CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Executive, Tuesday 4 November 2025 at 4.30pm

Major Projects – Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next Steps

Approved Executive 8 papers

AI summaryCity of York Council Executive unanimously approved up to £9.934m for Castle and Eye of York and Coppergate car park works, and delegated procurement, subject to planning permission. It also agreed a permanent closure of Castle Car Park to standard parking users from 2026. [D]

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedFunding, procurement and parking closure were agreed. [D]
MoneyUp to £9.934m [D]Package covers the project and Coppergate car park works. [D]
What happens nextPlanning, funding and procurement [D]Proceed after consent and within approved budgets. [D]
Who it affectsNot stated

What was decided

The Executive noted the scheme's evolution from the original masterplan and progress on design and planning. [D] It approved a total funding package of up to £9.934m, combining Council and external funding for Castle and Eye of York and Coppergate car park works, and approved inclusion in the York Prospectus. [D] If the Prospectus bid is unsuccessful, the approved virement is £1.5m from the highways programme to Castle Gateway across 2026/27 to 2028/29. [D]

Coppergate improvements were approved to create an attractive, safe and convenient alternative, including the potential for longer operating hours. The estimated cost is £200k and is included in the package. [D] Procurement of contractors and specialist support services was approved, subject to planning permission, with authority to award and vary contracts delegated to the Director of City Development in consultation with the Director of Governance, Head of Procurement and Director of Finance. [D] This delegation must stay within approved budgets and excludes Local Planning and Highways Authority requirements. [D]

The Executive agreed the permanent closure of Castle Car Park for standard parking users from 2026, while retaining blue badge parking. [D] It accepted the associated revenue loss and future budget pressure, and approved Coppergate and potential St George's Field mitigation, subject to planning permission. [D] Castle Car Park will very likely close to all users during construction, including blue badge holders, with mitigation to be sought. [D]

Why

Option 1 provides a clear delivery route, reflects the November 2023 decisions and offers an affordable route following the reduction in available funding. [P42][P46] Report P42, P46

The revised scheme retains most of the original scope and quality while providing blue badge access, green space, play space, increased footfall, biodiversity net gain and improved water management. [P9][P10] Report P9, P10

Parking analysis identified residual capacity at nearby car parks, with Coppergate and other measures used to mitigate effects on businesses and users. Retaining Castle Car Park would require upwards of £750k and significant space reductions. [P34][P35][P36] Report P34, P35, P36

What happens next

Seek external funding through the York Prospectus and WYCA transport funds. If the bid is unsuccessful, use the approved £1.5m highways virement across 2026/27 to 2028/29. [D][P66] Report P66

Complete planning determination for application 22/00209/FULM, following revised details submitted on 4th July 2025. Then procure contractors and specialist support through a compliant process, with contracts drafted by Legal Services. [D][P8][P78][P79][P82] Report P8, P78, P79, P82

Reflect the closure and reduced income in the revenue budget, with impact currently assumed from 2027/28. [P74] Publish the required notice of variation for 21 days, communicate alternative travel and parking, and proceed with Coppergate and possible St George's Field mitigation. [D][P35][P80][P96] Report P35, P74, P80, P96

The money

  • up to £9.934m Total funding package for Castle and Eye of York and Coppergate car park works
  • £1.5m Fallback highways programme virement if the Prospectus bid is unsuccessful Report P66
  • £200k Estimated Coppergate improvements, including potential longer operating hours Report P32, P57
  • £7.634m Core scheme cost plan, with HVM still to be added Report P9
  • £1.55m Current spend on Castle and Eye of York to 31.03.2025 Report P51
  • up to £0.5m per year Estimated net revenue loss from closing Castle Car Park Report P11
  • £500k Budget setting impact assumption for Castle Car Park closure Report P74
  • upwards of £750k Capital investment needed to retain Castle Car Park Report P36

