Planning application Ref W/06/00972/LB - Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance, orangery and staff accommodation above. The Manor House, Lower End, Birlingham, WR10 3AD. Mr & Mrs S G Byrne.
RefusedPlanning1 paper
Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 12 October 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- (1) The Manor House is a Grade II Listed late 18th Century three-storey house with sash windows and central pedimented doorway, which gives a symmetrical form to the principal (south) elevation. There is an existing modest two-storey extension added to the west elevation, set back from the front face of the building, and a large, flat roof single-storey extension attached to the east elevation which would be demolished to make way for the proposal. The existing dwelling lies within Birlingham Conservation Area and occupies a prominent position within the streetscene, given that the dwelling is elevated above the level of the lane that lies adjacent to the eastern boundary of the application site. (2) Whilst no objection is raised to the demolition of the existing, modern garage that abuts the east elevation of the Manor House, it is considered the size, scale, design and siting of the proposal within close proximity to the eastern boundary of the site will disrupt the architectural symmetry of the principal elevation of the building and, given the elevated position of the Manor House, create a dominant feature within the streetscene. It is considered that the development proposed would be harmful to the special architectural qualities of the listed building failing to comply with Policies QE3 and QE5 of the West Midlands Spatial Strategy, Policies CT19 and CTC20 of the adopted Worcestershire County Structure Plan, Policies GD2, ENV13, SUR1 and SUR6 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006).
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting.Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk
Date Valid: 26/05/2006 Case Lynn Bailey Officer: Expiry Date: 21/07/2006 Tel: 01386 565328 Member(s): Cllr Peter Wright
1. Site Description and Details of Proposal
The application site comprises a Grade II Listed brick building and lies within Birlingham Conservation Area. The Manor House is also Listed for group value with the adjacent Ivy Cottage and barn at Manor House.
The original building is three-storey in height and dates from the late 18th century. A 2-storey wing forms the west elevation of the building and a flat roofed, single-storey extension has been constructed between the original east elevation of the dwelling and the roadside boundary wall. The existing building lies within a large curtilage and occupies a prominent position within the streetscene, given that the dwelling is elevated above the level of the lane that lies adjacent to the eastern boundary of the site.
The proposal involves the demolition of the existing twentieth century, flat roofed extension on the east elevation of the Listed Building and its replacement with a two- storey brick extension, with the incorporation of an orangery on the rear elevation. This application should be read in conjunction with the associated planning application W/06/00971/PP.
This application is brought to Committee and is the subject of a Members' site visit at the request of the local Ward Member, Cllr Wright. 2. Planning Policies
Worcestershire County Structure Plan Relevant Policies are:
CTC19 (Areas and Features of Historic and Architectural Significance) CTC20 (Conservation Areas)
Wychavon District Local Plan June 2006 Relevant Policies are:
GD2 (General Development Control) SUR1 (Built Design) ENV13 (Alterations to Listed Buildings) ENV12 (Conservation Areas)
West Midlands Regional Spatial Strategy Relevant Policies are:
QE3 (Creating a High Quality Built Environment for All) QE5 (Protection and Enhancement of the Historic Environment)
3. Planning History
W/05/00498/LB - Demolition of existing garage and erection of 2-storey side extension and orangery. Withdrawn. W/05/00499/PP - Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance orangery and staff accommodation above. Withdrawn. W/05/00500/PN - Erection of garage buildings with ancillary staff accommodation above. Approved W/05/01836/PP - Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance, orangery and staff accommodation above. Refused 2.12.05 W/05/01837/LB - Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance, orangery and staff accommodation above. Refused 2.12.05.
4. Consultation Responses
Parish Council:
Object - The alterations to the latest design detail and the plan footprint are very slight and therefore no improvement. The size and scale of the proposal will destroy symmetry of original building and detract from qualities of the period design. Would be clearly visible from both within Conservation Area, given elevated position, and river and countryside to south and west of the river Avon. Original plans for porch would introduce grandiose feature on what it currently a simple elevation.
Highways Partnership Unit:
No comments received. English Heritage:
No objection to the amended designs. Clarification will be needed on materials and detailing. Content to leave resolution of these matters with the Council's conservation officers.
The Georgian Group:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Planning application Ref W/06/00972/LB: Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance, orangery and staff accommodation above. The Manor House, Lower End, Birlingham, WR10 3AD. Mr & Mrs S G Byrne.Report
172Planning application Ref W/06/00972/LB - Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance, orangery and staff accommodation above. The Manor House, Lower End, Birlingham, WR10 3AD. Mr & Mrs S G Byrne.This decision
Planning application Ref W/06/00972/LB - Removal of existing garage, construction of new entrance, orangery and staff accommodation above. The Manor House, Lower End, Birlingham, WR10 3AD. Mr & Mrs S G Byrne.This decision
Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.