AI summaryCity of York Council Executive unanimously accepted the Examiner's modifications and recommended that Council approve the Charging Schedule for implementation from 1 February 2026. [D] Projected receipts are c.£19m, and a future Executive report will consider spending. [P10] [P33] [P46]
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedExaminer's modifications accepted; Council approval still required. [D]
Moneyc.£19m projected receiptsProjected over the Plan Period from updated viability evidence. [P10] [P33]
What happens nextCouncil decision, future spending reportFuture Executive will consider how CIL receipts are spent. [D] [P46]
Who it affectsDevelopers, residents and infrastructureLiability covers permissions granted on or after 1 February 2026. [P64] [P81]
What was decided
Executive accepted the Examiner's conclusions and proposed modifications. It recommended that Council approve the Charging Schedule with those modifications. Report P38, P40, P94, P95, P96
Executive recommended that the Community Infrastructure Levy take effect from 1 February 2026. This is subject to Council adoption. Report P42, P81
Authority was delegated to the Director of City Development to review the instalment policy and make minor editorial or implementation date changes. The Director for Environment and Regulatory Services will agree publication and necessary documentation. A future Executive report will consider CIL spending. Report P44, P45, P46
Why
The Examiner found that the draft Charging Schedule met legal drafting requirements, subject to modifications. The Council must carry those modifications into any adoption to keep the schedule legally sound. Report P3, P94, P95, P96
CIL offers developers a predictable, transparent charge and enables the Council to pool contributions across the city. It can fund strategic and local infrastructure alongside Section 106 agreements. Report P5, P6, P7
What happens next
Council must decide whether to adopt the modified Charging Schedule. A challenge to implementation can be made during the statutory 6 week judicial review period after the Council decision. Report P81, P97
The Director of City Development will review the instalment policy and may make minor editorial changes or change the implementation date. The Director for Environment and Regulatory Services will agree publication and necessary documentation. Report P44, P45
Before commencement, services need software, monitoring, staffing, communications and Local Validation List changes. A future Executive report will consider how to spend CIL receipts. Report P46, P89, P108
The money
c.£19m Projected receipts from all potential CIL liable development over the Plan Period. Report P10, P33
£150 to £75 per sqm Residential CIL rate reduction proposed by the Examiner. Report P8
£150 per sqm Purpose built student accommodation rate accepted by the Examiner. Report P8
c.£460m Remaining funding gap for strategic infrastructure. Report P11
approximately £500m Local Plan viability gap after identified funding. Report P32
5% Administration fee for implementation, monitoring and delivery. Report P36, P92
£1m Expected administration income over the period. Report P92
Options considered
Chosen: Accept the Examiner's conclusions and modifications. The schedule was independently examined and found sound subject to modifications. Report P83, P87
Rejected: Do not accept the conclusions or modifications. This would prevent progression to adoption and leave the current developer contribution approach continuing. Report P83, P89
Chosen: Recommend that Council adopts the Charging Schedule. It allows Council to decide whether to adopt the Charging Schedule. Report P83, P88
Rejected: Do not proceed to Council for adoption Report P83
Rejected: Implement immediately after the Council decision. The Council could not prepare systems and resources in time, risking errors, appeals and reduced confidence. Report P85, P90
Chosen: Implement from 1 February 2026. It balances preparation of internal systems and resources with effective implementation. Report P85, P90
Chosen: Delegate instalment review, minor editorial changes and any implementation date change to the Director of City Development. It permits responsive operational decisions if factors change before implementation. Report P85, P91
Chosen: Delegate publication and documentation to the Director for Environment and Regulatory Services. It enables timely progression, operational readiness and regular monitoring. Report P45, P85
Implications
Financial: Projected CIL receipts are c.£19m over the Plan Period. This does not affect Section 106 monies for site specific infrastructure or affordable housing. Report P10, P33
Legal: Any Council adoption must include the modifications needed to remedy the Examiner's identified non compliance. The Council must publish the approval, and commencement cannot precede publication. Report P94, P95, P96, P97
Risk: An immediate start would not allow effective implementation. It risks errors, appeals, reduced confidence and complications. Report P90
Risk: New rates and procedures may confuse developers and applicants. This could cause non compliance, reputational damage or appeals. Report P108
Staffing: No immediate human resource implications are identified. Any extra resources for monitoring, governance and delivery will be considered under existing policies. Report P93
Financial: Up to 5% of the levy may cover administration. This is expected to be in the region of £1m over the period. Report P92
Climate: CIL may support district heating, parks and open spaces. The Charging Schedule also builds in sustainable construction and affordable housing delivery assumptions. Report P28, P100
Equalities: The full Equality Impact Appraisal identifies positive effects from health care, education, transport and green infrastructure funded by CIL. Report P102
Who and where
Developers of most developments over 100 sqm and any new dwelling Report P5, P49
Developers of purpose built student accommodation, at £150 per sqm Report P8
Qualifying social housing developments that remain social housing for at least 7 years Report P23, P29
Residents and communities in all wards Report P14, P109
People using schools, parks, roads, community facilities and health facilities Report P99, P101
Planning, development, finance, legal and technical officers Report P13, P89
Timeline
Summer 2022: Executive resolved to proceed with CIL. Report P2
18 July 2025: Draft Charging Schedule submitted for independent Examination. Report P2, P57
22 October 2025: Examination concluded and the Examiner's Report received. Report P3, P80
4 November 2025: Executive accepted the modifications and recommended Council adoption. Report P1