Options considered

  • Chosen: Castle and Eye of York Scheme Delivery. It provides clear next steps, reflects the November 2023 decisions and offers an affordable route following the funding reduction. Report P42, P46
  • Rejected: Castle Gateway Delivery. It would require additional borrowing or external grant funding with no clear source, add cost and delay the scheme. Report P43, P48
  • Rejected: Retain Castle car park. It would halt scheme delivery, require £750k to resurface the car park and cause a significant loss of parking spaces. Report P44

Implications

  • Financial: Closure is assumed for budget setting at £500k, equal to 25% of revenue, from 2027/28. The £86k net loss assessment in Appendix 2 is also noted. Additional maintenance and operating costs must be managed within current revenue budgets, and longer Coppergate hours may require extra security resource costs. [P32][P72][P74] Report P32, P72, P74
  • Financial: The £4.523m WYCA budget needs confirmation that it covers transport costs. Its use may involve swapping up to £3.474m of approved CYC YORR funding. [P67] Report P67
  • Legal: All works and services must follow the Procurement Act 2023 and the Council's Contract Procedure Rules. Contracts must be drafted by Legal Services, grant arrangements require advice and assessment under the Subsidy Control Act 2022, and grant terms must be passed into contracts. [P78][P79][P82] Report P78, P79, P82
  • Legal: The works need planning permission. The closure requires a notice published in a local newspaper for 21 days, display at the car park and formal variation of the off street parking order, subject to no objections. [D][P80] Report P80
  • Risk: Principal risks are cost and contract management, reputational, non delivery and loss of revenue. Cost planning, staffing, resourcing and pre market engagement are intended to mitigate them. If costs cannot be value engineered while retaining the outcomes, the final option is not to deliver. [P100][P101] Report P100, P101
  • Equalities: The scheme retains 30 blue badge spaces, including 3 electric vehicle spaces. Construction is likely to close Castle Car Park to all users, including blue badge holders, with mitigation to be sought. A full Equalities Impact Assessment has been completed, and ongoing dialogue with affected groups is needed. [P26][P31][P91][D] Report P26, P31, P91
  • Climate: The proposals support active travel, lower transport emissions, biodiversity net gain, improved water management and reduced air pollution and noise. [P10][P87] Report P10, P87
  • Staffing: The report identifies no HR implications. Project staffing and resourcing are nevertheless part of the mitigation for cost and contract management risks. [P76][P101] Report P76, P101

Who and where

  • All wards Report P105
  • Blue badge parking users Report P9, P26
  • Standard parking users at Castle Car Park Report P32
  • Coppergate car park users Report P32
  • City centre businesses Report P33, P94
  • Residents and visitors Report P10
  • Children and families Report P9, P10
  • People using walking, cycling and public transport Report P13, P87

Timeline

  • November 2023: Executive approved a revised approach retaining blue badge parking and flexible green space with children's play provision. [P1] Report P1
  • from the 15th of August until 20th September 2024: Formal public consultation ran after revised concept designs were tested with stakeholders and the public between May and September 2024. [P4][P5] Report P4, P5
  • 4th July 2025: The Council submitted revised planning details and statutory determination began. [P8] Report P8
  • 1st of October 2025: Corporate Scrutiny Committee discussed the report. [P40] Report P40
  • June 2026: This is the estimated start date, subject to consent and procurement approvals. [P54][P59] Report P54, P59
  • from 2026: Castle Car Park's permanent closure for standard parking users takes effect. [D]
  • 2026/27 to 2028/29: The approved fallback virement would move £1.5m from the highways programme to Castle Gateway. [D]
  • 2027/28: The closure's revenue impact is currently assumed for budget setting. [P74] Report P74

Plain English for the jargon

  • HVM: Hostile Vehicle Mitigation. The works protect the area from terrorism associated risks. [P56][P104]
  • Value engineering: Reducing project cost while seeking to retain the proposed outcomes. [P101]
  • Virement: Moving £1.5m from the highways programme to Castle Gateway if the Prospectus bid is unsuccessful. [D]
  • Blue badge parking: Accessible parking retained at Castle Car Park for blue badge holders. [P9][P26]
  • Standard parking: Parking spaces listed separately from blue badge spaces in the car park tables. [P16][P26]
  • WYCA: The funder of a £4.523m Castle Gateway grant, subject to confirmation that it covers transport costs. [P67]
  • Off street parking order: The formal parking order that must be varied to implement the closure. [P80]
  • Movement and Place: The wider transport workstream where potential St George's Field car park works will be considered. [D][P35]
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item162

