its size, height, location and design would not be comparable to the existing single-storey flat-roofed mobile home. The proposed height of approximately 4.8 metres for the new dwelling would be significantly higher than the existing structure and with a significantly larger footprint and would perpetuate and intensify the visual impact of the development on this sensitive site within the countryside. The proposed dwelling would be visible from the adjoining highway and Public Right of Way and would appear visually prominent and out of character in this isolated rural location and would be harmful to the attractive and open character of the landscape. The proposal would therefore fail to comply with policy CTC1 of the adopted Worcester County Structure Plan and Policy ENV1 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006). Z003 Approval of this proposal would be likely to result in the submission of further similar proposals in the district, which would be more difficult to resist and would progressively harm the character of the open countryside contrary to the advice in PPS7.