( i ) That the proposals to review the Council’s Constitution and Governance arrangements using a 3-stage approach, as detailed in Option 2 at paragraph 9 of the report, be approved. (ii) That the review of the Constitution include consideration of the provisions regarding key decisions, to ensure that the legal requirements are met. (iii) That the Terms of Reference for Stage 2 of the review (governance arrangements) be agreed by the Leader and Deputy Leader, in consultation with the Chair of Audit & Governance Committee. Reason: To facilitate an expedited review of the Constitution document to ensure it is accurate and effective, and to enable a thorough and robust review of the Governance arrangements, taking into account the impact of any potential changes on all interested parties. ( i ) That the proposals to review the Council’s Constitution and Governance arrangements using a 3-stage approach, as detailed in Option 2 at paragraph 9 of the report, be approved. (ii) That the review of the Constitution include consideration of the provisions regarding key decisions, to ensure that the legal requirements are met. (iii) That the Terms of Reference for Stage 2 of the review (governance arrangements) be agreed by the Leader and Deputy Leader, in consultation with the Chair of Audit & Governance Committee. Reason: To facilitate an expedited review of the Constitution document to ensure it is accurate and effective, and to enable a thorough and robust review of the Governance arrangements, taking into account the impact of any potential changes on all interested parties.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. This report sets out the proposals for undertaking a review of the Constitution and the Governance arrangements for City of York Council.
Recommendations
2. The Executive is asked to:
1) Approve the proposed reviewed of the Council’s Constitution and Governance arrangements as set out in Option 2.
Reason: To facilitate an expedited review of the Constitution document to ensure it is accurate and effective and to enable a thorough and robust review of the governance arrangements taking into account the impact of any potential changes on all interested parties.
Background
3. City of York Council, like all local councils, has to make decisions that have far reaching implications for the way that services are delivered which impact on the lives of local people. Local people need to be confident that such decisions are evidence based and considered openly and accountably.
4. The Constitution sets out the framework within which Council decisions are taken and it is therefore imperative that it is accurate to ensure that all decisions taken are within the Council’s powers and are compliant with legislative requirements.
5. The Localism Act 2011 introduced changes to the possible governance arrangements available to councils to include the adoption of a committee system.
6. Good governance is essential to ensure decision- making is effective and therefore the Council must regularly review its governance arrangements including the decision making structures as set out in the Constitution.
7. This report recommends a staged approach to ensuring that the existing Constitution document is accurate and effective in the short tern and to facilitate a more wide-ranging review of how decisions are taken in the longer term.
Consultation
8. None in relation to this report although consultation with the Executive, members of Council, the public and officers will be required if the recommendations are approved. Stage 1 will require consultation with members and officers to ensure areas of concern are addressed in relation to the Constitution document itself. Stage 2 will require more extensive consultation to include external bodies both in terms of developing the proposals for presentation to Full Council and then following the Council decision in principle, prior to implementation.
Options
9. Option 1 – Do Nothing. The existing Constitution document remains unchanged subject to any legally required amendments that can be undertaken by the Interim Assistant Director of Legal & Governance under delegated powers. The decision- making framework would also remain unchanged.
Option 2 – Undertake a Stage Approach to the Review
Stage 1 – Undertake a review of the Constitution document to ensure it is accurate, up to date and effective. This should be completed within 2 months. The proposed tracked changes to the document would be presented to the Audit & Governance Committee meeting for recommendation to Council. Ideally this should be completed as soon as possible but the timescales will need to take account of the dates of all the committee meetings for those committees who would wish to participate in the review.
Stage 2 – Undertake a full review of the Council’s formal governance arrangements to include consideration of decision-making systems available to the Council under the Localism Act 2011 which for example: Leader and cabinet Committee system. In addition the review should also consider the possible variations for each of the models that can lead to a hybrid approach, for example a leader/cabinet and committee system.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.