Resolved

Resolved (unanimously): That Executive a. Notes the evolution from the original masterplan scheme to the proposed scheme as summarised in Appendix 1,and the progress to date around planning submission and scheme development. b. Approves the total project funding package of up to £9.934m, to deliver the Castle and Eye of York and Coppergate car park works, comprised of both Council and external funding as set out from paragraph 56 of the report. c. Approves the inclusion of the scheme in the York Prospectus (Executive agenda item 15) to seek additional external funding. In the event that the bid is not successful, approve the virement of £1.5m from the highways programme to the Castle Gateway scheme across the years 2026/27 to 2028/29. d. Approves the improvements to be made to Coppergate car park to ensure that it is an attractive, safe and convenient alternative parking option for all users, including potential to extend hours of operation at an estimated cost of £200k (included in the £9.934m). e. Approves the procurement of contractors and specialist support services to enable timely completion of the scheme ( pending Planning ref 22/00209/FULM with further details submitted on 4 th July 2025). The works are subject to the granting of planning permission. f. Delegates authority to the Director of City Development, in consultation with the Director of Governance, Head of Procurement and the Director of Finance, to procure such contractors and/or consultants and to take such steps as are necessary to award and enter into any resulting contracts for works and/or services for the completion of the Scheme and the proposed works at Coppergate car park (including (where applicable) any and all planning agreements and/or highways/land agreements as required and any grant terms and conditions relating to any external funding bids as may be necessary) as well as any subsequent modification and/or extension to any such contracts post-award); (however for the sake of clarity this delegation is not for any requirements of either the Local Planning and/or Highways Authority). The delegations given in this recommendation must be exercised within the budgets approved within this report. g. Agree the permanent closure of Castle Car Park to non-blue badge parking, from 2026 and accept the associated loss of income and unavoidable growth pressure in future revenue budget processes. Approve the associated package of mitigation (to include works to Coppergate Car Park and exploring potential future works to St George’s Field Surface Car Park - to be considered as part of the wider Movement and Place workstream both subject to the granting of any necessary planning permission). To note that during the construction period the car park will very likely be closed to all users, including blue badge holders, though the extent and impact of such closures on blue badge holders will be sought to be mitigated. Reason : h. To allow the progression of the Castle and Eye of York scheme to deliver this project which has been a longstanding development ambition of the city and partners. ...
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive, 26 pages

Meeting: Executive Meeting date: 4 November 2025 Report of: Garry Taylor, Director of City Development Portfolio of: Councillor Kilbane, Deputy Leader and Executive Member for Economy and Culture Councillor Lomas, Executive Member for Finance, Performance, Major Projects, Human Rights, Equality and Inclusion

Decision Report: Major Projects: Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next Steps

Subject of Report 1) The Castle & Eye scheme offers a major opportunity to transform a prominent and important part of York City Centre, replacing the current poor quality surface car park with a vibrant and community facing asset with significant amenity benefits, whilst also improving biodiversity and climate performance. Children’s play facilities provided within the scheme will improve the draw to the city centre and dwell time for users, boosting the city economy and providing social return on investment.

2) The changes would help drive improvements to the city’s long-term economy of place through improved functionality, enhanced visitor perceptions, supporting jobs through the construction and supply chain, and catalysing wider place-based improvements in the broader area. The scheme would also play a key role in weaving the historic fabric of the city together, and better framing nationally important heritage assets. Together, these improvements deliver significant non-financial benefits to the City and our communities and represent a significant investment in quality of place and futureproofing our social and environmental resilience as a city. The proposals are not without their challenges however, with the intrinsic risks that come with any major capital project, capital investment required, and impacts on Council income, and city movement. These are set out within the report and members will be invited to consider these detailed and balanced issues in making a decision on the progression of the project. 3) Following previous Executive approvals relating to the comprehensive Castle Gateway Masterplan (April 2018), the composition of phase 1 including approval of the closure of Castle Car Park (January 2020), and reframing of the proposition to respond to policy and delivery changes (November 2023), the purpose of this report is to provide Executive with an update on the progress made on the Castle and Eye component of the masterplan, and to obtain approval for the next steps including delivery for this specific element.