Following a Council decision: Statutory 6 week judicial review period for a challenge. Report P81
1 February 2026: Proposed CIL implementation date, subject to Council adoption. Report P42, P81
future Executive: Further report on spending of CIL receipts. Report P46
Plain English for the jargon
Community Infrastructure Levy: A charge on most new development that helps fund infrastructure. [P48] [P49]
Charging Schedule: The document setting CIL rates and the rules for liability and payment. [P16] [P24]
Independent Examiner: The independent person who checks legal compliance, consultation and development viability. [P52] [P57]
Section 106 agreement: A planning obligation used mainly for site specific mitigation and affordable housing. [P7] [P48]
Instalment policy: The published rules for paying CIL in stages. [P24] [P64]
Neighbourhood Fund: The part of CIL receipts that must be spent in the local area. [P14]
Viability: Whether a development can bear required costs and remain financially feasible. [P51]
Judicial review: A High Court challenge to the legality of a decision. [P10]
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item167
Resolved
Resolved (unanimously): That Executive i) Accepts the outcomes of the independent Examiner’s Report (Annex B of the report), including modifications proposed by the Examiner to ensure the (CIL) and proposed Charging Schedule can be soundly implemented. Reason: To ensure the Charging Schedule is legally compliant, robust, and capable of being implemented effectively, in line with the recommendations of the independent Examiner and national planning guidance. ii) Recommends to Council that the draft CIL Charging Schedule be approved as set out in Annex A as modified by the Examiner as set out in Annex B of the report. Reason: To allow the CIL Schedule to be legally adopted and implemented. iii) Recommends that the implementation date for the Community Infrastructure Levy will take effect from 1 February 2026. Reason: To agree to set a CIL implementation date that supports adequate preparation of internal systems and resources. iv) Delegates authority to the Director of City Development to review the instalment policy and make any necessary further minor editorial changes to the Charging Schedule or a change to the implementation date, if necessary. v) Delegates authority to the Director for Environment and Regulatory Services to agree publishing and necessary documentation for the introduction of CIL. Reason: To enable timely and efficient progression of the CIL adoption process, ensuring operational readiness, sound implementation and regular monitoring. vi) Notes that a further report regarding the spending of CIL will be brought to a future Executive for consideration. Reason: To allow Executive to consider how to spend the CIL monies received.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Meeting: Executive Meeting date: 4 November 2025 Report of: Garry Taylor, Director of City Development Portfolio of: Councillor Lomas, Executive Member for Finance, Performance, Major Projects, Human Rights, Equality and Inclusion
Decision Report: Community Infrastructure Levy Subject of Report 1. Executive in Summer 2022 resolved to proceed with a Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) as a charging mechanism for the delivery of associated infrastructure resulting from development. Subsequently, a number of consultations on the CIL Draft Charging Schedule have taken place with the final draft version submitted for independent Examination on 18 July 2025.
2. Examination concluded on 22 October 2025 with receipt of the Examiner’s Report, wherein it concluded that “the draft City of York Community Infrastructure Levy Charging Schedule, subject to the making of the modifications… satisfies the drafting requirements and I therefore recommend that the draft Charging Schedule be approved.”
3. This report considers the outcomes of the Examination and how to proceed with implementation of the Community Infrastructure Levy.
Benefits and Challenges 4. CIL provides a consistent, non-negotiable charge per square metre on most developments over 100 sqm or any new dwelling. This will capture developments that currently do not contribute to infrastructure delivery where they are either ineligible for making Section 106 contributions or are not sufficiently meaningful to deliver an infrastructure project. It is the cumulative impact of these sites that have a consequential impact on the city’s social, health and transport infrastructure, which CIL can address through capturing funding contributions toward essential infrastructure improvements. 5. The introduction of a CIL Charging Schedule provides a predictable and transparent approach for developers by being clear and upfront in relation to what they will be expected to pay. It should lead to early discussions in relation to ensuring scheme viability as well as simplifying the process.
6. For the Council, it also means that we can plan infrastructure investment more effectively with a clearer understanding of future income. CIL funds can be allocated to strategic or local infrastructure priorities without being tied to the development site, supporting delivery of the Council’s long-term growth and infrastructure planning. Unlike Section 106 agreements, CIL enables the Council to pool contributions and fund infrastructure across the city, rather than being limited to site-specific mitigation.
7. The CIL will continue to operate alongside Section 106 agreements but should streamline the process of complex negotiations. Section 106 agreements will focus on on-site or site-specific mitigation (particularly for the large strategic sites and/or where affordable housing is necessary) tied to the development, while CIL handles broader infrastructure needs.
8. The CIL Examination has provided an independent review of the process undertaken and found that subject to proposed modifications, the schedule is proportionate and a viable approach by which to proceed. The Examiner accepted the levy rate for purpose built student accomodation (PBSA) at £150 per sqm for but has proposed two modifications to the draft Schedule: £0 rating all strategic sites Reducing the residential rate from £150 to £75 per sqm.
9. The revised draft CIL Charging Schedule proposed by the Examiner reflects his consideration of the updated viability evidence, including consideration of a general uplift in build costs, and evidence presented at Examination. The modifications are seen as necessary to set rate charges that are proportionate and viable.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.