4) Building on previous delegations from Executive, the report sets out additional detail and business case for the delivery of: a. Castle car park and Eye of York - public realm scheme as outlined in the report, including the closure of Castle car park as previously approved. b. Improvements to Coppergate Car Park.

5) The report sets out the costs and funding package for the relevant works and/or services and seeks delegations to allow such works and/or services to be procured.

Benefits and Challenges 6) The Castle & Eye of York (EoY) scheme will deliver transformative public benefits including enhanced quality of place, amenity and accessibility in an important and central historic area of the city. It will also serve as a catalyst for the wider masterplan area and further private investment.

7) The key benefits of progressing the scheme’s delivery as recommended, and in line with previous executive approvals, are: a. Progressing a realistic, deliverable and viable proposition within available funding parameters, through the changed design and phasing approach.

b. Establishing the public benefits and catalyst effect as described above in a timely manner, whereby the outputs and outcomes can be achieved early in programme. c. Delivering these scheme components now to avoid further inflationary impacts and consequent erosion of project quality and outputs in the current inflationary environment, and;

d. Utilising available external grant funding to achieve this within available timeframes.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Item 8: Major Projects: Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next Steps: Appendix 1Appendix 1 pages Download
PDF
Item 8: Major Projects: Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next Steps: Appendix 2Appendix 10 pages Download
PDF
Item 8: Major Projects: Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next Steps: Appendix 3Appendix 17 pages Download
PDF
Major Projects: Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next StepsReport 26 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
View as HTML (162./2) 16 KBAppendix 16 KB Copy on its way
PDF
View as HTML (162./3) 144 KBAppendix 144 KB Copy on its way
PDF
View as HTML (162./4) 88 KBAppendix 88 KB Copy on its way
PDF
View item 162. as HTML 167 KBReport 167 KB Copy on its way

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 8 attended
CD
Councillor Claire DouglasChair, present
PK
Councillor Peter KilbaneVice-Chair, present
JK
Councillor Jenny KentCommittee Member, present
KL
Councillor Katie LomasCommittee Member, present
MP
Councillor Michael PavlovicCommittee Member, present
KR
Councillor Kate RaviliousCommittee Member, apologies
LS
Councillor Lucy Steels-WalshawCommittee Member, present
RW
Councillor Robert WebbCommittee Member, present

On this subject at York

Search all
  1. Major Projects – Castle and Eye of York Update Report and Next StepsThis decision
  2. Major Projects (Station Gateway and York Outer Ring Road Business Case)Approved
  3. Finance, Performance, Major Projects, Human Rights, Equality and Inclusion Executive Member Decision Session held on 24 April 2025Approved
  4. Major Projects - Castle Gateway Update (6.38 pm)Noted
  5. Presentation on Ongoing Major ProjectsNoted
  6. Monitor 2 2017/18 - Key Corporate Risks and Update on Major ProjectsAgreed

More from York Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Nov 2026 Minutes (4:46pm)That the Minutes of the Executive meeting held on 6 October 2026 be approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Capital Programme Monitor Update 2 Report (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. In relation to the overall programme: · Recommended to Full Council the adj... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Q2 2026-27 Finance and Performance Monitor (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: i. Noted the finance and performance information. ii. Noted that work will con... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Treasury Management Quarter 2 Prudential Indicators (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Noted the 2026/27 Treasury Management activity up to the period ending 30th ... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 Medium Term Financial Strategy Update (4:47pm)Resolved (unanimously) that Executive: · Agreed the Medium Term Financial Strategy as outlined in this report · In re... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies